The impact of detergent performance on sustainable consumer laundry behavior; a socio-technical challenge

Debora Miranda Cortez,Martin Ter Bekke,Zhiwu Liang,Rainer Stamminger
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/tsd-2023-2575
2024-03-09
Tenside Surfactants Detergents
Abstract:The laundry process is energy-intensive and an important target for reducing residential environmental impacts. Category life-cycle analysis (LCA) studies show the primary environmental impact is due to the energy consumed during the use phase, mainly for heating water. However, doing the laundry is a complex socio-technical system, where addressing sustainability requires not only technical levers but also an understanding of users' habits, practices, and belief systems. This study investigates if and how consumers change their laundry habits and product satisfaction when using a technically lower-performing eco-brand detergent compared to a heavy duty high-performance detergent. These represent two distinct sustainable innovation strategies within the detergent industry, i) high-performance detergents formulated to provide excellent cleaning performance at lower wash temperatures and ii) eco-brand detergents optimized for a lower ingredient footprint but reducing cleaning performance. It is hypothesized that consumers may compensate in ways detrimental to the overall sustainability of the laundry lifecycle. The results showed significantly lower consumer satisfaction with the eco-brand performance which led to compensatory behavior including increased detergent dosing and higher wash temperatures. This study confirms the importance of detergent cleaning performance for sustainable consumer habit changes regarding lower wash temperatures.
engineering, chemical,chemistry, applied, physical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the impact of detergent performance on consumer habits in sustainable laundry behavior. Specifically, the study explores the performance differences and their effects on consumer satisfaction and laundry habits between two different types of detergents—high-performance heavy-duty detergent (HDD) and eco-friendly brand detergent (EBD)—through a blind intervention experiment. ### Main Issues: 1. **Consumer Satisfaction**: Is there a difference in overall acceptance between high-performance heavy-duty detergent and eco-friendly brand detergent? How do consumers perceive the performance of these two detergents differently? 2. **Changes in Laundry Behavior**: Do consumers exhibit different laundry behaviors when using different test detergents? This includes aspects such as detergent dosage, washing temperature, and the use of additional products. 3. **Attribution of Behavior Changes**: Are consumers aware that their behavior changes are caused by the test detergents? ### Research Background: - Laundry is an energy-intensive process with significant environmental impact. - The socio-technical system is complex, and achieving sustainability requires not only technical improvements but also an understanding of users' habits, practices, and belief systems. - The study hypothesizes that low-performance eco-friendly detergents may lead consumers to engage in compensatory behaviors, such as increasing detergent dosage or raising water temperature, thereby offsetting the potential benefits of eco-friendly detergents. ### Experimental Design: - A 12-week study was conducted with 69 French consumers, divided into two groups: one using high-performance heavy-duty detergent and the other using eco-friendly brand detergent. - Data were collected through diary records and questionnaires to assess overall consumer satisfaction and specific attribute evaluations of the two detergents. - Changes in laundry habits were analyzed, including detergent dosage, water temperature, and the use of additional products. ### Overview of Results: - Consumers using eco-friendly brand detergent had significantly lower overall satisfaction compared to those using high-performance heavy-duty detergent. - Consumers exhibited compensatory behaviors such as increasing detergent dosage and raising water temperature when using eco-friendly brand detergent. - These results confirm the importance of detergent cleaning performance in promoting consumer adoption of low-temperature washing. In summary, this paper aims to reveal how the performance of different detergents affects consumer laundry behavior and its implications for sustainability.