Abstract:Research highlights ▶ Laves phase precipitates in steel X12 during short-term exposure of 204 h at 650 °C and 400 h at 600 °C. ▶ Laves phase has stacking faults in it and the SAED patterns of it are characteristic of streaked. ▶ There are two mechanisms of the nucleation and growth for Laves phase present in steel X12. ▶ The size and the number of Laves phase are strongly dependent on temperature, but slightly on stress. ▶ The formation of Laves phase in steel X12 is a thermodynamically possible process. Abstract Precipitation behavior of Laves phase in steel X12CrMoWVNbN10-1-1 during short-term (≤400 h) creep exposure was investigated using a transmission electron microscope (TEM) and an ultra high resolution thermal field emission scanning electron microscope (UHR-FESEM). The results demonstrate that Laves phase precipitates are detected in the creep specimens exposed for such a short-term of 400 h at 600 °C and 204 h at 650 °C. Stacking faults are observed in them and the selected area electron diffraction patterns of the phase are characteristic of streaked. There are two mechanisms of the nucleation and growth for Laves phase, one of which is that Laves phases occur alone on martensite lath boundaries and they are coherent with a grain but grow into the adjacent grain which has no rational orientation relationship with them. The other one is that Laves phases are formed in the regions adjacent to M 23 C 6 particles, and then they grow at the expense of the Cr-rich M 23 C 6 carbides in close vicinity. It is established that the former one is the dominant formation mechanism for Laves phase in steel X12CrMoWVNbN10-1-1. Laves phases prefer to locate on the prior austenite grain boundaries and the martensite lath boundaries. The mean diameter and the number density of the phase show significant change with temperature, but slightly change with stress. Moreover, it is proved that the formation of Laves phase in this steel is a thermodynamically possible process. The nucleation process has not finished after heat-treatment and the number of nuclei for Laves phase formed in the steel decreases with raising the temperature. Keywords Laves phase Precipitation behavior X12CrMoWVNbN10-1-1 10% Cr steels Short-term creep Mean diameter 1 Introduction X12CrMoWVNbN10-1-1 (COST steel E [1] , hereby, it will be referred as X12) is recognized as a mature material that is widely used for rotor steel of ultra-supercritical steam turbines. It was modified from 9Cr–1Mo–V–Nb steel (ASME SA213-T91 [2] ) by adding W to increase creep strength and increasing Cr content for better oxidation resistance. The steel is characterized by tempered martensite matrix and strengthened by solution hardening of such elements as Mo, W and by precipitation hardening of such phases as M 23 C 6 (M: Cr, Fe, Mo, W, etc.) type carbides and MX (M: V, Nb, etc. and X: C, N) type carbonitrides [3–9] . The degradation of creep properties of the steel during long-term exposure is generally accompanied by ripening of M 23 C 6 carbides and precipitation of new phases such as Laves phase and Z phase. Precipitation of Laves phase is unavoidable for W and Mo alloyed X12 steel during ageing or creep exposure at temperatures around 600 °C because it is thermodynamically stable. The effect of the Laves phase precipitation on long-term creep strength has been debated for long. Laves phase is generally considered detrimental for the creep strength of 9–12% Cr steels because the precipitation of Laves phase promotes the depletion of Mo and W from solid solution [10–12] . On the other hand, they can contribute to the increase of the creep strength by precipitation hardening under certain circumstances [13] . Recently, it is generally agreed that the fine Laves phase may contribute to the creep strength [13–16] . In this case, the coarsening of Laves phase should be controlled during high-temperature exposure to maintain a good creep resistance. So far, the precipitation behavior of Laves phase in these steels including steel X12 has been extensively studied for long-term (>1000 h) creep exposure [3–20] , but very limitedly for short-term (200–400 h) creep, showing the behavior at the early stage of creep. However, it is difficult to control the coarsening of Laves phase without complete understanding on its behavior at the early stage. The aim of the present work is to investigate the precipitation behavior of Laves phase in X12 during short-time (≤400 h) creep, focusing on its microstructure evolution, the mechanism of its nucleation and growth and quantification of the particles. The role of stress and temperature on the precipitation of Laves phase is discussed. 