The Impact of Innovative Behavior by Different Pay Contacts: An Experiment Evidence
Ya-hui ZHANG,Di-fang WAN,Lei-ming FU,Xiang-ru CHEN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13587/j.cnki.jieem.2015.02.006
2015-01-01
Abstract:Sustaining innovation is very important for an enterpriseu0027s development. However, innovation is a special activity with high degree of uncertainty, requiring long-term investment, and having negative impact on the enterpriseu0027s short-term performance. For these reasons, the career-concerned managers are reluctant to invest in innovation activities. This phenomenon is known as managerial myopia. Obviously, the managerial myopia behavior would reduce the managersu0027 willingness for innovation. Thus, it is an urgent and core issue to design a reasonable pay system that encourages managers for more innovation. In this paper, we used the experiment method to test the relationship between manager innovation and three different compensation contracts, including short-term contract, long-term contract and termination contract. In each contract, we designed a cocktail experiment with 20 periods. Results show that comparing with short-term contracts and termination contracts, of long-term contracts has a significantly better performance. It is easier for experiment subjects under the long-term contracts to find the optimal operating region in the final period. The baru0027s benefit in the last period and the maximum benefit of each period are significantly higher than that of the other two contracts.(2) After analyzing the innovation process under different contracts, we found that comparing with short-term contracts and termination contracts, subjects under the long-term contracts invest more in innovation. Specifically, in the first 10 periods they are more likely to run the bar under the non-given location(T spot). The average standard deviation of three successive terms and the barsu0027 profit in each period are significantly higher than those of the other two contracts.(3) Finally, by comparing the average profit of bars under different contracts, we find that the barsu0027 profit under long-term contract is significantly higher than that of the other two contracts.(4) The above results are still robust after considering the experimentersu0027 risk preferences.This paper shows that combing the tolerance for early failure with the reward for long-term success is effective in motivating innovation. Thus, long-term stock options or putting higher weight in long-term payment would effectively motivate managersu0027 innovation.