Abstract:In this paper we examine differences in welfare implications between two trade protection measures: antidumping (AD) duties and price undertakings. Based on a stylized model of duopolistic competition under an effective AD law, we first analyze the case where a foreign firm convicted of dumping is required to pay an AD duty. We then examine the case in which a convicted foreign firm has the option of (i) paying an AD duty or (ii) accepting an undertaking by raising product price to its “normal value.” Taking into account the GATT/WTO policy that an AD duty rate must not exceed the margin of dumping, we show conditions under which a foreign firm chooses to evade its AD fine by a price undertaking. We find that the welfare-maximizing AD duty rate for a dumped product depends crucially on its normal value. If the foreign product's normal value is “critically high,” the optimal AD rate is set to fully reflect the dumping margin. Otherwise, the optimal AD rate is set lower than the dumping margin. From the perspective of social welfare, these findings help to identify the economic conditions under which one policy instrument is chosen over the other against foreign dumping.

Anti-dumping export price adjustment research

Antidumping duties and price undertakings: A welfare analysis

Antidumping and Heterogeneous Quality Adjustment of Multi-Product Firms: Evidence from Chinese Exporters

Antidumping: A Study with Respect to Antimonopoly Law

How do exporters adjust export product scope and product mix to react to antidumping?

How Do Exporters Respond to Antidumping Investigations?

Accounting for Stylised Facts about Recent Anti‐Dumping: Retaliation and Innovation

Retaliatory Anti-dumping and USITC Anti-dumping Determination

Antidumping Petition: To File Or Not To File

Study on impact anti-dumping duties based on current export rebate policy

Studies on Anti-Dumping of Agricultural Products: A Review of Literature in China and Abroad

Analysis on the Injury to Industry by the Dumping and Antidumping Behavior for Agricultural Products in China

Antidumping, Firm Performance, and Subsequent Responses

The Analysis and Designing on Anti-dumping System of Farm Produce in China

A Decision-making Method to Make Anti-dumping Strategy

Pricing Model of AD Duty Rates Towards Multiple Companies

Game Analysis of Implementing Price Undertaking Agreements in Anti-dumping Disputes

A Legal Study on the Anti-Dumping New Shipper Review System in the Anti-Dumping Agreement

Academic Development Process of Chinese Anti-Dumping Law in New Century

Optimal model of anti-dumping duty rate under Cournot competition between similar products

Eeconomic and Political Factors Affecting Antidumping Activities against China