Abstract:Abstract Background Respect for patients’ autonomy is usually considered to be an important ethical principle in Western countries; privacy is one of the implications of such respect. Healthcare professionals frequently encounter ethical dilemmas during their practice. The past few decades have seen an increased use of courts to resolve intractable ethical dilemmas across both the developed and the developing world. However, Chinese and American bioethics differ largely due to the influence of Chinese Confucianism and Western religions, respectively, and there is a dearth of comparative studies that explore cases of ethical dilemmas between China and the United States. Methods This paper discusses four typical cases with significant social impact. First, it compares two cases concerning patient privacy: the “Shihezi University Hospital Case”, in which a patient was used as a clinical teaching object without her permission, and the “New York-Presbyterian Hospital Case”, in which the hospital allowed the filming of a patient’s treatment without his consent. Second, it compares two cases regarding patient autonomy and potentially life-saving medical procedures: the “Case of Ms. L”, concerning a cohabitant’s refusal to sign a consent form for a pregnant woman’s caesarean, and the “Case of Mrs. V”, concerning a hospital’s insistence upon a blood transfusion for a dissenting patient. This paper introduces the supporting and opposing views for each case and discusses their social impact. It then compares and analyses the differences between China and the United States from cultural and legislative perspectives. Conclusions Ethical dilemmas have often occurred in China due to the late development of bioethics. However, the presence of bioethics earlier in the US than in China has not spared the US of ethical dilemmas. This paper highlights lessons and inspiration from the cases for healthcare professionals and introduces readers to the role and weight of privacy and autonomy in China and in the US from the perspectives of different cultures, religions and laws.

On the Function Orientation and Systematic Construction of Chinese Hospital Ethics Committees

Discussion on the Development of Hospital Ethics Committee

Discussion on the current situation and existing problems of ethics committee in a new hospital

On Community Health Service System Ethics Construction

System Construction of Hospital Ethics Committee

Survey on the Function, Structure and Operation of Hospital Ethics Committees in Shanghai.

Evaluation on function and management of hospital ethics committees in Shanghai by health personnel

Contemplation of the methods on optimizing hospital ethics committees management model

Patient privacy and autonomy: a comparative analysis of cases of ethical dilemmas in China and the United States

Research on the construction of integrity ethics in contemporary Chinese hospitals

Survey on the ethics review in Shanghai Hospital Ethics Committee

Analysis on the Organization and Management of Thirteen Hospital Ethics Committees in Shanghai

Advice of Legislation about Ethic Committee of Hospital

Professionalizaiton of Hospital Chief Executives: International Experiences, Domestic Situation and Policy Recommendations

Analysis on the process of informed consent of medical researches involving human subjects in public hospitals in Shanghai

Discussion on the Operating Pattern and Regulatory mechanism of Ethics Committee in Our Country

Investigation on the Ethics Cognition of Medical Staff in Grade 3 Hospitals, Jiangsu

Current status and regulatory measures for the ethics committee of drug clinical trial institutions in China

Application and exploration of ethics review platform

Challenges for Ethics Committees in Biomedical Research Governance: Illustrations from China and Australia.

Construction of the Cultivation Platform of Scientific Research Ethics Values in Hospitals