Abstract:Background : COVID-19 had a major global impact on education, prompting concerns about its unequal effects and some impetus to reboot equity strategies. Yet, policy processes exhibit major gaps between such expectations and outcomes, and similar inequalities endured for decades before the pandemic. Our objective is to establish how education researchers, drawing on policy concepts and theories, explain and seek to address this problem. Methods : A qualitative systematic review (2020-21), to identify peer reviewed research and commentary articles on education, equity, and policymaking, in specialist and general databases (ERIC, Web of Science, Scopus, Cochrane/ Social Systems Evidence). We did not apply additional quality measures. We used an immersive and inductive approach to identify key themes. We use these texts to produce a general narrative and explore how policy theory articles inform it. Results : 140 texts (109 articles included; 31 texts snowballed) provide a non-trivial reference to policymaking. Limiting inclusion to English-language produced a bias towards Global North articles. Our comparison with a review of health equity research highlights distinctive elements in education. First, education equity is ambiguous and contested, with no settled global definition or agenda (although some countries and international organisations have disproportionate influence). Second, researchers critique ‘neoliberal’ approaches that dominate policymaking at the expense of ‘social justice’. Third, more studies provide ‘bottom-up’ analysis of ‘implementation gaps’. Fourth, more studies relate inequity to ineffective policymaking to address marginalised groups. Conclusions : Few studies use policy theories to explain policymaking, but there is an education-specific literature performing a similar role. Compared to health research, there is more use of critical policy analysis to reflect on power and less focus on technical design issues. There is high certainty that current neoliberal policies are failing, but low certainty about how to challenge them successfully.

Investigating Ten Years of Equity Policy in Australian Higher Education

Analysis of equity groups in higher education 1991-2002

Equity and Affirmative Action:Probing into the Policies and Strategies for Educational Balanced development in India

Student access to higher education through alternative pathways and differences by equity group and discipline

Influence of entry pathway and equity group status on retention and the student experience in higher education

From equity to excellence: reforming Australia’s national framework to create new forms of success

HIGHER EDUCATION EXPANSION,ABILITY HETEROGENEITY AND RETURN TO HIGHER EDUCATION---Evidences from CGSS

Enhanced use of educational accountability data to monitor educational progress of Australian students with focus on Indigenous students

Advancing Educational Equity Research, Policy, and Practice

Career guidance, school experiences and the university participation of young people from equity groups

Three decades of misrecognition: defining people with disability in Australian higher education policy

A Study on the Equity and Efficiency of Area Higher Education in China from 1990 to 2000

Unpacking equity. Educational equity in secondary analyses of international large-scale assessments: A systematic review

Using Aptitude Testing to Diversify Higher Education Intake – an Australian Case Study

Calling out Racism in University Classrooms: The Ongoing Need for Indigenisation of the Curriculum to Support Indigenous Student Completion Rates

Diversity in Australian Higher Education: an Empirical Analysis

Monitoring the Pathways and Outcomes of People from Disadvantaged Backgrounds and Graduate Groups

The future of education equity policy in a COVID-19 world: a qualitative systematic review of lessons from education policymaking

Equity in student finance: Cross-UK comparisons

Australia: The Changing Academic Profession - An Encapsulation

Evaluating local primary health care actions to address health inequities: analysis of Australia's Primary Health Networks