Cost-effectiveness analysis of oral vs intravenous iron treatment for renal anemia patients

Kang-ning BI,Yong GU,Wen CHEN,Xiao-qiang DING,Jun XUE,Shu RONG,Bi-cheng LIU,Wen-hu LIU,Hui-lan LIU,Ling ZHANG,Zi-dong LIU,Min CHEN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/j.issn:1001-7097.2006.10.003
2006-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of intravenous and oral iron supplements in hemodialysis patients with chronic renal anemia.Methods Two hundred and thirty- five patients with renal anemia were enrolled and randomly divided into intravenous group(n=116) who received iron dextran injection and oral group (n=119) who received ferrous suecinate tablets.The dosage of iron dextran was calculated for each patient and was given during each hemodialysis session.After total dosage was finished,100 mg of maintenance dose was given periodically depending on the levels of ferritin and Hb.The oral group received ferrous succinate tablet equivalent to 200 mg element iron.Two hundred and twenty-six patients finished 26-week treatment and 113 patients in each group.HB and Hct were indexes to evaluate the efficacy of the treatment.The treatment cost included the direct medical costs in iron product,EPO,medical examination and adverse events,and indirect medical costs in traffic,nursing,nutriment and the loss of labor. Results The average treatment cost for each patient was 25 thousand yuan (RMB) and 24.1 thousand yuan (RMB) for intravenous and oral group respectively with no significant difference (P>0.05).The effective rates were 88.5% and 71.68% for intravenous and oral group respectively with significant difference (P<0.05).Therefore,average cost per patient for achieving effectiveness was 28.213 thousand yuan (RMB) and 33.683 thousand yuan (RMB) for intravenous and oral group respectively.Conclusions Intravenous iron therapy is more effective in the treatment of renal anemia.There is no significant difference in treatment cost between two groups.Therefore, intravenous iron dextran has greater cost-effectiveness than oral iron in renal anemia,and is worthy to be recommended to clinical application.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?