Abstract:BACKGROUND: In prospective experimental studies of neck pain patients, it is difficult to determine whether responses to sham acupuncture differ from responses to real acupuncture due to the heterogeneous methodologies in control/sham interventions. Here we aim to compare the specific and nonspecific effects of electroacupuncture with four types of sham acupuncture.METHODS: In this double-blind, sham-controlled study, we randomly assigned 175 patients with neck pain to receive 10 sessions of electroacupuncture, shallow puncture, nonacupoint deep puncture, nonacupoint shallow puncture, or nonpenetration acupuncture. We used the Northwick Park Neck Pain Questionnaire (NPQ) as our primary outcome, and Short-form McGill Pain Questionnaire, visual analog scale (VAS), and Pain Threshold as secondary outcomes to measure the changes from baseline to a 3-month follow up.RESULTS: All groups, except nonacupoint shallow puncture, had significant improvement in all outcome measurements. Electroacupuncture only showed superior improvements than the shallow puncture, nonacupoint shallow puncture, and nonpenetration groups when compared using the NPQ and VAS scale (*p < 0.001). Interestingly, the nonacupoint shallow puncture produced even less placebo response than nonpenetration acupuncture.CONCLUSION: Our study demonstrates the high variability of placebo response among different types of sham controls depending on the depth of needle insertion and the puncture location. An important implication of our results is nonacupoint deep puncture produced similar analgesic effects as electroacupuncture. Our study may shed a new light on the predominant underlying mechanisms among different types of sham acupuncture controls, which can help with interpreting the effect of acupuncture in other studies.TRIAL REGISTRATION: Chinese clinical trial registry (ChiCTR-IOR-15006886).SIGNIFICANCE: This study compared the observed specific and nonspecific analgesia effect in four different types of sham acupuncture stimulation with neck pain patients, assessed by four outcomes. Although all of the sham controls produced significant reduction in neck pain, electroacupuncture had superior significant improvement. Importantly, placebo responses differed significantly between the sham controls and responses were inconsistent according to different outcome assessments. This study emphasizes the importance of taking into consideration which sham control and method of outcome measurement were used in a pain research study when evaluating its results.

Patients’ perceptions on non‐specific effects of acupuncture: Qualitative comparison between responders and non‐responders

Non-specific effects of acupuncture and sham acupuncture in clinical trials from the patient’s perspective: a systematic review of qualitative evidence

Fecal microbiota as a predictor of acupuncture responses in patients with postpartum depressive disorder

[Progress of researches on non-specific effect of acupuncture]

Randomised clinical trial: an assessment of acupuncture on specific meridian or specific acupoint vs. sham acupuncture for treating functional dyspepsia

Factors influencing participant compliance in acupuncture trials: An in-depth interview study

Neural Responses of Acupuncture for Treating Functional Dyspepsia: An fMRI Study

Su1425: PLACEBO RESPONSE RATES IN ACUPUNCTURE THERAPY TRIALS FOR FUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA: A META ANALYSIS

Understanding Placebo and Nocebo Responses Based on a Randomized Sham-Controlled Study on Acupuncture in Integrative Cancer Care

Influence of acupuncture treatment on cerebral activity in functional dyspepsia patients and its relationship with efficacy.

Individualized Acupuncture for Symptom Relief in Functional Dyspepsia: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Factors related to acupuncture response in patients with chronic severe functional constipation: Secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial

What makes one respond to acupuncture for insomnia? Perspectives of cancer survivors

Effect of acupuncture and its influence on cerebral activity in functional dyspepsia patients: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

The central mechanism of acupuncture treatment with a long-lasting effect for functional dyspepsia: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

Effect of electroacupuncture on discomfort during gastroscopy: A randomised controlled trial

Psychological and neurological predictors of acupuncture effect in patients with chronic pain: a randomized controlled neuroimaging trial

Factors Associated with the Magnitude Of acUpuncture treatment effectS (FAMOUS): a meta-epidemiological study of acupuncture randomised controlled trials

Placebo response varies between different types of sham acupuncture: A randomized double‐blind trial in neck pain patients

A clinical audit in a UK-based acupuncture private practice: assessing patient demographics, outcomes and experience

Acupuncture: Theory, Efficacy, and Practice