The Accuracy of Accounting Estimates,Consensus Information and Individual Investors' Decisions

Zhang Jixun,Zhang Lixia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2012.03.012
2012-01-01
Abstract:Accounting information plays a very important role in the process of investors' decision-making and its quality directly determines investors' judgments and decisions,in turn,accounting information is also very essential for the healthy operation of capital market.To ensure the quality of accounting information,especially the relevance of accounting information,the accounting principles and financial accounting standards allow the information preparers make reasonable estimates of uncertain items,however,accounting estimates also provide the latitude for managers' earning management.This paper investigates whether the ex post disclosure of the accuracy of accounting estimates can help individual investors make proper judgments and decisions by employing an experimental method.According to attribution theory,individuals are more likely attribute the positive outcome to external reasons when the positive outcome is from the persons other than themselves.The experiment results show that:(1) although individual investors can make different investment-related judgments between accurate and inaccurate accounting estimates,they can't identify the proper reasons for the accurate accounting estimates;(2) only aided with the industry con-sensus information,can this mechanism for the ex post disclosure of the accuracy of accounting estimates work as intended,namely only with the both effects,can individual investors correctly recognize the reasons for the accuracy of accounting estimates,attribute the accuracy of accounting estimates to accurate causes,and make proper judgments and decisions;(3) This paper also finds and uncovers the specific process for individual investors to make investment judgments and decisions.Specially,investors attribute the accuracy of accounting estimate to different reasons.Investors' attributions influence their appraisal of managements,their appraisal of managements influence their P/E ratio judgments,and in turn,the P/E ratio judgments influence investors' investment willing.Our research results have implications for accounting standards setters who are considering of the control mechanism of managers' earning manage-ment behaviors by the opportunity accounting estimates.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?