Abstract:Understanding the statistical fluctuations of lattice observables over the gauge configurations is important both theoretically and practically. It provides a physical insight into tackling the famous signal-to-noise problem and the sign problem, and inspires new thoughts in developing methods to improve the signal of lattice calculations. Among many efforts, exploring the relationship between the real part and imaginary part of lattice numerical result is a new method to understand lattice signal and error, because both the real part and imaginary part come from the same sample of gauge field and their distributions on the gauge sample are related in principle. Specifically, by analyzing the distributions of the real part and imaginary part of quenched lattice two-point function with high statistics and non-zero momentum, this work proposes a possible quantitative formula connecting these two distributions as \begin{document}$R(x)=\displaystyle\int {\rm{d}}y S(y-x) \left[I(y) K(U_y)\right]$\end{document}, where \begin{document}$R(x)$\end{document} denotes the real-part distribution, \begin{document}$I(x)$\end{document} the imaginary-part distribution, \begin{document}$S(x)$\end{document} the underlying signal distribution and \begin{document}$K(U_x)$\end{document} a kernel function of the gauge field. This theoretical assumption has universal validity because the kernel function contains the gauge field information that determines all the distributions. The formula is numerically verified by calculating the non-trivial statistical correlations of the real part and the kernel-function-modified imaginary part under the further assumption of the kernel function. It is found that the most naïve guess of \begin{document}$K(U_x)=1$\end{document} does not work, which leads to no statistically significant correlation. Meanwhile, the assumption that \begin{document}$K(U_x)$\end{document} is only a sign function works well, giving rise to \begin{document}$\sim70\%$\end{document} correlation. Then, through the process of adding random distortions to the absolute values of the imaginary part, it is found that even a slight distortion, of around 1% could result in a significant reduction in the correlation between the real part and imaginary part down to less than 50% or lower. This essentially proves that the observed \begin{document}$\sim70\%$\end{document} correlation is highly non-trivial and the hypothesis that \begin{document}$K(U_x)$\end{document} is a sign function captures at least some of the physical mechanisms behind the scenes. Employing this correlation, the variance of lattice results can be improved by around 40%. It is not a significant improvement in practice; however, this study offers an innovative strategy to understand the source of statistical uncertainties in lattice QCD and to improve the signal-to-noise ratio in lattice calculation. Further research on the ability to use machine learning on various more accurate lattice data will hopefully give better instructions and constraint on the form of the kernel function.

The Sequential Empirical Bayes Method: An Adaptive Constrained-Curve Fitting Algorithm for Lattice QCD

An algorithm for obtaining reliable priors for constrained-curve fits

Empirical Baye's Method and Tests in Very Light Quark Range from the Overlap Lattice QCD

Lattice Calculation Of Baryonic Electromagnetic Form-Factors

Empirical Baye's Method and Roper Resonance State in Very Light Quark Region

Constrained curve fitting for semi-parametric models with radial basis function networks

Bayesian Inference for Contemporary Lattice Quantum Field Theory

Lattice QCD Beyond Ground States

A Bayesian approach to chiral extrapolations

Reconstructing lattice QCD spectral functions with stochastic pole expansion and Nevanlinna analytic continuation

Bayesian quantification of strongly interacting matter with color glass condensate initial conditions

Improved Semileptonic Form Factor Calculations in Lattice QCD

Quantum many-body calculations using body-centered cubic lattices

Chebyshev and Backus-Gilbert reconstruction for inclusive semileptonic $B_{(s)}$-meson decays from Lattice QCD

Bayesian quantification of strongly-interacting matter with color glass condensate initial conditions

Imaginary-part Distribution and Signal Improvement of Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Data

Spectral-function determination of complex electroweak amplitudes with lattice QCD

QCD in the chiral SU(3) limit from baryon masses on Lattice QCD ensembles

The Design of New Practical Constraints in Auxiliary-Field Quantum Monte Carlo

Two-nucleon S-wave interactions at the $SU(3)$ flavor-symmetric point with $m_{ud}\simeq m_s^{\rm phys}$: a first lattice QCD calculation with the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method