Abstract:BackgroundSmall number of clusters and large variation of cluster sizes commonly exist in cluster-randomized trials (CRTs) and are often the critical factors affecting the validity and efficiency of statistical analyses. F tests are commonly used in the generalized linear mixed model (GLMM) to test intervention effects in CRTs. The most challenging issue for the approximate Wald F test is the estimation of the denominator degrees of freedom (DDF). Some DDF approximation methods have been proposed, but their small sample performances in analysing binary outcomes in CRTs with few heterogeneous clusters are not well studied.MethodsThe small sample performances of five DDF approximations for the F test are compared and contrasted under CRT frameworks with simulations. Specifically, we illustrate how the intraclass correlation (ICC), sample size, and the variation of cluster sizes affect the type I error and statistical power when different DDF approximation methods in GLMM are used to test intervention effect in CRTs with binary outcomes. The results are also illustrated using a real CRT dataset.ResultsOur simulation results suggest that the Between-Within method maintains the nominal type I error rates even when the total number of clusters is as low as 10 and is robust to the variation of the cluster sizes. The Residual and Containment methods have inflated type I error rates when the cluster number is small (<30) and the inflation becomes more severe with increased variation in cluster sizes. In contrast, the Satterthwaite and Kenward-Roger methods can provide tests with very conservative type I error rates when the total cluster number is small (<30) and the conservativeness becomes more severe as variation in cluster sizes increases. Our simulations also suggest that the Between-Within method is statistically more powerful than the Satterthwaite or Kenward-Roger method in analysing CRTs with heterogeneous cluster sizes, especially when the cluster number is small.ConclusionWe conclude that the Between-Within denominator degrees of freedom approximation method for F tests should be recommended when the GLMM is used in analysing CRTs with binary outcomes and few heterogeneous clusters, due to its type I error properties and relatively higher power.

An approximately optimal non-parametric procedure for analyzing exchangeable binary data with random cluster sizes

A simple and effective method for simulating nested exchangeable correlated binary data for longitudinal cluster randomised trials

Non-exchangeable random partition models for microclustering

Comparing denominator degrees of freedom approximations for the generalized linear mixed model in analyzing binary outcome in small sample cluster-randomized trials

Power Analysis for Cluster Randomized Trials with Binary Outcomes Modeled by Generalized Linear Mixed-Effects Models

Exact Test of Goodness of Fit for Binomial Distribution

Optimal Bayesian stepped-wedge cluster randomised trial designs for binary outcome data

Optimal exact tests for multiple binary endpoints

Distributed Estimation and Inference for Semi-parametric Binary Response Models

Marginal Regression on Transient State Occupation Probabilities with Clustered Multistate Process Data

A Simple Algorithm for Estimating Distribution Parameters from $n$-Dimensional Randomized Binary Responses

Model Averaging for Estimating Treatment Effects With Binary Responses

A Non-Parametric Sequential Procedure for the Generalized Partition Problem

Nonparametric Method for Clustered Data in Pre-Post Factorial Design

Saddlepoint approximation for weighted log-rank tests based on block truncated binomial design

The impact of clustering binary data on relative risk towards a study of inferential methods

Approximating Partial Likelihood Estimators via Optimal Subsampling

An optimal exact confidence interval for the difference of two independent binomial proportions

A variable clustering approach for overdispersed high-dimensional count data using a copula-based mixture model

Intent-to-treat Analysis of Cluster Randomized Trials when Clusters Report Unidentifiable Outcome Proportions.

A Randomized Exchange Algorithm for Optimal Design of Multi-Response Experiments