More on Ten Critiques: Guo Moruo's Intentions and His Ideas on Pre-Qin Scholarship

QI Xuemin
2007-01-01
Historical Research
Abstract:Ten Critiques (ten treatises on pre-Qin society and scholarship) was Guo Moruo's most important historical production during the War of Resistance against Japanese Aggression. It is academically significant to re-examine Guo's intention in writing these treatises, and based on this, to clarify his ideas on the basic principles of academic research and judge their academic achievement. These papers were meant not only as a defiance of the dictatorial rule of the Nationalists but also as a response to his fellow Marxist historians. Holding views on the pre-Qin philosophers that differed in part from those of other Marxist historians, Guo had published an article in The Masses criticizing the view that took Mo Zi as a "representative of the revolution of artisans and peasants." Marxist historians and scholars at Yan'an disagreed with Guo and wrote critical articles that also appeared in The Masses. Guo felt so uneasy about the criticism from his comrades that he made a systemic scrutiny of pre-Qin society and scholarship as a reply to his critics. Ten Critiques presents us with a perfect example of the principle of seeking truth from the facts in academic research. Its achievement in historiography and intellectual significance must be understood in the specific context of the time when Guo was writing.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?