2 Materials and experimental methods In present study, the testing material was cut from a steam turbine rotor made of a forged steel X12 produced by SAAR in Germany. The material was austenitized at 1050 °C for 21.5 h and then cooled in oil, followed by tempering at 570 °C for 21 h in the first step and at 690 °C for 23 h in the second step. The nominal composition is listed in Table 1 . Particle-size measurements on Laves phase were carried out on samples crept at 600 °C/650 °C for 400 h under different stresses ( Table 2 ). All measurements were made on the gauge area. Laves phase in the steel can be successfully identified against the matrix as bright precipitates via scanning electron microscope under backscattered electron (SEM-BSE) mode due to the large Z contrast of 28% between Laves phase and the matrix in the steel X12 [15] . The technique of quantification of Laves phase in various samples is the same as the method reported in Ref 16. Samples were prepared by grinding, polishing, and slight etching in Villella's etching solution. SEM was performed at 15 kV on an ultra high resolution thermal field emission scanning electron microscope (UHR-FESEM) JSM-7600F at a displayed magnification of 25,000×. 20 micrographs per specimen were recorded. Both secondary electron (SE) and backscattered electron (BSE) images consisting of 1280 × 962 pixels were taken from each area. The Image-Pro Plus software [17] was used for image analysis. To ensure a minimal systematic error [15,16] , the quantification of the particle-size smaller than approximately 10 pixels was deleted from the results. Hence, Laves phase particles with a diameter smaller than 40 nm are not included in this study. The area fraction and the number of Laves phase particles were evaluated on the basis of information from the mentioned 20 areas for each specimen. The detailed microstructure of Laves phase was observed by using a conventional transmission electron microscope (JSM-2010) operating at 200 kV. 3 Results and discussion In the as-received condition, there are only M 23 C 6 and MX present in steel X12, and no Laves phase has been detected. However, in addition to M 23 C 6 and MX, Laves phase has been found in the creep specimens after exposure at 650 °C for 204.7 h and at 600 °C for 400 h, as shown in Figs. 1 and 2 . From the bright-field images ( Figs. 1(a) and 2(a) ) and the dark-field images ( Figs. 1(b) and 2(b) ), it can be observed that Laves phase precipitates have irregular shape and locate along the martensite lath boundaries or subgrain boundaries. The stacking faults within the Laves phases could be observed in both tested specimens. The particles of Laves phase formed during creep at 650 °C are larger than those precipitated at 600 °C. In Fig. 1 (a), B, C and D precipitates are also identified as Laves phase. They are clustering along the lath boundary, which is in agreement with the previous report that the distribution of the Laves phase is very heterogeneous and often in a clustering state [18] . Analysis of the selected area electron diffraction (SAED) pattern ( Fig. 1 (c)) shows that the crystal structure of Laves phase is a hexagonal structure with the lattice constants of a = 4.75 Å and c = 7.73 Å, in agreement with those of Laves phase in a 12Cr–2W heat-resistant steels [18] . Characteristic streaks on the SAED pattern are displayed in Fig. 1 (c) for particle A, similar to the result shown previously in 9–12% Cr steels [18,19] . This feature allows easy distinction of Laves phase from M 23 C 6 . Both particles prefer to precipitate in close vicinity, preferentially on subgrain boundaries [19] , as shown in Fig. 2 (a). In addition, Fig. 1 (d) compares the energy-dispersive spectrum (EDS) of particle A and the matrix. It is obvious that Laves phase in the experimental steel is of (Fe, Cr) 2 (W, Mo) type and the particle is enriched in W and Mo. With regard to the nucleation and growth of Laves phase in steel X12, in current study, two mechanisms have been found, one mechanism is that the nucleation of Laves phase in the matrix occurs on martensite lath boundaries or subgrain boundaries alone (with no M 23 C 6 carbides in the vicinity), Laves phases are coherent with a grain but grow into the adjacent grain with which they do not have a rational orientation relationship, because of coherent interfaces having a lower mobility than incoherent interfaces, as shown in Fig. 1 (a), and similar results have been found in a 12Cr–2W power plant steel [18] and steel P92 [19] . The other one is that Laves phase precipitates in the chromium-depleted regions adjacent to M 23 C 6 particles, as displayed in Fig. 2 (a). It is because such regions have relatively high W and Mo content, which are beneficial to the formation of Laves phases. Then Laves phases grow at the expense of the Cr-rich M 23 C 6 carbides in the vicinity due to the rearrangement of the alloy elements (Cr, Mo, W) [20,21] . Similar observations have been made for steel T9 [22] . It is interesting to note that most of Laves phases precipitating in steel X12 during short-term creep are found alone on martensite lath boundaries or subgrain boundaries with no M 23 