Abstract:In their classic accounts, anthropological ethnographers developed causal arguments for how specific sociocultural structures and processes shaped human thought, behavior, and experience in particular settings. Despite this history, many contemporary ethnographers avoid establishing in their work direct causal relationships between key variables in the way that, for example, quantitative research relying on experimental or longitudinal data might. As a result, ethnographers in anthropology and other fields have not advanced understandings of how to derive causal explanations from their data, which contrasts with a vibrant "causal revolution" unfolding in the broader social and behavioral sciences. Given this gap in understanding, we aim in the current article to clarify the potential ethnography has for illuminating causal processes related to the cultural influence on human knowledge and practice. We do so by drawing on our ongoing mixed methods ethnographic study of games, play, and avatar identities. In our ethnographic illustrations, we clarify points often left unsaid in both classic anthropological ethnographies and in more contemporary interdisciplinary theorizing on qualitative research methodologies. More specifically, we argue that for ethnographic studies to illuminate causal processes, it is helpful, first, to state the implicit strengths and logic of ethnography and, second, to connect ethnographic practice more fully to now well-developed interdisciplinary approaches to causal inference. In relation to the first point, we highlight the abductive inferential logic of ethnography. Regarding the second point, we connect the ethnographic logic of abduction to what Judea Pearl has called the ladder of causality, where moving from association to intervention to what he calls counterfactual reasoning produces stronger evidence for causal processes. Further, we show how graphical modeling approaches to causal explanation can help ethnographers clarify their thinking. Overall, we offer an alternative vision of ethnography, which contrasts, but nevertheless remains consistent with, currently more dominant interpretive approaches.

The Construction of Causal Schemes: Learning Mechanisms at the Knowledge Level

Conceptual Change in a Microcosm: Comparative Learning Analysis of a Learning Event

The Magic of Mechanism: Explanation-Based Instruction on Counterintuitive Concepts in Early Childhood

Progression toward Causal Mechanistic Reasoning through Phenomenon-Based Learning in Introductory Chemistry

Tunnel Effects in Cognition: A new Mechanism for Scientific Discovery and Education

Inhibiting intuition: Scaffolding children's theory construction about species evolution in the face of competing explanations

Towards Understanding How Machines Can Learn Causal Overhypotheses

Epistemological perspectives on conceptual change: Implications for educational practice

Causal inference in ethnographic research: Refining explanations with abductive logic, strength of evidence assessments, and graphical models

Causality, Causal Discovery, and Causal Inference in Structural Engineering

Conceptual change in science and in science education

Causal learning by infants and young children: From computational theories to language practices

Exploring Mechanistic Reasoning in Chemistry

Systems with Switching Causal Relations: A Meta-Causal Perspective

Causal Curiosity: RL Agents Discovering Self-supervised Experiments for Causal Representation Learning

The Causal-Neural Connection: Expressiveness, Learnability, and Inference

Causal Abstraction: A Theoretical Foundation for Mechanistic Interpretability

Multiple Conceptual Coherences in the Speed Tutorial: Micro-processes of Local Stability

Nonlinearity, Feedback and Uniform Consistency in Causal Structural Learning

Seeking instructional specificity: an example from analogical instruction