Towards a Jurisprudence of Legislators--A Reflective Look at Contemporary Jurisprudence against the Backdrop of Law Transplantation

JiangShigong

2005-01-01

Social Sciences in China

Abstract:This paper examines the internal logic of the development of different intellectual trends in jurisprudence over the past two decades, from Marxist jurisprudence to theories of legal culture and legal modernization, in the context of legal transplant and the transformation of modern states. These dominant trends all take the position of “stateless law.” They are not only the product of the political ideology of legal transplant, but also of the professional ideology of the legal community. These schools of thought may be called the jurisprudence of jurists, as they are so closely related with law researchers' self-identity. In reflecting on the methodological pitfalls such jurisprudence encounters in dealing with relations between law and the state, I explore criticism of the dominant trends by pragmatic jurisprudence, a marginal theory in jurisprudence, and the tension that arises from this between localist methodologies and localist political positions. Based on this, I propose a “jurisprudence of law-makers” with a view to re-focusing jurisprudence on state and politics in a boarder theoretical context, so as to integrate the “jurisprudence of jurists” in a technical sense, and consider the theoretical questions facing China in its transformation as a national and civilized state.