Abstract:The 2008–2009 Global Financial Crisis (GFC) has swayed regulators to set forth the Solvency II agreement for determining Solvency Capital Requirement (SCR) for insurance companies. In this paper, we apply novel internal models to investigate whether the latest version of the Solvency II standard model demands sufficient capital charges, both in normal and stressed times, for the different risk categories included in bond and stock portfolios. Because the GFC has shown that extreme events on the tail of probability distributions can occur quite often, our empirical findings indicate that the magnitude of the equity risk using the GJR–EVT–Copula method requires insurers to keep more SCR for stock portfolios than the Solvency II standard model. In the case of a bond portfolio, we conclude that the Solvency II standard model requires approximately the same SCR as our internal model for the higher quality and longer maturity bonds, whereas the standard model overestimates SCR for the lower quality and shorter maturity bonds. At the same time, the standard model underestimates interest-rate risk and overestimates spread risk. Overall, the discrepancies in the estimated SCRs between the Solvency II standard technique and our internal models increase as the level of the risks rise for both stock and bond markets. Our empirical results are in line with other competing internal modeling techniques regarding stock market investment and bond portfolios with the higher quality and longer maturity bonds, while for the lower quality and shorter maturity bonds, the results contradict other modeling procedures. The obtained empirical results are interesting in terms of theory and practical applications and have important implication for compliance with the Solvency II capital requirements. Likewise, it can be of interest to insurance regulators, policymakers, actuaries, and researchers within the field of insurance and risk management.

Parameter uncertainty and reserve risk under Solvency II

Parameter uncertainty for integrated risk capital calculations based on normally distributed subrisks

The Quality of Reserve Risk Calculation Models under Solvency II and IFRS 17

A three dimensional stochastic Model for Claim Reserving

Measuring market and credit risk under Solvency II: evaluation of the standard technique versus internal models for stock and bond markets

Forecasting reserve risk for temporal dependent losses in insurance

Modeling surrender risk in life insurance: theoretical and experimental insight

Estimation of Operational Risk Capital Charge under Parameter Uncertainty

Stochastic Loss Reserving: Dependence and Estimation

Modellvalidierung mit Hilfe von Quantil-Quantil-Plots unter Solvency II (Model validation on the basis of quantile-quantile-plots under Solvency II)

Quantifying Life Insurance Risk using Least-Squares Monte Carlo

Comparison of Stochastic Claims Reserving Models in Insurance

Analyzing the Impact of Time Horizon, Volatility and Profit Margins on Solvency Capital: Proposing a New Model for the Global Regulation of the Insurance Industry

Capital Requirements for Cyber Risk and Cyber Risk Insurance: An Analysis of Solvency II, the U.S. Risk-Based Capital Standards, and the Swiss Solvency Test

Solvency assessment within the ORSA framework: issues and quantitative methodologies

Multi-year analysis of solvency capital in life insurance

The Quantification of Operational Risk using Internal Data, Relevant External Data and Expert Opinions

On the impact of outliers in loss reserving

Addressing the Impact of Data Truncation and Parameter Uncertainty on Operational Risk Estimates

A bridge between Local GAAP and Solvency II frameworks to quantify Capital Requirement for demographic risk

Practice-relevant model validation: distributional parameter risk analysis in financial model risk management