Enhanced mechanical properties in a new Ni–Co base superalloy by controlling microstructures
C.Y. Cui,Y.F. Gu,Y. Yuan,T. Osada,H. Harada
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2011.03.085
2011-01-01
Abstract:Highlights ► We examined the tensile and creep properties of a new Ni–Co base superalloy as a function of heat treatment conditions. ► By increasing the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C, the yield strength could be improved by 60 MPa, and an improvement of 15 °C in temperature capacity could be achieved. ► The enhanced mechanical properties were mainly ascribed to grain growth, the increasing of fraction of tertiary γ ′ and of the length of annealing twin formed during the heat treatment. Abstract We report the enhanced tensile strength and creep resistance of a new Ni–Co-base superalloy (TMW-2) by increasing the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C. The yield strength could be improved by 60 MPa, and a temperature gain in creep resistance of about 15 °C could be achieved. The improvements in yield strength and creep resistance are mainly due to the coarsening of grain size, the increasing of the volume fraction of tertiary γ ′ and of the length of annealing twin formed during the heat treatment. Keywords Ni–Co base superalloy Yield strength Creep Tertiary γ ′ Annealing twin 1 Introduction Recently, we proposed a new idea of combining two types of γ / γ ′ alloys (Ni-base and Co-base) to design new disk superalloys [1–3] . Based on this innovative concept, we have succeeded in developing a new kind of Ni–Co base superalloy (termed as TMW) with the world's highest heat resistance of 725 °C, exceeding that of the existing high strength C&W Ni-base alloy U720Li by 50 °C [4] . Meanwhile, we also produced successfully a real-scale pancake by TMW alloy under a commission from Japanese New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization (NEDO). TMW alloys are expected to be made into turbine components such as turbine disk for aircraft engine and industrial gas turbine engine applications. Unlike turbine blade exposed wholly to high temperature, turbine disk experiences a spectrum of temperature, which ranged from lower temperature at the bore, intermediate temperature in the web and higher temperature at the rim. Therefore, it is essential that the mechanical properties of the new TMW alloys in all temperature regions are well understood. For disk alloys, the grain size has a major effect on the critical properties including tensile strength, creep resistance, low cycle fatigue (LCF) and fatigue crack growth rate. It is generally believed that the LCF life and tensile strength have opposite grain size dependence to creep strength and fatigue crack growth [5] . However, the present study indicated that the tensile yield strength and creep resistance of new TMW alloys could be improved simultaneously. The effect of increasing the solution temperature on the microstructures and main reasons for the improvements will be discussed. 2 Experimental procedure The nominal composition of the alloy TMW-2 is listed in Table 1 . The alloy was heat-treated at 1100 °C, 1120 °C and 1140 °C for 4 h respectively (air cooling), and then aged at 650 °C for 24 h (air cooling), and finally at 760 °C for 16 h (air cooling). The grain orientations of the heat-treated samples were measured by an electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) method. Tensile tests were performed at room temperature (RT) and 400 °C under a strain rate of 3 × 10 −4 s −1 . Creep experiments were performed at 725 °C/630 MPa. The transmission electron microscope (TEM) disks with thickness of about 300 μm were cut from the crept samples perpendicular to the stress axis. Then the disks were manually ground down to 50 μm and perforated by twin-jet electro-polisher at 40 V and 0 °C. The electrolyte consisted of 50 ml perchloric acid, 100 ml ethanol and 300 ml 2-butoxyethanol. The TEM microstructures of specimens were investigated using a TECNAI 20 TEM operated at 200 kV. 3 Results and discussions Fig. 1 (a) shows the tensile creep curve of the samples tested at 725 °C/630 MPa. Each of these creep curves included a primary (transient) creep stage, a steady-state creep stage and tertiary creep stage. The rupture life was about 160 h for 1100 °C solution treated samples, 260 h for 1120 °C solution treated samples and 300 h for 1140 °C solution treated samples, respectively. So there was a factor of about 2 improvement in rupture life of TMW-2 alloy by improving the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C. Time to 0.2% creep strain was also analyzed