Why Is Wealth Gap between the Rich and Poor in Contemporary China Unjust?——From Relevant Statements in Marx's Critique of Gotha Programme

Duan Zhong-qiao
2013-01-01
Abstract:Wealth gap between the rich and poor is a major problem in contemporary China.However,Chinese Marxist scholars remain silent on the injustice of wealth gap.This phenomenon is caused by two reasons: First,some scholars misunderstand Marx's view of justice.They either believe Marx rejected and criticized justice,and ignore the fact that Marx spoke highly of a proletarian demand of justice,or believe justice or injustice depends for Marx on whether or not being correspondent with the mode of production,and fail to notice the normative content of Marx's concept of justice.Second,they are so restricted by the conception of exploitation being unjust that they cannot respond to the question of whether wealth gap is just.In fact,there contains a conception of justice different from the conception of exploitation being unjust in Marx's Critique of Gotha Programme: inequalities of income caused by nonselective accidental factors are unjust.This conception can shed light on understanding of the main causes of Chinese contemporary wealth gap,i.e.,different status,backgrounds or talents,and thus provide a new argument for the injustice of wealth gap in contemporary China.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?