Framing tough problems Wicked Problems: How to Engineer a Better World Guru Madhavan Norton, 2024. 384 pp.

Donna Riley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.ado0913

IF: 56.9

2024-03-30

Science

Abstract:An engineer urges readers to think more holistically about complex challenges

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Tackling 'wicked' problems calls for engineers with social responsibility

Susan Krumdieck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-01519-1

IF: 64.8

2024-05-28

Nature

Abstract:Many technologies are high-risk, and their problems cannot be fixed by policy alone; engineers must embrace social responsibility. Many technologies are high-risk, and their problems cannot be fixed by policy alone; engineers must embrace social responsibility.

multidisciplinary sciences
Reframing Engineering Design: Integrating Design Thinking and Systems Thinking in Engineering Education and Practice to Address Wicked Problems

Eric Wilson,David Dunne,Terry Bergen,Phalguni Mukhopadhyaya

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1139/cjce-2023-0433

2024-04-22

Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering

Abstract:The conceptualization of ‘engineering design’, as outlined by the Canadian Engineering Accreditation Board (CEAB), has shifted over the years, however, a gap in engineering education remains A prevailing deficiency in engineering education and practice lies in the exclusion of non-technical competencies (such as empathy, communication, innovation, and creativity) that are impeding engineers from effectively addressing complex issues. These frameworks offer a robust methodology for tackling complex, dynamic, and interconnected challenges—referred to as "wicked problems." In addition, this paper proposes a fourth-year engineering design course that explicitly incorporates these approaches, addressing the identified gap in social competencies within engineering education. By integrating these approaches into the foundation of engineering design education, there may be an avenue to equip engineers with the skills needed to empathize with stakeholders, understand contextual landscapes and generate meaningful solutions that contribute positively to society.

engineering, civil
Wicked Problem Solvers

Amy C Edmondson

Abstract:Companies today increasingly rely on teams that span many industries for radical innovation, especially to solve "wicked problems." So leaders have to understand how to promote collaboration when roles are uncertain, goals are shifting, expertise and organizational cultures are varied, and participants have clashing or even antagonistic perspectives. HBS professor Amy Edmondson has studied more than a dozen cross-industry innovation projects, among them the creation of a new city, a mango supply-chain transformation, and the design and construction of leading-edge buildings. She has identified the leadership practices that make successful cross-industry teams work: fostering an adaptable vision, promoting psychological safety, enabling knowledge sharing, and encouraging collaborative innovation. Though these practices are broadly familiar, their application within cross-industry teams calls for unique leadership approaches that combine flexibility, open-mindedness, humility, and fierce resolve.
Envisioning a radical future Imagination: A Manifesto Ruha Benjamin Norton, 2024. 192 pp.

Victor Ray

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adn3943

IF: 56.9

2024-02-02

Science

Abstract:A more inclusive society begins with imagining audacious alternatives to today's systems, argues a sociologist

multidisciplinary sciences
Self-reflection for Activist Engineering

Darshan M A Karwat

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11948-019-00150-y

Abstract:Many blame politicians, governments, and markets for the technically-driven problems the world faces (think war, climate change, surveillance, disinformation, and so on). But why is it that there are almost always engineers and corporations willing to design and build the technologies that cause those problems, many times in spite of knowing about the negative consequences of those technologies? I offer in this paper practical guidance on how to engage in activist engineering, the goal of which is to get engineers to step back from their work and be able to ask and have a conversation about the question, "What is the real problem, and does this problem 'require' an engineering solution?" Building on research in the history and philosophy of engineering, and engineering ethics and education, as well as current events-all of which highlight important issues of debate within engineering practice-I provide a list of questions that engineers can start with for self-reflection to better understand their motivations for doing engineering work, and to better understand the implications of their work. The questions relate to considerations engineers must make regarding the social, environmental, economic, and peace implications of their work, and relate to alternative and non-technical interventions to the problem at hand. I believe that each engineer should, in the end, be able to answer the questions: Why am I an engineer? For whose benefit do I work? What is the full measure of my moral and social responsibility?
Entertaining audacious ideas The Weirdness of the World Eric Schwitzgebel Princeton University Press, 2024. 376 pp.