C 6 carbides in close vicinity in our experiment. It can conclude that the former one is the dominant formation mechanism for Laves phase in X12. Fig. 3 is the UHR-FESEM image of the tested steel, presenting the distribution sites of Laves phase precipitates (indicated by black arrows) after short-term creep under various conditions. It is apparent that the prior austenite grain boundaries (PAGBs) and martensite lath boundaries are the favorable sites for Laves phase, perhaps because the interfacial energy of these boundaries facilitates its nucleation. Sawada et al. [23] reported some Laves phase particles located inside the grain (thought to be the location of the former grain boundaries). However, in our study, no Laves phase has been observed inside the grain. Quantification of Laves phase particle in the creep specimen is shown in Fig. 4 , including the corrected mean diameter, area fraction and number of Laves phase precipitates as a function of stress and temperature. The error bars in Fig. 4 (a) are derived from the standard deviation and the number of particles with assuming the 95% confidence internal as normal distributions. It is obvious that the corrected mean diameter of Laves phase precipitated at 650 °C is larger than that at 600 °C. However, the area fraction and the number of particles of specimen at 650 °C are lower than those at 600 °C ( Fig. 4 (b)), that is, creep specimens exposed at 650 °C display a lower density of Laves phase precipitates as compared with those at 600 °C, which is consistent with the results of steel GX12 and steel P92 reported in Ref. [15] . Furthermore, it must be noted that Laves phases in the specimens exposed at 600 °C reveal insignificant change in size with increasing the stress, as is in agreement with investigations on the steel GX12 using TEM/EFTEM by Hofer et al. [8] that strain has little influence on the size of Laves phase precipitates. In Fig. 4 (b), the area fraction of Laves phase precipitates slightly decreases with raising the stress from 130 MPa to 230 MPa at 600 °C and the number of particles of the creep specimens under higher stress is slightly lower than those under lower stress, which suggest that stress (or strain) has negative influence on the area fraction and the number of Laves phase, in accordance with the experimental results of steel GX12 during short-term creep [15] . Cui et al. [24] studied stress effect on the precipitation behavior of the Laves phase at the early stage of aging and creep in the Fe–10%Cr–6%W–(Co) alloys and found that the creep stress enhanced the Laves phase precipitation at 600 °C and 650 °C. That is, average size of precipitates in the creep specimen is slightly larger than that in the aged specimens and the number density of Laves phase precipitates increases in the creep specimen. The discrepancy of the above results is attributed to the different microstructure and microstructure evolution during creep for the steels. The Fe–10%Cr–6%W–(Co) steel studied in Ref. [24] is fully ferritic, and creep stress and strain promote the formation of dislocation substructure, which act as nucleation sites for Laves phase, i.e., stress promotes the nucleation of Laves phase in the fully ferritic steel. However, the tested steel X12 in this study and steel GX12 studied in Ref. [15] are martensitic, and have a microstructure of tempered martensite with high density of dislocations and subgrains, which are potential nucleation sites for Laves Phase. Stress and strain reduce the dislocation density and cause growth of subgrains, i.e., stress suppresses the nucleation of Laves phase, which is in accordance with the observations. The thermodynamic calculation in this study has been performed using the software JMatPro [25] , as shown in Fig. 5 . M 23 C 6 , MX, and Laves phase are the equilibrium phases for the experimental material at creep temperature (600 °C/650 °C). These results are in accordance with experimentally found phases except for the as-received state, in which the equilibrium conditions have not been achieved yet. According to Fig. 5 , precipitation of Laves phase may occur at temperatures lower than the solution temperature of Laves phase (698.6 °C), and the volume fraction of Laves phase increases with decreasing the temperature below 698.6 °C. The equilibrium volume fraction of Laves phase at 600 °C (1.04%) is higher than that at 650 °C (0.61%), while the experimental results on the volume fraction of Laves phase is between 0.25% and 0.34% at both temperatures, which is far from that at the equilibrium state. The precipitation of Laves phase is possible to occur at both tempering temperature 570 °C and 690 °C from the thermodynamic calculation result ( Fig. 5 ). However, the Laves phase which has been formed during the first-step tempering process (570 °C/21 h) probably have been dissolved during the process of tempering at higher temperature 690 °C for a longer