Abstract:Objective To systemically evaluate the clinical recovery differences between beating heart surgery and arrested heart surgery during mitral valve replacement. Methods Using the Cochrane systematic review methods, we searched the Cochrane Controlled Trial Registers (CCTR) of the Cochrane Library, PubMed, EMBASE, CNKI and Wanfang databases concerning the comparison of clinical recovery of beating heart surgery and arrested heart surgery during mitral valve replacement from inception to December 2016. Two reviews independently selected studies and assessed the quality of the trials. Disagreements were resolved by discussion, in consultation with a third reviewer. Then, Meta-analysis was performed using RevMan 5.3 software. Results Seven original randomized controlled trial (RCT) investigated a total of 242 patients, of whom 116 received beating heart surgery and 126 received arrested heart surgery, whi ch met the inclusion criteria. Meta analysis results show that the frequency of defibrillation during operation [odds ratio (OR)=0.10, 95％CI (0.03, 0.29), P<0.05] and usage of vasoactive agents after operation [weighted mean differences (WMD)=-2.71, 95％CI (-3.10, -2.32), P<0.05] were less in beating heart surgery. In addition, the CPB time [WMD=-13.29, 95％CI(-21.97, -4.61), P=0.003] and length of ICU stay [WMD=-7.73, 95％CI(-10.92, -4.54), P<0.05] were shorter in beating heart surgery, as compared to the arrested heart surgery. However, there were no significant differences between the two groups in operative time [WMD=-9.69, 95％CI(-26.15, 6.78), P=0.25], mechanical ventilation time [WMD =-4.39, 95％CI(-10.01, 1.23), P=0.13], post-operatively hospital stay [WMD=-1.12, 95％CI(-2.24, 0.01), P=0.05] and death toll during hospital stay [OR=2.48, 95％CI (0.34, 18.11), P=0.37]. Conclusions During mitral valve replacement, the clinical recovery of beating heart surgery is better than recovery of arrested heart surgery in the frequency of defibrillation, usage of vasoactive agents after operation, CPB time and length of ICU stay. But the operative time, mechanical ventilation time, post-operatively hospital stay and death toll during hospital stay did not show significant differences between the two groups.

The Application of Antegrade/Retrograde Cardioplegia Combined with Warm Blood Retrograde Before Releasing Aortic Cross-Clamp in Double Valve Replacement

Blood Conservation Strategies in Cardiac Valve Replacement

Blood conservation strategies in cardiac valve replacement: A retrospective analysis of 1645 patients.

Intraoperative autologous based blood conservation strategies in mitral valve replacement

Valve Replacement for Valvular Heart Disease with Giant Left Ventricle.

Discussion on Valve Re-Operative Cases after Cardiac Valve Replacement

The clinical Research on Different Retrograde Perfusion Pressure through Coronary Sinus for Myocardial Protection

Clinical observation on the myocardial protective effect of a combination method of crystalloid and blood cardioplegic solution during open heart surgery

Effects of agkistrodon hemocoagulase on coagulation function in patients undergoing cardiac valve replacement with cardiopulmonary bypass

Effects of remote ischemic preconditioning on acute myocardial injury in patients undergoing valve replacement

Retrograde Inferior Vena Caval Perfusion for Total Aortic Arch Replacement Surgery: a Randomized Pilot Study

Antegrade Versus Retrograde Cerebral Perfusion in Relation to Postoperative Complications Following Aortic Arch Surgery for Acute Aortic Dissection Type A

Comparison of a coronary bypass surgery using a combination of both on-pump beating heart and cardioplegic arrest with conventional coronary bypass surgery using cardioplegic arrest on-pump

Results of surgical treatment in valve disease in 70 patients

Can heartbeat recovery be improved with terminal non-cardioplegic warm blood perfusion prior to aortic unclamping in single-clamp technique coronary artery bypass surgery? A randomized controlled trial

The Clinical Recovery of Beating Heart Versus Arrested Heart Techniques for Mitral Valve Replacement Surgery: a Meta-analysis

Cardiac and renal responses to cross-clamping of the descending thoracic aorta

Aortic valve replacement in elderly patients:Surgical risk and outcome

Studies on the Myocardial Protective Effects of Antegrade Cold Crystalloid and Warm Blood Cardioplegia Administration

The Analysis of Anterolateral Minithoracotomy Versus Partial Upper Hemisternotomy in Minimally Invasive Dual Mitral and Aortic Valve Replacement

Influence of beating and arrested heart surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass on prostaglandins