Differences of middle school students' depressive symptoms development in gender, age and grade
Feng Zheng-zhi,Zhang Da-jun
2005-01-01
Abstract:Aim: To explore the differences of middle school student depressive symptoms in gender, age, and grade. Methods: Totally 2 634 junior and senior middle school students were randomly selected from 25 middle schools of Chongqing and Sichuan province in August 2004, including 1 298 boys and 1 336 girls, aged from 11 to 19 years. All middle school students were free from mental illnesses,and were willing to participate in the survey. (1) Depressive symptoms of middle school students were assessed by using Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) [21 items in total, rated with negative(0 score), mild (1 score), middle (2 scores) and serious (3 scores), totally 4 degrees according to the symptoms degrees.BDI:total scores ≤4, negative or extremely mild; 5-13 scores, moderate; 14-20 scores, middle; 21 scores or higher, serious] and Zung Self-Depression Scale (SDS) [SDS composed of 20 statement sentences and corresponding questions. Each item equal a corresponding symptom, rated with 1, 2, 3, 4 four degrees, circle with 1(never or seldom), or 2(sometimes), or 3(often), or 4(always) according to the fittest time frequencies of participants, and 10 items are scored with reaction. SDS: total scores ≤40, negative; 41-47 scores, mild or moderate; 48-55 scores, middle; 56 scores or higher,serious]. (2)F-test and t-test were used to compare the difference of measurement data. Results: All 1 115 middle school students with depressive symptoms entered the results analysis,and completed the questionnaire assessment. Positive depressive symptoms were signaled by satisfying the assessment criterions of both BDI and SDS at the same time (among 1 115 middle school students, junior middle school: 107 first year boys, 114 girls; 83 second year boys, 96 girls;86 third year boys,111 girls; Senior middle school students: 131 first year boys, 151 girls; 68 second year boys, 78 girls; 38 third year boys, 52 girls). (1)Comparison of middle school students' depressive degrees in different ages and grades: Grade 2 of junior middle school students and 13-year-old students had lower depressive degree than other grades and ages, and the depressive symptoms levels of other grades and ages increased along with their grades and age. Analysis of variance was done with the independent variable of grade and age, F separately scores with F (5, 1 114)=4.658, P < 0.01; F (6, 1 114)=3.047, P < 0.01. Main effects of middle school students' depressive symptoms in age and grades were illustrated. (2)Gender differences of middle school students' depressive degrees development in different grades:Grade 2 boys of junior middle school had the lowest depressive level,and depressive symptoms levels of other grades students increased along with their grades. Analysis of variance in boys'depressive symptoms levels were done with the independent variable of grade, F(5, 512)=1.072, P > 0.05; Analysis of variance in girls'depressive symptoms levels were done with the independent variable of grade, F(5,601)=2.886, P < 0.05. There were significant differences between boys and girls in first year of junior middle school and third year of senior middle school (P < 0.01). (3)Gender differences of middle school students' depressive degrees developmental characters in different ages: Depressive degrees of boys and girls increased along with their age(except for 13-year-old girls). There was significant difference between girls in different ages, F (5, 601)=2.434, P < 0.05. t test of boys and girls with all ages showed that the difference was significant between boys and girls at age 13, 14, 17 (t=3.462, 2.689, P < 0.01; t=2.223, P < 0.05), but it was not significant between other ages. Conclusion: (1)At the level of middle school students' depressive symptoms, 13 is the critical age, and Grade 2 of Junior middle school is the critical grade. (2)The girl depressive symptom levels increase along with their age and grades and remain significant main effects. (3)There are sharp gender differences at same age and grade.The depressive symptom levels of boys are more serious than those of girls.