term 23 h, which promotes the diffusion of Fe, Mo and W atoms. Thus Laves phases formed at 570 °C are negligible. The number of Laves phase would not change with temperature provided that the nucleation process of Laves phase has been finished during the second-step tempering process (690 °C/23 h). Whereas, the experimental result shows that the number of Laves phase decreases with raising temperature from 600 °C to 650 °C ( Fig. 4 (b)). So the nucleation process of Laves phase has not finished after heat-treatment and some new nuclei of Laves phase should be formed during creep exposure. The nucleation of Laves phase in 9–12% Cr steels is believed to be heterogeneous [15,18,20,21] , which is also confirmed by this work. The number of nuclei is related to the potential nucleation sites for Laves phase such as the dislocation networks and subgrain boundaries. The increase in temperature accelerates the process of recovery and recrystallization, and thereby reduces dislocation density and promotes the subgrain growth, i.e., the increase in temperature suppresses the nucleation of Laves phase. Accordingly, the number of nuclei formed in the steel decreases with raising the temperature, in agreement with our experimental results. 4 Conclusions Laves phase precipitates in the creep specimens made of steel X12 during short-term exposure of 200 h at 650 °C and 400 h at 600 °C. They have irregular shape and have stacking faults in them. The SAED patterns of the phase are characteristic of streaked. Two mechanisms of the nucleation and growth for Laves phase present in steel X12 have been found. One is that Laves phases are formed alone on martensite lath boundaries and they are coherent with a grain but grow into the adjacent grain having no rational orientation relationship with them. The other is that Laves phases occur in the regions adjacent to M 23 C 6 particles, and then they grow at the expense of the Cr-rich M 23 C 6 carbides in the vicinity. It is concluded that the former one is the primary mechanism for the formation of Laves phase in steel X12. The PAGBs and martensite lath boundaries are the favorable locations for Laves phase. The size and the number of the phase are strongly dependent on temperature, but show a weaker variation with stress. Furthermore, perhaps it is because Laves phase is one of the thermodynamically stable phases present in steel X12 at 600 °C and 650 °C that Laves phase has been detected in such a short-time. In addition, it is believed that the nucleation process of Laves phase has not been finished after heat-treatment. Temperature has negative influence on the number of nuclei for Laves phase, i.e., the number of nuclei formed in the steel decreases with raising the temperature. Acknowledgement This work was supported by a grant from the Scientific Research Innovation program of Shanghai Educational Committee in PR China (No. 09ZZ16). References [1] T.U. Ken B. Scarlin R.W. Vanstone K.H. Mayer J. Lecomte-Beckers Materials for Advanced Power Engineering, Part I 1998 Jülich GmbH, Forschungszentrum Jülich 53 [2] V.K. Sikka C.T. Ward K.C. Thomas Fabrication, Properties and Applications of Ferritic Steels for High-Temperature Applications 1981 ASM Int. Conf. Production Warrendale, PA [3] K. Maruyama K. Sawada J.-I. Koike ISIJ Int. 41 2001 641 653 [4] J. Hald S. Straub J. Lecomte-Beckers F. Schubert P.J. Ennis Materials for Advanced Power Engineering, 1998 Forschungszentrum Julich, Germany 155 [5] F. Masuyama ISIJ Int. 41 2001 612 625 [6] K. Yamada M. Igarashi S. Muneki F. Abe ISIJ Int. 43 2003 1438 1443 [7] H. Cerjak P. Hofer B. Schaffernak ISIJ Int. 39 1999 874 888 [8] P. Hofer H. Cerjak B. Schaffernak P. Warbichler Steel Res. 69 1998 343 348 [9] Y. Qin G. Götzb W. Blum Z.G. Zhu J. Alloys Compd. 52 2003 260 264 [10] Y. Hosoi N. Wade S. Kunimitsu T. Urita J. Nucl. Mater. 461 1986 141 143 [11] K. Miyahara J.-H. Hwang Y. Shimoide Scr. Metall. Mater. 32 1995 1917 1921 [12] S. Kunimitsu T. Iwamoto A. Hotta Y. Sasaki Y. Hosoi Proc Int. Conf. on Stainless Steels Chiba ISIJ 1991 627 [13] J. Hald Steel Res. 9 1996 369 374 [14] J. Hald L. Korcakova ISIJ Int. 43 2003 420 427 [15] G. Dimmler P. Weinert E. Kozeschnik H. Cerjak Mater. Charact. 51 2003 341 352 [16] L. Korcakova J. Hald M.A.J. Somers Mater. Charact. 47 2001 111 117 [17] Media Cybernetics, Computer software. [18] Q. Li Metall. Mater. Trans. A 37A 2006 89 97 [19] P.J. Ennis A. Czyrska-Filemonowicz Sādhanā 28 2003 709 730 [20] Y. Tsuchida K. Okamoto Y. Tokunaga ISIJ Int. 35 1995 317 323 [21] C. Yang F. Sun L. Zhang J. Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ. (Chin. Ed.) 43 2009 1640 1643 [22] B.A. Senior Mater. Sci. Eng., A 119 1989 5 9 [23] K. Sawada M. Takeda K. Maruyama R. Ishii M. Yamada Y. Naga Mater. Sci. Eng., A 267 1999 19 25 [24] J. Cui I.S. Kim C.Y. Kang K. Miyahara ISIJ Int. 41 2001 368 371 [25] Web article: http://www.sentesoftware.co.uk/biblio.html , 2007.

