World-Class Universities: An Exploration of the Transnational Convergence Process
Olivier Bégin-Caouette
2013-01-22
Abstract:Since the creation of the first ranking of world universities in 2003, universities are engaged in a global competition based on reputation and scientific production (Liu & Cheng, 2005). These rankings have become private governance mechanisms of the globalization of universities as well as tools for quality assurance, accountability and knowledge diplomacy (Olds, 2009). Benefiting from an increasing popularity among governments, institutions, professors and students, world university rankings have caused a transnational convergence process (Hassenteufel, 2008; Vught, 2008) by using specific indicators and henceforth promoting corresponding practices. Deem, Mok and Lucas (2008) even argue that these indicators have fostered the construction of a new ideal type: the Emerging Global Model of Universities. Using Sassen’s (2005) concept of spatial scales and Steiner-Khamsi’s (2010) theory of policy borrowing and lending, this presentation will analyze the impact of these global mechanisms on sub-national units, i.e. the universities. The analysis reveals five levels of convergence: archetypical, programmatic, organizational, cybernetic (governance), and linguistic. Indeed, univesities must deal with a new ideal type (the Emerging Global Model); the Licence-Master-Doctorate reform in Europe; the pressure to become "real universities"; a greater autonomy granted by the State; and a pressure to work, publish and teach in English. It is worth noting that this presentation will pay special attention to non-Anglophone and emerging countries as well as to non-university higher education instutions.
Political Science,Education