Edouard Machery

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adn0629

IF: 56.9

2024-01-26

Science

Abstract:Unbound by empiricism, a philosopher's provocative musings inspire delight and vexation

multidisciplinary sciences
Pragmatism and Care in Engineering Ethics

Indira Nair,William M. Bulleit

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11948-018-0080-y

IF: 3.777

2019-01-07

Science and Engineering Ethics

Abstract:Engineering is a practice that must function in an environment of incomplete and uncertain knowledge. This environment has become even more difficult in an increasingly complex world. Engineering ethics has to be framed and taught in a way that addresses these realities. This paper proposes a combination of the philosophy of pragmatism and the ethic of care as a possible framework for the practice of engineering ethics that can provide flexibility and openness to address engineering ethics problems more realistically within the ethos and culture of engineering. Embedding values into practice, pragmatism and care provide a broad, reflective, and corrective framework for engineering ethics that can accommodate the realities in which engineering operates. It is shown that these two approaches are more consonant with design methodologies and have a natural fit with design thinking, so they mesh well with what engineers do and with the complexities of their work today. As humans more and more try to alter the socio-techno-natural world, e.g., the earth’s climate, the combination of pragmatism and care will allow enhanced ethical behavior. Alterations to complex adaptive systems will produce highly uncertain results that require engineers to have a mindset that allows them to act with humility in the face of significant uncertainty and potential catastrophic failures.

ethics,history & philosophy of science,multidisciplinary sciences,engineering, multidisciplinary
Engineering Decision: A Remarkable Philosophical Problem

AN Wei-fu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-8934.2007.08.012

2007-01-01

Abstract:It is seen that engineering decision is to choose among programme. But this conception is incomprehensive at least. I think that the core of engineering decision is not technical problem but the problem of value that engineering decision questioning for aims, meeting the needs for person or society, majority or minority.
Confronting challenges together What If We Get it Right? Visions of Climate Futures Ayana Elizabeth Johnson One World, 2024. 496 pp.

Miriam R. Aczel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adp8863

IF: 56.9

2024-09-27

Science

Abstract:Community, collaboration, and collective action are key to moving the climate needle

multidisciplinary sciences
Manu Prakash

Vivien Marx

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41592-020-0968-8

Abstract:Frugally built technology to study the ocean’s microbes, and engineering for societal good.
Beyond Inevitability: Emphasizing the Role of Intention and Ethical Responsibility in Engineering Design

Kathryn A. Neeley,Heinz C. Luegenbiehl

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-6591-0_19

2008-01-01

Abstract:Much of how humans think about their world and their actions in relation to it is governed by the manner of their speaking. In this paper the authors argue that this has an especially significant impact on the work of engineers and their perception of ethical responsibility. A discourse framework governing the actions of engineers which focuses on the idea of technological development tends to lead toward perceptions of technological inevitability, whereas one focusing on the terminology of engineering design enhances perceptions of choice and, consequently, of individual responsibility. Perceptions of responsibility resulting from design focused discourse thus are not limited to narrow safety and production considerations, but include holistic considerations such as aesthetic and environmental factors, as well as considerations of societal implications of design choices. The authors propose that increased focus on design discourse, in both professional and public settings, will enhance a broader sense of ethical responsibility among engineers.
Empathy Enabled by Critical Design - A New Tool in the Universal Design Toolbox

Anne Britt Torkildsby

Abstract:The next generation of designers, architects, engineers, etc. have a rough road ahead. Due to their strong role in shaping our future, they must face issues relating to inclusion, equality, and diversity, ensuring that the 'Elder Boom' generation have safe, useful, and independent housing, workplaces are planned and constructed in such a way that they are usable by the broader population, and social justice and equality are in focus when designing public buildings and spaces so as to eliminate prejudice and discrimination. This implies that the built environment as we know it must be improved. Thus, those responsible for addressing upcoming challenges, i.e. future universal design thinkers, must be adequately equipped with various methodological tools and valuable experience of interdisciplinary work. Both aspects are essential to preparing them for real-life problems and projects, regardless of complexity. What happens if architecture, interior architecture, engineering, and product design students spend a week together investigating the built environment from a critical design point of view? Can this upside-down way of thinking provide them with alternative starting points for the problem-solving process, and help them to identify and understand people's needs differently? This paper describes a critical design method and presents the results of and lessons learned from conducting a one-week workshop based on this method. The outcomes of the workshop (critical design examples) were created to illuminate the built environment and so provide the students with first-hand experience of what can happen if the "dark side" of design thinking is ignored.
Tackling wicked problems in strategic management with systems thinking

Sylvia Grewatsch,Steve Kennedy,Pratima Bansal,Pratima (Tima) Bansal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/14761270211038635

