Analysis on Difference of Evaluation Results of Surface Water Quality in Dalate Qi

许士国,冯峰
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-0860.2007.11.004
2007-01-01
Abstract:A comparison is made on four evaluation results of the surface water quality herein,in which the results from both the variable fuzzy assessment method and the identification index method are more consistent,but the evaluation result from the grey clustering method has a larger discrepancy with those from the two methods mentioned above.Based on the analysis of the discrepancy,it is considered that there are some inapplicabilities in both the determination of the clustering weight and the calculation of the whiteness function during the application of the grey clustering method,which leads to some distortions of the part of the indexes,and then results in the inconsequence of the evaluation result concerned.As only the poorest classification of water quality is considered in the method of single factor extreme value and the result is short of integrativity and scientificity,it is suggested that the method need no longer to be used.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?