Abstract:Reliable quantification of low-abundance proteins in complex proteomes is challenging largely owing to the limited number of spectra/peptides identified. In this study we developed a straightforward method to improve the quantitative accuracy and precision of proteins by strategically retrieving the less confident peptides that were previously filtered out using the standard target-decoy search strategy. The filtered-out MS/MS spectra matched to confidently-identified proteins were recovered, and the peptide-spectrum-match FDR were re-calculated and controlled at a confident level of FDR≤1%, while protein FDR maintained at ~1%. We evaluated the performance of this strategy in both spectral count- and ion current-based methods. >60% increase of total quantified spectra/peptides was respectively achieved for analyzing a spike-in sample set and a public dataset from CPTAC. Incorporating the peptide retrieval strategy significantly improved the quantitative accuracy and precision, especially for low-abundance proteins (e.g. one-hit proteins). Moreover, the capacity of confidently discovering significantly-altered proteins was also enhanced substantially, as demonstrated with two spike-in datasets. In summary, improved quantitative performance was achieved by this peptide recovery strategy without compromising confidence of protein identification, which can be readily implemented in a broad range of quantitative proteomics techniques including label-free or labeling approaches. SIGNIFICANCE:We hypothesize that more quantifiable spectra and peptides in a protein, even including less confident peptides, could help reduce variations and improve protein quantification. Hence the peptide retrieval strategy was developed and evaluated in two spike-in sample sets with different LC-MS/MS variations using both MS1- and MS2-based quantitative approach. The list of confidently identified proteins using the standard target-decoy search strategy was fixed and more spectra/peptides with less confidence matched to confident proteins were retrieved. However, the total peptide-spectrum-match false discovery rate (PSM FDR) after retrieval analysis was still controlled at a confident level of FDR≤1%. As expected, the penalty for occasionally incorporating incorrect peptide identifications is negligible by comparison with the improvements in quantitative performance. More quantifiable peptides, lower missing value rate, better quantitative accuracy and precision were significantly achieved for the same protein identifications by this simple strategy. This strategy is theoretically applicable for any quantitative approaches in proteomics and thereby provides more quantitative information, especially on low-abundance proteins.

Automatic validation of phosphopeptide identifications by the MS2/MS3 target-decoy search strategy.

A Three-Stage Search Strategy Combining Database Reduction and Retention Time Filtering to Improve the Sensitivity of Low-Input and Single-Cell Proteomic Analysis.

Target-decoy search strategy for increased confidence in large-scale protein identifications by mass spectrometry

Identification of Phosphopeptides with Unknown Cleavage Specificity by a De Novo Sequencing Assisted Database Search Strategy.

Increased confidence in large-scale phosphoproteomics data by complementary mass spectrometric techniques and matching of phosphopeptide data sets

pValid 2: A deep learning based validation method for peptide identification in shotgun proteomics with increased discriminating power

Comprehensive and Reliable Phosphorylation Site Mapping of Individual Phosphoproteins by Combination of Multiple Stage Mass Spectrometric Analysis with a Target-Decoy Database Search.

Improving Peptide Identification with Single-Stage Mass Spectrum Peaks.

PeaksDB: New Software for Substantially Improved Peptide Identification from Orbitrap ETD Mass Spectrometry

Enhancing peptide identification confidence by combining search methods.

A Novel Algorithm for Validating Peptide Identification from a Shotgun Proteomics Search Engine

Integrating de Novo Sequencing and Database Search for Peptide Identification

PEAKS DB: De Novo Sequencing Assisted Database Search for Sensitive and Accurate Peptide Identification.

Estimating the Efficiency of Phosphopeptide Identification by Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Using the entrapment sequence method as a standard to evaluate key steps of proteomics data analysis process

Analysis of human serum phosphopeptidome by a focused database searching strategy.

A peptide-retrieval strategy enables significant improvement of quantitative performance without compromising confidence of identification.

A Workflow of MS/MS Data Analysis to Maximize the Peptide Identification.

Classification filtering strategy to improve the coverage and sensitivity of phosphoproteome analysis.

Decoy methods for assessing false positives and false discovery rates in shotgun proteomics.

Optimization of Filtering Criterion for SEQUEST Database Searching to Improve Proteome Coverage in Shotgun Proteomics