Comparison of the Value of ~(18)F-FDG PET and ~(99)Tc~m-MDP Bone Scan in the Detection of Bone Metastases

Song Shaoli

2008-01-01

Abstract:Objective:To evaluate the diagnostic value of 18F-2-deoxyglucose (18F-FDG) PET imaging in the detection of bone metastases and to compare with that of 99Tcm-MDP bone scan.Methods:18F-FDG PET/ CT and 99Tcm-MDP bone scan were performed in 97 patients having or being suspected malignant tumor.The interval of these 2 examinations was within 30 days.The results of the above-mentioned examinations were compared and analyzed.Results:Of the 97 patients,63 patients had clinical or pathology diagnosed bone metastases.Based on case to case analyses,18F-FDG-PET showed 62 patients with positive diagnosis,and 1 patient was false negative;99Tcm-MDP showed 49 patients with positive diagnosis and 14 patients were false negative.The sensitivity was 98.4% vs 77.8%,showing significant statistical difference (P0.05).Of the 34 patients without bone metastases,18F-FDG-PET showed 29 patients with true negative and 5 patients with false positive results,while 99Tcm-MDP had 21 true negative and 13 false positive cases.The specificity was 93.8% vs 72.2% (P0.05) and the accuracy was 93.8% vs 72.2% (P0.05) respectively.Based on focal lesion to lesion analysis,altogether there were 1261 bone regions in these 97 patients (the skeletal system was divided into 13 regions),with 226 regions having metastases,14 regions were excluded due to indeterminate final diagnosis.Of these,18F-FDG-PET found 222 regions showing true positive diagnosis and 4 regions showing false negative;99Tcm-MDP showed 154 regions had at least one positive lesion,72 regions showed false negative.The sensitivity was 98.7% vs 68.1% (P0.05),with significant statistical difference as well.Of the 1021 regions did not have skeleton metastases,18F-FDG-PET showed 1010 true negative and 11 false positive regions,while 99Tcm-MDP showed 1001 true negative and 20 false positive regions.The specificity and accuracy were 98.9% vs 98.0% (P0.05) and 98.8% vs 92.6% (P0.05) respectively.According to CT features,the detection rate of bone metastases with CT osteolytic lesion and no CT abnormality by 18F-FDG-PET and 99Tcm-MDP were 99.4% vs 72.6% and 81.5% vs 40.7% respectively,with significant statistical differences (P0.05).Conclusion:18F-FDG PET has higher sensitivity and accuracy than 99Tcm-MDP bone scan,no matter based on case or based on focal lesion analysis.Furthermore,for osteolytic and no abnormality CT lesions,the detection rate of 18F-FDG PET was superior than bone scan.