Abstract:We previously reported the performance of four color difference equations around the CIE 1978 blue color center (NCSU-B1) using various statistical measures [1,2]. In this study we employed the standardized residual sum of squares (STRESS) [3] index to test the performance of twelve colordifference formulae using two experimental NCSU datasets. The first dataset (NCSU-B1) included 66 sample pairs around the CIE 1978 blue color center and the second dataset (NCSU-2) contained 69 sample pairs around 13 color centers [4]. In the first dataset 26 observers made a total of 5148 assessments of sample pairs with small color differences (ΔE*ab<5) while the second dataset involved 20,700 assessments by 100 observers from four different geographical regions of the world (25 in each region). Each pair in both sets was assessed by each color normal observer in three separate sittings on separate days and the average of assessments was calculated. For the samples in the first dataset a custom AATCC standard gray scale was employed to assess the magnitude of difference between colored samples. A third-degree polynomial equation was used to convert gray scale ratings to visual differences (ΔV). In the second study a novel perceptually linear gray scale was developed and a linear function was used to obtain visual differences. Based on the analysis of STRESS index results the DIN99d equation gave the best results for both datasets, and the CIELAB equation the worst.

Assessing colour differences with different magnitudes

Evaluation of Colour-difference Formulae for Different Colour-difference Magnitudes

Colour‐difference Evaluation Using CRT Colours. Part I: Data Gathering and Testing Colour Difference Formulae

Evaluation of Very Large Colour Difference Based on Object Surface Colours

Verification of CIEDE2000 using industrial data

A Colour-Difference Formula for Assessing Large Colour Differences

A Parametric Colour Difference Equation to Evaluate Colour Difference Magnitude Effect for Gapless Printed Stimuli

Checking Recent Colour-Difference Formulas with a Dataset of Metallic Samples and Just Noticeable Colour-Difference Assessments.

Performance Testing of Ciede2000 Color-Difference Formula Using Crt Colors

Investigation of texture effect on visual colour difference evaluation

Study of Color Discrimination Threshold Using CRT Display. Part Ⅱ : Evaluation of Classical Color-Difference Formulae

Color Difference Evaluation for Wide-Color-gamut Displays.

Investigation of Parametric Colour Difference on Physical Size Effect for Sample Pairs with Separation

Evaluation of Performance of Twelve Color-Difference Formulae Using Two NCSU Experimental Datasets.

The CIEDE2000 color-difference formula: Implementation notes, supplementary test data, and mathematical observations

A Comparison of the Colour Differences Computed Using the CIE94, CMC(l:c) and BFD(l:c) Formulae

The development of the CIE 2000 colour-difference formula: CIEDE2000

A Parametric Colour-difference Study on the Separation and CMF Effects.

Assessing Colour Differences under a Wide Range of Luminance Levels Using Surface and Display Colours

Comparing Different Colour Discrimination Data Sets

A Comprehensive Test of Colour‐difference Formulae and Uniform Colour Spaces Using Available Visual Datasets