using a Larson-Miller parameter commonly employed for disk alloy, the analyzed results are shown in Fig. 1 (b). Creep resistance was improved by increasing the solution temperature. It was noted that a temperature gain of about 15 °C could be achieved by increasing the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C. Table 2 shows the tensile results of the alloy TMW-2 with various solution temperatures, all the tests were performed at RT and 400 °C under a strain rate of 3 × 10 −4 s −1 . By increasing the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C, the yield strength of the TMW-2 was improved by about 60 MPa, while the elongation and area reduction of TMW-2 alloy was not influenced, showing that the alloy's tensile strength could also be improved by increasing the solution temperature. Detailed microstructural investigations were carried out to understand the occurrence of the enhanced yield strength and creep resistance at the same time by increasing solution temperature. Fig. 2 (a) shows the microstructure of the starting materials. It consisted of primary γ ′ precipitate at the grain boundaries of the γ matrix and little amount of TiC with irregular shape. TEM observations ( Fig. 2 (b)) revealed intragranular secondary γ ′ precipitates (about 70 nm) and small amounts of tertiary γ ′ precipitates (about 15 nm). Fig. 3 shows the SEM microstructures of the alloy TMW-2 after heat treatments. The grain boundary character distribution (GBCD) in the heat-treated samples was analyzed from the EBSD maps using OIM. One feature was that grain growth occurred in the heat treatment. The grain size increased from 6.9 μm to 8.7 μm with increasing the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C. Another feature was that the annealing twins increased greatly from 0.146 to 0.413 with increasing solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C. The evolution of annealing twin in the heat treatment will be reported in detail elsewhere [6] . Beside the grain growth in the heat treatment, the fraction of primary γ ′ decreased greatly from 0.166 at 1100 °C to 0.054 at 1140 °C, this means that fraction of secondary and tertiary γ ′ content increased about 0.11 by improving the solution temperature, which enhanced the mechanical properties of disk alloys [1,7] . The results are also summarized in Table 3 . Fig. 4 shows the variation of secondary and tertiary γ ′ particle with various solution heat treatments. The secondary and tertiary γ ′ precipitates with a spherical morphology were observed to precipitate in all the samples, independent of heat treatment condition. As for the secondary γ ′ size and fraction ( Table 3 ), the secondary γ ′ fraction changed slightly in the heat treatment, whereas the secondary γ ′ size was influenced by heat treatment. The average secondary γ ′ size was measured to about 75 nm at 1100 °C and 90 nm at 1140 °C, respectively. A striking feature in Fig. 4 and Table 3 was that the fraction of tertiary γ ′ increased about 8% by increasing heat treatment temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C, while the tertiary γ ′ in all the heat treatment had very small size of about 15 nm. Generally speaking, Ni-base superalloys derive their outstanding properties from a combination of several principal strengthening mechanisms: (1) solid solution [8] , (2) precipitation [9] , and (3) grain boundary strengthening [10] . The alloy TMW-2 had a complex microstructure, it mainly consisted of γ grain, primary γ ′, secondary γ ′ and tertiary γ ′ and high fraction of annealing twin. Thus, the yield strength of the alloy TMW-2 was mainly related to the following parameters: solid solution by γ , primary γ ′, secondary γ ′, tertiary γ ′, grain size, annealing twin. During the heat treatment, the effect of solid solution of γ on yield strength was minimal [1] . Also, the primary γ ′ with a size of about 1 μm, formed in the forging process, mainly located on the grain boundary, thus it had little effect on the mechanical properties [11] . In addition, twin boundary (Σ3) was reported to be important to the ductility improvement because it was believed to be tough and crack-resistant boundary, whereas effect of twin boundary (Σ3) on yield stress was not obvious [12] . On the other hand, increasing content and decreasing size of secondary and tertiary γ ′ precipitate are reported to strongly increase the yield strength, fatigue resistance, and creep resistance [13] . As presented in Fig. 3 and Table 3 , the samples heat treated at 1140 °C/4 h had larger grain size and secondary γ ′ size, higher content of tertiary γ ′. Thus, the strength