2021-08-21

Strategic Organization

Abstract:Strategy scholars are increasingly attempting to tackle complex global social and environmental issues (i.e. wicked problems); yet, many strategy scholars approach these wicked problems in the same way they approach business problems—by building causal models that seek to optimize some form of organizational success. Strategy scholars seek to reduce complexity, focusing on the significant variables that explain the salient outcomes. This approach to wicked problems, ironically, divorces firms from the very social-ecological context that makes the problem “wicked.” In this essay, we argue that strategy research into wicked problems can benefit from systems thinking, which deviates radically from the reductionist approach to analysis taken by many strategy scholars. We review some of the basic tenets of systems thinking and describe their differences from reductionist thinking. Furthermore, we ask strategy scholars to widen their theoretical lens by (1) investigating co-evolutionary dynamics rather than focusing primarily on static models, (2) advancing processual insights rather than favoring causal identification, and (3) recognizing tipping points and transformative change rather than assuming linear monotonic changes.

management,business
How to build a better world

Annalee Newitz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0262-4079(24)02109-2

IF: 0.906

2024-12-02

The New Scientist

Abstract:John "Bud" Benson Wilbur isn't often remembered today, but this forgotten civil engineer had a vision of the future we could all learn from, says Annalee Newitz

multidisciplinary sciences
Taming the wicked problem of climate change with "virtuous challenges": An integrated management heuristic

David Weaver,Brent D Moyle,Char-Lee McLennan,Luca Casali

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.119136

2023-12-01

Abstract:Climate change is widely regarded as a "wicked problem" due to its complexity, interconnectedness, and the numerous stakeholders involved in finding a solution. The wickedness of climate change is further compounded by effects which are often nonlinear and uncertain, making it difficult to predict and manage its impacts. This paper builds on the growing body of knowledge on wicked problems by proposing an integrated heuristic that facilitates management in diverse economic and sociopolitical contexts by capturing the origins and dynamics of contemporary global socioenvironmental wicked problems and their potential resolution. The heuristic can also serve as the basis for a holistic wicked problem macro-theory. It is recognised that wicked problems such as climate change amplify into crisis states due to poverty and rigidity traps embedded within a system panarchy, which impede effective action for adaptation and mitigation. The concept of the "virtuous challenge" is embedded within the heuristic as a vital link in governance to enable effective leadership in the management of contemporary wicked problems through focused incremental transformation and a shift to an "agrowth" imperative. It is acknowledged that collaboration between stakeholders in the Global North and Global South is necessary for successful responses to virtuous challenges.
Go Big or Go Home? A New Case for Integrating Micro-ethics and Macro-ethics in Engineering Ethics Education

Andrew McAninch

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11948-023-00441-5

IF: 3.777

2023-05-18

Science and Engineering Ethics

Abstract:In this paper, I make a novel case for an expansive approach to engineering ethics education, one that regards micro-ethics and macro-ethics as essentially complementary. Although others have voiced support for including macro-ethical reflection within engineering ethics education, I advance a stronger claim, arguing that isolating engineering ethics from macro-level issues risks rendering even micro-ethical inquiry morally meaningless. I divide my proposal into four parts. First, I clarify the distinction between micro-ethics and macro-ethics as I am construing it, defending my characterization against a potential worry. Second, I consider but reject some arguments for a restrictive approach, one that excludes macro-ethical reflection from engineering ethics education. Third, I offer my central argument for an expansive approach. Finally, I suggest that macro-ethics education can learn something valuable from micro-ethics pedagogy. On my proposal, students consider both micro- and macro-ethical problems from the deliberative perspective, situating micro-ethical problems within a broader social framework but also situating macro-ethical problems within an engaged, practical framework. By emphasizing the value of the deliberative perspective, my proposal contributes to a growing call to broaden the scope of engineering ethics education while maintaining its practical relevance.

ethics,history & philosophy of science,multidisciplinary sciences,engineering, multidisciplinary
Engineering an Anthropocene Citizenship Framework

Shima Beigi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1508.03525

2015-07-26

Abstract:This article presents an Anthropocene citizen-cantered framework by incorporating the neuroscience of sustainability related stressors, the biology of collaboration in multi-agent ecosystems such as urban systems, and by emphasising on the importance of harnessing the collective intelligence of the crowd in addressing wicked challenges of sustainable development. The Anthropocene citizenship framework aims to transcend the cognitive model of global citizenship and sustainability to a dynamic, resilient and thriving mental model of collective cooperation.

