Moral Confucianism or Political Confucianism? Old Mission of A New State or New Mission of An Old State: Some Reflections on the Revival of Confucianism
Tongdong Bai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-2938.2010.11.001
2010-01-01
Abstract:The twentieth-century New Confucians,in their efforts to revive,is focused on its mental and moral(xinxing)aspects.The problem of this focus is twofold.On the one hand,they preserve too much of Confucianism by upholding it as the one and only moral principle in an already pluralistic society.On the other hand,they yield too much ground to the West in that they fully accept the superiority of Western science and democracy.I want to argue for a new focus on the political dimension of Confucianism.Among those who have attended to this focus,I will be critical of Jiang Qing for the following reasons.He,too,upholds the transcendence and universality of Confucian moral principle.His political idea is based upon a situational version of Confucianism(offered by gongyang scholars in the Han Dynasty) which was specifically designed for the time in which it occurred,and he takes this version as fundamental to Confucianism,and dogmatizes it,and makes it sacred.His and some others'efforts assume a culture-specific point of view,thus depriving Confucian political thinking of its universal appeal.I wish to argue that what we should preserve is the philosophical spirit of Confucianism,and we should develop a new Confucian political theory that takes into account the new situations of contemporary world and the political problems that are facing all modern states.By doing so,we can develop a new mission from the old state,rather than imposing the old mission on a new state.