Right Contract for Right Workers? Incentive Contracts for Short-term and Long-term Employees

Wei Chi,Tracy Xiao Liu,Qing Ye,Xiaoye Qian

2015-01-01

Abstract:This study examines a principal’s incentive contract choice and wage offers, and agent effort in the case of long-term and short-term employment relationships. The study is motivated by the observation made from a unique dataset collected by the World Bank and the National Bureau of Statistics of China based on the survey of 12,400 manufacturing firms in 120 cities in China: companies offer different pay contracts to regular and temporary workers. Prominent contract choices include: an explicit incentive contract such as piece-rate; an implicit incentive contract, for example, “fixed wage+bonus”; and finally a trust contract such as “fixed wage only”. We propose a theoretical model to show a principal’s contract choice, wage offers, and agent effort in long-term and short-term relationships. Using a real-effort laboratory experiment, we find that piece-rate has the strongest incentive effect on short-term agents’ effort and is dominantly chosen by principals. Nevertheless, the bonus contract works almost as well as piece-rate for long-term agents. In addition, we find that the effect of the bonus contract on effort is mainly driven by the second-stage bonus, suggesting that fixed payment alone cannot be an effective mechanism to improve worker performance.