Physics and Society,Biological Physics
Managing expectations Fluke: Chance, Chaos, and Why Everything We Do Matters Brian Klaas Scribner, 2024. 336 pp.

Michael Travisano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adn5394

IF: 56.9

2024-02-17

Science

Abstract:A political scientist urges readers to embrace the chaos and complexity of life

multidisciplinary sciences
Wicked problems in engineering education: preparing future engineers to work for sustainability

Johanna Lönngren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13504622.2019.1639038

IF: 3.725

2019-07-16

Environmental Education Research

Abstract:An important aim of environmental and sustainability education (ESE) is to prepare students for addressing complex sustainability problems (here called 'wicked problems'), such as climate change and resource management. This aim is particularly important in engineering education since technological development has profound impacts on social and environmental welfare. Unfortunately, most engineering education today does not adequately prepare students to contribute to addressing wicked problems. The thesis addressed this gap by asking: RQ1) What do engineering students need to learn to be able to address wicked problems? And RQ2) How can the ability to address wicked problems be taught and assessed in engineering education?

environmental studies,education & educational research
Managing Dilemmas Embodied in 21st Century Engineering

Salman Ahmed,Minting Xiao,Jitesh H. Panchal,Janet K. Allen,Farrokh Mistree

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1115/detc2012-71168

2012-08-12

Abstract:In this session we describe in four parts the pedagogy and out-comes of a course Designing for Open Innovation designed to empower 21st century engineering students to develop competencies associated with innovating in an inter-connected technologically flat world: 1. Competencies for Innovating in the 21st Century, [1]. 2. Developing Competencies In The 21st Century Engineer, [2]. 3. Identifying Dilemmas Embodied in 21st Century Engineering, [3]. 4. Managing Dilemmas Embodied in 21st Century Engineering - this paper. In the first paper we describe the core characteristics of the engineering in an interconnected world and identify the key competencies and meta-competencies that 21st century engineers will need to innovate and negotiate solutions to issues associated with the realization of systems. In the second paper, we describe our approach to fostering learning and the development of competencies by an individual in a group setting. We focus on empowering the students to learn how to learn as individuals in a geographically distanced, collaborative group setting. We assert that two of the core competencies required for success in the dynamically changing workplace are the competencies to first identify and then to manage dilemmas. In the third paper, we illustrate how students have gone about identifying dilemmas and in the fourth paper how they have attempted to manage dilemmas. In papers three and four students have briefly described the challenges that they faced and their takeaways in the form of team learning and individual learning. In this the last of four papers in this session, we focus on how students learned to manage dilemmas associated with the realization of complex, sustainable, socio-techno-eco systems, namely, energy policy design. The example involves the identification of a bridging fuel that balances environmental, economic and socio-cultural concerns. The principal outcome is clearly not the result attained but a student’s ability to learn how to learn as illustrated through the development of personal competencies in a collaborative learning framework and environment.

Framing tough problems Wicked Problems: How to Engineer a Better World Guru Madhavan Norton, 2024. 384 pp.

Tackling 'wicked' problems calls for engineers with social responsibility

Reframing Engineering Design: Integrating Design Thinking and Systems Thinking in Engineering Education and Practice to Address Wicked Problems

Wicked Problem Solvers

Envisioning a radical future Imagination: A Manifesto Ruha Benjamin Norton, 2024. 192 pp.

Self-reflection for Activist Engineering

Entertaining audacious ideas The Weirdness of the World Eric Schwitzgebel Princeton University Press, 2024. 376 pp.

Pragmatism and Care in Engineering Ethics

Engineering Decision: A Remarkable Philosophical Problem

Confronting challenges together What If We Get it Right? Visions of Climate Futures Ayana Elizabeth Johnson One World, 2024. 496 pp.

Manu Prakash

Beyond Inevitability: Emphasizing the Role of Intention and Ethical Responsibility in Engineering Design

Empathy Enabled by Critical Design - A New Tool in the Universal Design Toolbox

Tackling wicked problems in strategic management with systems thinking

How to build a better world

Taming the wicked problem of climate change with "virtuous challenges": An integrated management heuristic

Go Big or Go Home? A New Case for Integrating Micro-ethics and Macro-ethics in Engineering Ethics Education

Engineering an Anthropocene Citizenship Framework

Managing expectations Fluke: Chance, Chaos, and Why Everything We Do Matters Brian Klaas Scribner, 2024. 336 pp.

Wicked problems in engineering education: preparing future engineers to work for sustainability

Managing Dilemmas Embodied in 21st Century Engineering