Comparison of Two Methods of Determining Index Weight During Groundwater Quality Assessment

吴东杰,王金生,丁爱中

2006-01-01

Abstract:The general methods of assessing groundwater quality are fuzzy theory and gray system theory.With the same theory,however,the assessment results would be different from each other if different methods of determining the index weight are adopted during the assessment.Aiming at comparing the end-begin ratio method with the clustering weight method,this paper adopts the two methods to determine the index weight during the groundwater quality assessment by the comprehensive fuzzy assessment theory.Moreover,the exceeding-standard method and the standard method recommended by GB/T 14848-93 "The Quality Standard of Groundwater" has also been adopted as verification.Thirty-one groundwater samples within Yuncheng,Shanxi province are used as the examples,and eleven indices(pH,NH~+-4、Fe~(3+)、Cl~-、SO~(2-)-4、NO~--3、NO~--2、F~-、PO~--4、total hardness,degree of mineralization) are chosen and used to assess the quality of the groundwater samples.Based on the analysis and comparision of the assessment results,it can be concluded that the end-begin ratio method is not reliable for the groundwater quality assessment,however,the clustering weight method is relatively reasonable to assess the groundwater quality.