increase, caused by increasing the tertiary γ ′ content, was much higher than the strength loss caused by the grain growth and increasing the secondary γ ′ size, resulting in the improved yield strength. As mentioned previously, creep resistance of the alloy TMW-2 was also improved remarkably by improving the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C ( Fig. 1 ). It is generally believed that the creep strength of Ni-base superalloy depended on some interrelated microstructural parameters, including grain size, the volume fraction, precipitate size, distribution, and chemical characteristics of the γ ′ precipitates present in γ matrix [14,15] . Apparently, one reason for the temperature gain in creep resistance was ascribed to the coarser grain size in the samples heat treated at 1140 °C/4 h, as shown in Fig. 3 and Table 3 , because the creep resistance increased with the increase in grain size [5] . Another reason was proposed to be related to the higher fraction of tertiary γ ′. Viswanathan et al. [14] studied the creep deformation structure of the superalloy René 88 DT and found that the tertiary γ ′ fraction is crucial in dictating the transition in mechanism and the creep strength of disk superalloys. In this study, TEM observations ( Fig. 4 and Table 3 ) revealed that the 1140 °C/4 h heat-treated samples contained higher fraction of tertiary γ ′ compared with the 1100 °C heat-treated samples. In addition, the high density of annealing twin in the 1140 °C/4 h heat-treated samples may also contribute to the improved creep resistance of TMW-2. In the crept samples, many dislocations, stacking fault (SF) and deformation twin were present, as shown in Fig. 5 (a) . Dislocations could not penetrate the annealing twin and the dislocation density inside the annealing twin was rather low [16] . A lot of stacking faults (SF) existed in the matrix while SFs in the annealing twin were sparse. Even if the SFs formed in the annealing twin, the twin boundary impeded the motion of SF, as shown in Fig. 5 (b). This means that the coherent TBs impeded the dislocation and SF motion, which strengthened the creep resistance of the alloy TMW-2. In summary, we observed improved tensile strength and creep resistance of a new Ni–Co-base superalloy (TMW-2) by controlling microstructures. The enhanced yield strength was mainly attributed to the increased tertiary γ ′ fraction, while the improvement of creep resistance was mainly ascribed to the grain growth, the high fraction of tertiary γ ′ and of annealing twin formed in the heat treatment. 4 Conclusions The tensile and creep properties of a new Ni–Co-base superalloy, TMW-2 was examined as a function of heat treatment conditions and the following results were obtained: (1) By increasing the solution temperature from 1100 °C to 1140 °C, the yield strength could be improved by 60 MPa, and a temperature gain in creep resistance of about 15 °C could be achieved. (2) The enhanced yield strength and creep resistance were mainly ascribed to grain growth, the increasing of the tertiary γ ′ fraction and of the length of annealing twin formed in the heat treatment. Acknowledgements This work was financially supported by Hundreds of Talents Project and National Basic Research Program (973 Program) of China under grant no. 2010CB631200(2010CB631206) . The authors would like to acknowledge Ms. H. Gao for the EBSD measurements. References [1] C.Y. Cui Y.F. Gu H. Harada A. Sato Metall. Mater. Trans. A 36A 2005 2921 [2] Y. Gu H. Harada C. Cui D. Ping A. Sato J. Fujioka Scripta Mater. 55 2006 815 [3] C.Y. Cui Y.F. Gu Y. Yuan H. Harada Scripta Mater. 64 2011 502 [4] Y.F. Gu T. Fukuda C. Cui H. Harada A. Mitsuhashi T. Yokokawwa J. Fujioka Y. Koizumi T. Kobayashi Metall. Mater. Trans.A 40A 2009 3047 [5] J.C. Williams E.A. Starke Acta Mater. 51 2003 5775 [6] C.Y. Cui M. Demura K. Kishida T. Hirano J. Mater. Res. 135 2004 189 [7] C.Y. Cui Y.F. Gu D.H. Ping H. Harada Metall. Mater. Trans. A 40A 2009 282 [8] R.L. Fleischer Acta Metall. 11 1963 203 [9] E. Nembach G. Neite Prog. Mater. Sci. 29 1985 177 [10] W. Mangen E. Nembach Acta Metall. 37 1989 1451 [11] M.P. Jackson R.C. Reed Mater. Sci. Eng. A A259 1999 85 [12] C.Y. Cui M. Demura K. Kishida T. Hirano J. Mater. Res. 20 2005 1054 [13] K. Harris G.L. Erickson R.E. Schwer M. Gell C.S. Kortovich R.H. Bricknell W.B. Knet J.F. Radavich Superalloy 1984 TMS Warrendale, PA 221 [14] G.B. Viswanathan P.M. Sarosi M.F. Henry D.D. Whitis W.W. Milligan M.J. Mills Acta Metall. 53 2005 3041 [15] D.P. Pope S.S. Ezz Int. Met. Rev. 29 1984 136 [16] Y. Yuan Y.F. Gu C.Y. Cui T. Osada T. Yokokawa H. Harada Adv. Eng. Mater 13 2011 296