Abstract:This study compares the two-year impact factor (JIF2), JIF2 without journal self-citation (JIF2 noJSC), five-year impact factor (JIF5), eigenfactor score and article influence score (AIS) and investigates their relative changes with time. JIF2 increased faster than JIF5 overall. The relative change between JIF2 and JIF noJSC shows that the control of JCR over journal self-citation is effective to some extent. JIF5 is more discriminative than JIF2. The correlation between JIF5 and AIS is stronger than that between JIF5 and the eigenfactor score. The relative change in journal rank according to different indicators varies with the ratio of the indicators and can be up to 60 % of the number of journals in a subject category. There is subject category discrepancy in the average AIS and its change over time. Through the screening of journals according to variations in the ratio of JIF2 to JIF5 for journals in individual subject categories, we found that journals in the same subject categories can have considerably different citation patterns. To provide a fair comparison of journals in individual subject categories, we argue that it is better to replace JIF2 with the ready-made JIF5 when ranking journals. (C) 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Empirical Analysis of the Law of Subject Distribution and Transformation of Scholar Communication Behavior Based on JCR (Science Edition)

Analysis of the Influence of Library and Information Science Journals Based on JCR indicators

An Analysis of the International Academic Influence of Academic Journals in China over the Three Decades Since Reform and Opening Up

Research and Analysis on JCR Bibliometrics Index from 2005 to 2009

Relation Analysis of Chinese Academic Journal Evaluation based on Citation analysis——with Data from Chinese Journal Citation Reports(Expanded edition)

A Study on Subject Bibliometrics and Evaluation of JCR' Indicators——Example as JCR(Social Sciences Edition)

Evaluation on Chinese Scholarly Journal-by Subject Field

Internet Transmission Analysis on Journal of Northwest University (natural Science Edition) Based on CNKI

Empirical Research on Long-term Trend and Impact Factor of Scientific Journal Literature——Based on the Journal Citation Data of 4 Disciplines During 30 Years

Analyses of the Authors in the Articles of Information Science in China in the Past 30 Years

A scientometrics analysis on the disciplinary characteristics of Chinese science publications

Factors of Influence Archival Science Journal Articles Highly Cited by Quantitative Research:Based on SPSS Statistical Analysis

Joint Behaviors of Submission and Citation-Based Study on Temporal Variation of Journal Impact Factor

Empirical Analysis of Scholar Communication Behavior Based on ResearchGate--Case Study of Beijing Normal University

The Distribution Models of Bibliometrics Indicators Based on JCR Social Science Edition and Its Enlightenment——Takes Economics,Management,Information Science & Library Science as Example

Comparing study of three impact factors of journals in six subjects

An Analysis on Academic Influences of Papers Published in the Social Sciences Edition of Academic Journal of Xi'an Jiaotong University

A Comparison among Citation-Based Journal Indicators and Their Relative Changes with Time

Research on the Author Distribution of Academic Information on the Internet

A Longitudinal Analysis of Citation Distribution Breadth for Chinese Scholars

Analysis about Research Activity and Influence of Authors in China based on Citation Relationship