Abstract:We describe here the microstructure of simulated thermal cycles with the different peak temperatures associated with the heat-affected zone (HAZ) in a 600 MPa acicular ferrite steel. The microstructure, crystallographic features, and the effective grain size of different regions in the HAZ were examined by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and electron back scattering diffraction (EBSD) analysis. The study indicated that the effective grain size decreases with decrease in peak temperature and attains the smallest value at a peak temperature of 900 °C. However, EBSD analysis indicated that the effective grain size of the sub-zones is small, which contributes to the excellent low temperature toughness in the sub-zones of HAZ. Two hardness peaks were observed at temperatures of 800 °C and 1200 °C because of grain refinement. The study convincingly demonstrates that EBSD can accurately identify the effective grain size contribution on complex and fine-grained microstructures, and is helpful in predicting the grain refinement mechanism. Keywords Steels EBSD Heat-affected zone (HAZ) Grain refinement Acicular ferrite 1 Introduction Grain refinement continues to be an important and viable approach to obtain high strength–high toughness combination. Thus, an accurate measurement of the effective grain size is important to study the mechanism of grain refinement. For diffusion-controlled ferrite–pearlite microstructure under high temperature equilibrium conditions, the size of ferrite grains represents the actual grain size, i.e. the effective grain size. However, it is difficult to determine the effective grain size of the intermediate transformation microstructures, such as acicular ferrite, bainite, and martensite, particularly, if the phase transformation is rapid and shear-controlled, and a complex microstructure is obtained. Electron back scattered diffraction (EBSD) in SEM enables determination of phase and crystallographic orientation of the sample in different regions by recording diffraction patterns along the sample surface in steps of defined size [1–3] . The size and relative location of grain boundaries, phases, and grains in the sample can be conveniently determined using crystallographic information [4] . Extensive studies have been carried out to improve the toughness of the weld metal and/or HAZ of steels [5–9] . Given the fact that the microstructure of weld and heat-affected zone (HAZ) plays an important role in defining the mechanical properties of the weld zone [10–12] , a number of studies predicted the effect of microstructure and mechanical properties of weld zone and HAZ in steels [13–15] . A weld thermal cycle simulation technique was employed to examine the transformation behavior of the HAZ in the microalloyed steels, where the HAZ was generally divided into fusion zone, grain-coarsened zone, grain-refined zone, and partially transformed zone. Although the sub-zones in the HAZ experienced complicated thermal cycles during the actual welding process, they can, however, be simulated by the right choice of the peak temperatures. In an attempt to understand the strengthening and toughening mechanisms in the HAZ of an ultra-low carbon acicular ferrite steel, simulation of thermal cycle with different peak temperatures associated with different sub-zones of heat-affected zone (HAZ) was studied by EBSD in terms of microstructure and effective grain size in sub-zones of the HAZ. 2 Experimental procedure A 600 MPa ultra-low carbon acicular ferrite steel of 50 mm thickness was produced by an advanced TMCP-RPC (Thermal-Mechanical Controlled Processing-Relaxed Precipitation Control) process. The processing of the steel was carried out as follows: The reduction of the slab was greater than 50% in the two stages. The first stage was completed above 900 °C and the plate was held for several seconds after the second stage rolling. The plate was then water-cooled to 500 °C and subsequently cooled to the room temperature in air. Detailed processing details are not given here because of proprietary reasons. The chemical composition of the steel is presented in Table 1 . The peak temperatures ( T m ) for thermal cycle simulation in Gleeble 2000 were in the range of 800–1400 °C to simulate the different regions in HAZ. The Gleeble specimens had dimensions of 10 mm × 12 mm. Specimens were polished using standard metallographic procedures and etched with 3 vol.% Nital. EBSD analysis was conducted using a Quanta 400 operated at 30 kV. 3 Results 3.1 Microstructure of the HAZ sub-zones Fig. 1 shows the light micrographs of the sub-zones in HAZ simulated using different peak temperatures with the t 8/5 = 20 s (the time for temperature to drop from 800 °C to 500 °C). It is observed that at the peak temperature of 800 °C, the rolling characteristics disappear because of the occurrence of a small content of recrystallized microstructure ( Fig. 1 a). At the peak temperature of 1000 °C ( Fig. 1 b), a significant content of fine ferrite is formed because of complete recrystallization. With subsequent increase in peak temperature, the austenite grain size was increased and transformed to bainite during the cooling. At 1400 °C, the microstructure primarily consisted of bainitic lath together with acicular ferrite with the original austenite grains of average grain size of 60 μm ( Fig. 1 d). The TEM micrographs corresponding to the peak temperature of 1400 °C and 1200 °C are presented in Fig. 2 , respectively. Retained austenite and/or M/A constituents were present at the sub-grain boundary of bainite lath at the peak temperature of 1400 °C ( Fig. 2 a and b). Widmanstätten ferrite ( Fig. 2 c) grew from the grain boundary and acicular ferrite ( Fig. 2 d) formed in the interior of the austenite grain. At the peak temperature of 1400 °C, the austenite grains coarsened and indicated a high content of grain boundary and intragranular acicular ferrite compared to that at the peak temperature of 1200 °C. However, the latter indicated wide bainitic lath and higher