The risk of complaints against occupational physicians to the medical regulatory body in Ireland

Deirdre Gleeson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/occmed/kqad136

2024-04-26

Occupational Medicine

Abstract:Complaints against doctors to regulators are increasing in all jurisdictions. Occupational physicians (OPs) are at increased risk of complaint due to the unique doctor–patient relationship and the dual obligations of the role. OPs may become embroiled in third-party disputes and must be clear that their role is an advisor to the decision-maker, but not the decision-maker. OPs require training in how to reduce, cope with and defend against complaints to regulators.

public, environmental & occupational health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the issue of the risk of complaints faced by Occupational Physicians (OPs) to medical regulatory bodies. Specifically, the article focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Complaint Trends**: In recent years, complaints against doctors have been on the rise, especially in Ireland and the UK. Although the number of complaints decreased during the initial phase of the COVID-19 pandemic, it subsequently resumed its growth.

2. **Cultural Background of Complaints**: Factors such as increased patient expectations and the growing complexity of medical services have led to the current "complaint culture." Additionally, patients are becoming more aware of their rights and are less tolerant of unprofessional behavior.

3. **Unique Position of Occupational Physicians**: The work of occupational physicians involves assessing employees' health to determine their fitness for work or eligibility for benefits. Since they typically do not establish a therapeutic relationship with patients but rather conduct evaluations, they occupy a unique position when handling disputes between patients and third parties (such as employers, insurance companies, etc.).

4. **Risk of Complaints**: Occupational physicians face a higher risk of complaints due to the special nature of their work. When they do not support specific patient requests (such as returning to work or continuing sick leave), patients may become dissatisfied and file complaints.

5. **Impact on Occupational Physicians**: Receiving complaints can cause significant emotional stress for doctors, severely affecting their mental health. Studies show that doctors under investigation have a higher risk of suicide.

6. **Resolution Suggestions**: The article offers several suggestions to address this issue, including improving the complaint handling process, enhancing training, and helping occupational physicians better understand how to reduce and respond to complaints.

In summary, this paper aims to analyze the complaint risks faced by occupational physicians, the underlying reasons, and proposes some possible solutions.