Abstract:Most work on causality in machine learning assumes that causal relationships are driven by a constant underlying process. However, the flexibility of agents' actions or tipping points in the environmental process can change the qualitative dynamics of the system. As a result, new causal relationships may emerge, while existing ones change or disappear, resulting in an altered causal graph. To analyze these qualitative changes on the causal graph, we propose the concept of meta-causal states, which groups classical causal models into clusters based on equivalent qualitative behavior and consolidates specific mechanism parameterizations. We demonstrate how meta-causal states can be inferred from observed agent behavior, and discuss potential methods for disentangling these states from unlabeled data. Finally, we direct our analysis towards the application of a dynamical system, showing that meta-causal states can also emerge from inherent system dynamics, and thus constitute more than a context-dependent framework in which mechanisms emerge only as a result of external factors.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in machine learning, most research on causality assumes that causality is driven by a constant underlying process. However, in real - world environments, the behavioral flexibility of agents or turning points in environmental processes can change the qualitative dynamics of the system, leading to the emergence of new causal relationships, the change or disappearance of existing causal relationships, and thus changing the causal graph. Therefore, this paper proposes a new concept - meta - causal states - for analyzing the impact of these qualitative changes on the causal graph. Meta - causal states cluster classical causal models into groups with equivalent qualitative behaviors and integrate the parameterization of specific mechanisms. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to infer meta - causal states from observed agent behaviors and discusses potential methods for decoupling these states from unlabeled data. In addition, the paper also explores the application of meta - causal states in dynamic systems, showing that meta - causal states are not only a framework that depends on external factors but can also be generated by the intrinsic dynamics of the system. The main contributions of the paper include: 1. For the first time, formally introduce the type mechanism of edges in the generalized causal graph and provide a formal definition of the meta - causal model (MCM) that can capture the dynamic of causal mechanism switching types. 2. Propose a method for finding the number of meta - causal states in the two - variable case. 3. Show that the meta - causal model may be more powerful than the classical structural causal model (SCM) in expressing qualitative differences in certain system dynamics. 4. Illustrate that meta - causal analysis can lead to root cause attributions different from classical causal reasoning and can identify the causes of mechanism changes even in the absence of actual effect changes. Through these contributions, the paper aims to provide a new perspective for understanding the changes in causality in complex systems, especially in cases involving agent behavior and environmental dynamic changes.

Systems with Switching Causal Relations: A Meta-Causal Perspective

Disentangled Representations for Causal Cognition

Causal Modeling of Dynamical Systems

Causal Machine Learning: A Survey and Open Problems

On Causality in Distributed Continuum Systems

Causal Analysis of an Agent-Based Model of Human Behaviour

Causal Modeling in Multi-Context Systems: Distinguishing Multiple Context-Specific Causal Graphs which Account for Observational Support

Causal Abstraction: A Theoretical Foundation for Mechanistic Interpretability

Using Causal Threads to Explain Changes in a Dynamic System

Identifying Nonstationary Causal Structures with High-Order Markov Switching Models

Unified Causality Analysis Based on the Degrees of Freedom

Causal Reasoning from Meta-reinforcement Learning

Quantum causal modelling

Causal inference for process understanding in Earth sciences

Causal Deep Learning

Causal Discovery and Forecasting in Nonstationary Environments with State-Space Models

Causality in Neural Networks -- An Extended Abstract

Complete Inference of Causal Relations between Dynamical Systems

Language-Based Causal Representation Learning

Emergence and Causality in Complex Systems: A Survey on Causal Emergence and Related Quantitative Studies

Diagrammatic Modelling of Causality and Causal Relations