content of M/A constituent. Compared to the traditional ultra-low carbon lath bainitic steel, a significantly higher acicular ferrite is formed in the austenite grain, which is responsible for good low temperature toughness (see below). In Fig. 3 , TEM micrographs at the peak temperature of 900 °C consisting of massive ferrite and grain boundary features are presented. The massive ferrite has curved grain boundaries and low dislocation density. In contrast to the behavior at 900 °C ( Fig. 3 ), the microstructure at 800 °C consists of acicular ferrite, partially recrystallized microstructure, incomplete recrystallized massive ferrite and M/A constituent ( Fig. 4 a–d ). In Fig. 5 a is presented impact toughness as a function of peak temperature for the sub-zones of HAZ simulated specimens corresponding to different peak temperatures with the t 8/5 = 20 s. The toughness is lowest at the peak temperature of 800 °C and is highest at the peak temperature of 600 °C and 700 °C when tempering is rapid at these temperatures. The toughness is high at the peak temperature of 900 °C and 1100 °C, but decreases at the peak temperatures of 1200 °C and 1400 °C. In Fig. 5 b, the Vickers hardness data of the sub-zones is presented. It can be seen that there are two peaks at 216 HV 10 and 225 HV 10 , respectively at the peak temperature of 800 °C and 1200 °C. The hardness of 194 HV 10 at the peak temperature of 900 °C is close to that of the base matrix, and is discussed later. The EBSD analysis of the microstructural features of the sub-zones of HAZ simulated specimens corresponding to different peak temperature is presented in Fig. 6 a–f . At the peak temperature of 1400 °C ( Fig. 6 a), the microstructure primarily consists of ferrite lath, which divides the original austenite grain into separate regions together with small amount of acicular ferrite. At the peak temperature of 1200 °C ( Fig. 6 b), the microstructure consists of acicular ferrite and some granular bainite. The microstructure corresponding to 1000 °C ( Fig. 6 c) and 900 °C ( Fig. 6 d) is irregular ferrite and equiaxed ferrite, respectively. At the peak temperature of 800 °C ( Fig. 6 e), the microstructure is a complex mixture of acicular ferrite of the base metal, massive ferrite, and a small amount of fine equiaxed ferrite obtained from the incomplete recrystallization. 3.2 Effective grain size of simulated sub-zones Fig. 7 a–d shows the grain growth features and distribution of effective grain size of simulated sub-zones. At the peak temperature of 800 °C, the effective grain size is 7.73–8.83 μm ( Fig. 7 a) and the statistical distribution of grain size indicates non-uniform microstructure because of partial recrystallization. The effective grain size was smallest (3.95–4.17 μm) at the peak temperature of 900 °C ( Fig. 7 b) and increased with peak temperature. The grain size distribution at the peak temperature of 1200 °C indicated that the prior austenite grains started to grow such that the effective grain size was 8.12–9.36 μm ( Fig. 7 c). At the peak temperature of 1400 °C, austenite grains grow fast and there was bimodal grain size distribution ( Fig. 7 d). The effective grain size of simulated sub-zones is summarized in Table 2 for 20 fields of view for each specimen with grain angles set as 10° and 15°, respectively. 3.3 EBSD analysis on the angles between neighboring grains The angles between neighboring grains of the specimens at different peak temperatures were examined by EBSD with a resolution of 2°. The EBSD analysis map and statistical distribution of the grain angles between adjacent grains for different temperatures are presented in Figs. 8a–d and 9a–d , respectively. In these figures, different colors represent different grain boundary angles, for example, green standing for smaller angles of 3–12°, blue for 12–22°, red for 22–32°, purple for 32–42°, yellow for 42–52°, and white for 52–62°. It is observed that the incomplete recrystallization zone at the peak temperature of 800 °C was smallest by the grain boundary angle ( Figs. 8a and 9a ), followed by 1200 °C ( Fig. 8c and 9c ) and 1400 °C ( Figs. 8d and 9d ). At the peak temperature of 900 °C ( Figs. 8b and 9b ), the number of small-angle grain boundaries was significantly reduced and grains with large angles dominated the microstructure. In Table 3 , a summary of the proportion of grain boundaries with different grain boundary angles is presented. It can be concluded from Table 3 that the strength should be maximum at the peak temperatures of 800 °C and 1200 °C, and the former should have higher strength because of sub-grain strengthening. (For interpretation of references to color in Figs. 8 and 9, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.) 4 Discussion 4.1 Microstructure of sub-zones in HAZ The weld thermal cycle simulation technique was employed to examine the transformation behavior of the HAZ in the microalloyed steels. As we know that the HAZ can generally be divided into fusion, grain-coarsened, grain-refined and partially transformed zones. These sub-zones can be simulated by means of different peak temperature. The experimental phase transformation temperatures, A c1 and A c3 are 710 °C and 860 °C, respectively. The temperatures of 1400 °C and 1200 °C correspond to the coarse-grained region in HAZ and temperatures of 900 °C and 800 °C are related to the recrystallization phase zone and incomplete recrystallization phase zone, respectively. At the peak temperature of 1400 °C, the austenite grains coarsen compared to 1200 °C and the transformed microstructure shows a higher amount of intragranular acicular ferrite and Widmanstäten ferrite ( Fig. 2 ). However, dominant microstructures are bainitic lath and acicular ferrite. Compared to traditional ultra-low carbon bainitic steel, significantly higher acicular ferrite formed in the austenite grain is expected to provide good low temperature toughness. At the peak temperature of 900 °C, complete recrystallization occurred at high-energy positions such as grain boundary interfaces with consequent formation of fine idiomorphic grains. However, incomplete recrystallization occurred at the low-energy positions in the form of massive ferrite with low dislocation density. At the peak temperature of 800 °C, between the A c1 and A c3 , the recrystallization occurred only at the high-energy positions, i.e. at the austenite grain boundary. The microstructure consisted of retained acicular ferrite and massive ferrite with M/A constituents. 