Abstract:Semantic memory representations are generally well maintained in aging, whereas semantic control is thought to be more affected. To explain this phenomenon, this study tested the predictions of the Compensation-Related Utilization of Neural Circuits Hypothesis (CRUNCH), focusing on task demands in aging as a possible framework. The CRUNCH effect would manifest itself in semantic tasks through a compensatory increase in neural activation in semantic control network regions but only up to a certain threshold of task demands. This study compares 39 younger (20-35 years old) with 39 older participants (60-75 years old) in a triad-based semantic judgment task performed in an fMRI scanner while manipulating task demand levels (low versus high) through semantic distance. In line with the CRUNCH predictions, differences in neurofunctional activation and behavioral performance (accuracy and response times) were expected in younger versus older participants in the low- versus high-demand conditions, which should be manifested in semantic control Regions of Interest (ROIs). Our older participants had intact behavioral performance, as proposed in the literature for semantic memory tasks (maintained accuracy and slower response times (RTs)). Age-invariant behavioral performance in the older group compared to the younger one is necessary to test the CRUNCH predictions. The older adults were also characterized by high cognitive reserve, as our neuropsychological tests showed. Our behavioral results confirmed that our task successfully manipulated task demands: error rates, RTs and perceived difficulty increased with increasing task demands in both age groups. We did not find an interaction between age group and task demand, or a statistically significant difference in activation between the low- and high-demand conditions for either RTs or accuracy. As for brain activation, we did not find the expected age group by task demand interaction, or a significant main effect of task demand. Overall, our results are compatible with some neural activation in the semantic network and the semantic control network, largely in frontotemporoparietal regions. ROI analyses demonstrated significant effects (but no interactions) of task demand in the left and right inferior frontal gyrus, the left posterior middle temporal gyrus, the posterior inferior temporal gyrus and the prefrontal gyrus. Overall, our test did not confirm the CRUNCH predictions.

Age-related similarities and differences in cognitive and neural processing revealed by task-related microstate analysis

Spatiotemporal EEG Dynamics of Prospective Memory in Ageing and Mild Cognitive Impairment

Age-related modulation of EEG time-frequency responses in prospective memory retrieval

Age-Related Frontoparietal Changes During the Control of Bottom-Up and Top-Down Attention: an Erp Study

Age-related changes in MEG theta and alpha oscillatory signatures of attentional control

Age-Related Differences in Prestimulus EEG Affect ERPs and Behaviour in the Equiprobable Go/NoGo Task

Effects of Aging on Working Memory Performance and Prefrontal Cortex Activity: A Time-Resolved Spectroscopy Study

Age differences in the neural processing of semantics, within and beyond the core semantic network

Age-related differences in resting-state, task-related, and structural brain connectivity: graph theoretical analyses and visual search performance

EEG Biomarkers of Age-Related Memory Change

Lifespan differences in visual short-term memory load-modulated functional connectivity

Age-Related Alterations in Electroencephalography Connectivity and Network Topology During n-Back Working Memory Task.

Age-related changes in neural oscillations supporting context memory retrieval

Registered report: Age-preserved semantic memory and the CRUNCH effect manifested as differential semantic control networks: An fMRI study

Age differences in the principal temporo-spatial components of EEG activity during a proactive interference task.

Age-Dependent Differences in Human Brain Activity Using a Face- and Location-Matching Task: An fMRI Study

Age-related Changes in Topological Patterns of Large-Scale Brain Functional Networks During Memory Encoding and Recognition

Investigating Age-Related Neural Compensation During Emotion Perception Using Electroencephalography

Effects of aging on functional connectivity in a neurodegenerative risk cohort: resting state versus task measurement using near-infrared spectroscopy

Electrophysiological correlates of selective attention: A lifespan comparison

Age-related Differences in Response Inhibition Are Mediated by Frontoparietal White Matter But Not Functional Activity