Measurement of Perfectionism in Chinese Collegiate Athletes and Its Application
Wen-jie Lian,Zhi-xiong Mao,Fei Zi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1612197x.2007.9671844
2007-01-01
International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology
Abstract:The main aim of the research was to develop and validate a tool for the measurement of perfectionism in sports, which pertains to Chinese culture. Eighty-nine items were generated based on existing perfectionism scales. In order to establish content and construct validity, a sample of collegiate athletes (n=260) from different sports completed an initial 89 items scale. A series of item analyses were used to assure adequate reliabilities. Subsequently, a second sample of collegiate athletes (n=350) completed a primary revised 38 items scale. Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) was conducted to examine the factor structure, and reduce scale size based on psychometric properties of the items. Then, a third sample of collegiate athletes (n=420) completed the secondly revised 38 items scale. Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) was used to validate the factors derived from the initial EFA. After three times of modification, the final scale was named the Multi-dimensional Perfectionism Scale for Chinese Collegiate Athlete (MPS-CCA). The final scale with 37 items consisted of 5 dimensions, including Personal Standards, Repeated Thinking Match, Concern about Mistakes, Perceived Parents Pressure, and Perceived Coach Pressure. The final scale presented sufficient Alpha internal consistency coeficients, i.e., 83, .70, .73, .79, and .73, respectively. Test-retest reliability coefficients were: .83, .72, .80, .76, and .72, respectively.MANOVA was conducted to test possible gender and skill-level differences in dimensions of perfectionism. Results indicated that no interaction was found between gender and athletic level, while main effects existed. Post-hoc tests indicated gender differences existed only in Personal Standards Dimension (male athletes were higher than female athletes). Skill-level differences were found in the dimensions of Concern about Mistakes and Perceived Parents Pressure (first- level athletes were higher than second-level athletes).Four athletic perfectionism trait clusters were found using cluster analysis, namely Adaptive Perfectionism, Non-Perfectionism, Maladaptive Perfectionism and Social-Expected Perfectionism, similarly to Parker's(1997) results, but unique to the sport environment. Canonical correlation (Rc) analysis was used to examine the multivariate relationship between perfectionism and trait competitive anxiety. Two significant moderate canonical function pairs were found (Rc1 =.564; Rc2 =.439). The first function revealed that the Concern about Mistakes dimension was significantly (p =.000) and positively correlated with somatic anxiety(r =.43), personal failure anxiety(r =.47), and social-expected anxiety(r =.42) of trait competitive anxiety, The second function revealed that Personal Standards Dimension was significantly (p =.002) and positively associated (r =.22) with self-confidence. The patterns of canonical loadings suggested that the dimensions comprised in perfectionism could have either adaptive or maladaptive influences upon cognition, affect, and behavior.The study revealed that different dimensions in perfectionism reflect the trend of striving for perfection among athletes. It is suggested that future study explore developments of perfectionism using in-depth case study or qualitative approach. Furtheremore, future study must examine athletic trait of perfectionism, and use additional sources of variance to that of gender and skill-level. Perfectionism, as a multi-dimensional construct, could be reliably measued in this field. The tool developed in this research is of high validity and efficiency, and could be used in China in the future.