4.2 Evaluation of the grain refinement mechanisms of sub-zones in HAZ In the case of mixed microstructure of high strength steels, the formation of domains leads to microstructural refinement. Domain is defined as a cell with misorientation angle larger than 10° between neighboring grains in the deformed austenite and represents the effective grain size of the fine-grained microstructure in steels. The identification of the effective grain size is difficult. In the present work, the effective grain size in the mixed microstructure was identified by EBSD analysis technique, and the microstructural features and effective grain size were analyzed in the sub-zones in HAZ. Fig. 10 shows variation of the effective grain size with peak temperature with the grain angles set as 10° and 15°. It is observed that the variant of the actual grain size is consistent with the peak temperature. At the peak temperature of 1400 °C, the microstructure in the fusion line was characterized by largest effective grain size of 9.83–11.41 μm, and was similar to the microstructure at the peak temperature of 1200 °C with the effective grain size of 9.89–11.39 μm, which is in the low-temperature region of coarse-grained zone. The effective grain size reduces with decrease in temperature and is smallest at the peak temperature of 900 °C (i.e. 3.95–4.17 μm). However, when the temperature is 800 °C, the effective grain size increases to 7.73–8.83 μm. It can be concluded that the effective grain size of the sub-zones varies within the smaller range, even though the microstructure is coarse in the coarse-grain zone, which suggests the reasons why the weld joints have excellent low temperature toughness in the sub-zones in HAZ in ultra-low carbon acicular ferrite steel. In Fig. 11 , the percentage of large-angle grain boundary with different neighboring grain angles is presented for different peak temperatures. It is observed that the variance of the percentage of large-angle grain boundary for different peak temperatures is similar with the neighboring grain angles set in the range of 5–40°. The growth of austenite grains in the coarse-grain zone is not very obvious, as shown in Fig. 11 . 4.3 The effect of low angle grain boundary on hardening of weld joint microstructure The relationship between low angle grain boundary and the peak temperatures is presented in Fig. 12 , with first maxima at 800 °C and second maxima at 1200 °C, consistent with the hardness variance with temperature. This can be explained as follows. The temperature of 800 °C corresponds to the ferrite–austenite region when the microstructure is a combination of acicular ferrite retained from the base metal and massive ferrite transformed from the partially austenitic zones. There are also many M/A constituents in the massive ferrite. Lath with the neighboring grain angle smaller than 3° is retained in acicular ferrite with high density of dislocations located among these laths. Therefore, there is a large quantity of small-angle grain boundaries between neighboring grains. The peak temperature of 1200 °C is at the junction of coarse-zone and completely recrystallized zone. The lath features in this zone are distinct than that of completely recrystallized zone and the microstructure is finer as compared to that at 1400 °C, which is responsible for the hardness peak at this peak temperature. It is demonstrated that the ratio of the low angle grain boundary set as 3° reflects the amount of the lath and the level of refinement. Accordingly, it can be concluded that the grain refinement leads to the appearance of the peak hardness values at peak temperatures of 800 °C and 1200 °C. 5 Conclusions a. Effective grain size decreased with decrease in the peak temperature and attained the smallest value at 900 °C. However, when the temperature was decreased to 800 °C, the effective grain size started to increase. b. Effective grain size of the sub-zones of the investigated steel is small, which is responsible for the excellent low temperature toughness in the sub-zones in HAZ. c. The formation of acicular ferrite (AF) in the sub-zones (CGHAZ) plays an important role in the refinement of CGHAZ. d. EBSD can be used to identify the grain size contribution of complex fine-grained microstructure. References [1] H. Kitahara R. Ueji M. Ueda N. Tsuji Y. Minamino Mater. Charact. 54 2005 378 386 [2] F.J. Humphreys J. Mater. Sci. 36 2001 3833 3854 [3] V. Randle Microtexture Determination and its Applications second ed. 2003 Institute of Materials/Maney London [4] K.P. Mingard B. Roebuck E.G. Bennett M.G. Gee H. Nordenstrom G. Sweetman P Chan J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater. 27 2009 213 223 [5] T. Funakoshi T. Tanaka S. Ueda Trans. ISIJ 17 1977 419 427 [6] S. Kanzawa A. Nakajima K. Okamoto K. Kanaya Tetsu-to-Hagané 61 1975 2589 2603 [7] Y. Tomita N. Saito T. Tsuzui Y. Tokunaga K. Okamoto ISIJ Int. 34 1994 829 835 [8] M. Enomoto Met. Mater. 4 1998 115 123 [9] K.M. Wu Y. Inagawa M. Enomoto Mater. Charact. 52 2004 121 127 [10] K.E. Easterling S.A. David Proceedings of an International Conference on Trends in Welding Research ASM Int., Gatlinburg, TN 1986 177 185 [11] K.E. Easterling Introduction to the Physical Metallurgy of Welding 1992 Butterworth-Heinemann London [12] L.E. Svensson Control of Microstructures and Properties in Steel Arc Welding 1994 CRC Press Boca Raton, FL [13] Y. Shi D. Chen Y. Lei X. Li Comput. Mater. Sci. 31 2004 379 388 [14] M.F. Ashby K.E. Easterling Acta Metall. 30 1982 1969 1999 [15] J.C. Ion K.E. Easterling M.F. Ashby Acta Metall. 32 1984 1949 1962

