Comparison of laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy for adult patients with duplex kidney

XU Ben,ZHANG Qian,XI Zhijun,XIAO Yunxiang,HE Zhisong,JIN Jie,ZHOU Liqun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13201/j.issn.1001-1420.2012.04.009

2012-01-01

Journal of Clinical Urology

Abstract:Objective:To compare the treatment outcome of laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy for duplex kidney in adults.Method:Clinical data of 32 cases of duplex kidney in adults were analysed retrospectively,of them 8 cases were male,24 cases were female.The age ranged from 18 to 77.They were divided into 2 groups.Open group consisted of 20 patients,and laparoscopic group consisted of 12 patients.In open group,there were 4 male and 16 female with the average age of 33.8 years old.In laparoscopic group,there were 4 male and 8 female with the average age of 43.8 years old.There were no significant differences in ages between groups.Result:No conversion to open surgery and no complication occurred in laparoscopic group.There were 2 complications(hemorrhage and urine leakage) in open group.Mean duration of operation was 165.3min for open group,the difference of pre-and post-operation hemoglobin was 20.3 g/L,the volume of first-day drainage was 106.8 ml,the time of drainage was 7.2 d and mean hospitalization was 10.1 d.In laparoscopic group,the figures were 261.4 min,13.7 g/L,43.8 ml,3.3 d and 6.9 d respectively.The differences of the figures were significant between the 2 groups(P<0.05).Conclusion:Partial nephrectomy is the initial option in the treatment of duplex kidney in adults.Laparoscopic has the benefits of slighter pain,mini-invasion,less blood loss and shorter recovery compared with open surgery.