Influence of smelting processes on precipitation behaviors and mechanical properties of low activation ferrite steels

Effect of N on the Precipitation Behaviours of the Reduced Activation Ferritic/martensitic Steel CLF-1 after Thermal Ageing

Mechanical Properties and Thermal Stability of Carbide Dispersion Strengthened CLF-1 Steel

Mechanical Properties and Microstructure of 9Cr-Ods-clf-1 Steel

Low Cycle Fatigue and Creep Fatigue Interaction Behavior of 9Cr-0.5Mo-1.8w-v-nb Heat-Resistant Steel at High Temperature

Revealing influence of warm bending on creep performance of heat-resistant 2.25Cr-1Mo-0.25 V steel

Precipitates Change of Ferritic‐martensitic 11 % Chromium Steel under Short‐term Creep

Stabilities of the precipitates in CLAM steel during 30,000 h thermal aging

Precipitation behavior of Laves phase in 10%Cr steel X12CrMoWVNbN10-1-1 during short-term creep exposure

Precipitation Evolution in the Austenitic Heat-Resistant Steel HR3C upon Creep at 700 °C and 750 °C

Microstructural Evolution of a Re-Containing 10% Cr-3Co-3W Steel during Creep at Elevated Temperature

Evaluation of metallurgical risk factors in post-test, advanced 9% Cr creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steel

Strengthening and fracture mechanisms of Fe–20Ni–14Cr–2Cu alumina-forming austenitic steel during creeping

Precipitate phases in ferritic/martensitic steel P92 after thermomechanical treatment

Effect of Heat Treatment on Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Selective Laser Melted 18ni300 Maraging Steel

Identification of Precipitate Phases in an 11%cr Ferritic/martensitic Steel after Short-term Creep

Effect of Stress on Microstructural Evolution and Mechanical Properties of 12cr3w3co Steel During Aging and Short-Term Creep

Effect of Long-Term Thermal Aging on Microstructure Evolution and Creep Deformation Behavior of a Novel 11Cr-3W-3Co Martensite Ferritic Steel

An analysis of the microstructure of the heat-affected zone of an ultra-low carbon and niobium-bearing acicular ferrite steel using EBSD and its relationship to mechanical properties

Identification of Tantalum Precipitates in CLAM Steel

A Systematic Investigation of Precipitates in Matrix and at Grain Boundaries in an Alumina-Forming Austenitic Steel During Creep Testing at 700 °C