Abstract:Abstract Species distribution models (SDMs) are an increasingly popular tool in ecology which, together with a vast wealth of data from citizen science projects, have the potential to dramatically improve our understanding of species behaviour for applications such as conservation and wildlife management. However, many of the best performing models require information regarding survey effort, specifically absence, which is typically lacking in opportunistic datasets. To facilitate the use of such models, pseudo-absences from locations without recorded presence must be assumed. Several studies have suggested that survey effort, and hence likely absence, could be estimated from presence-only data by considering records across “target groups” of species defined according to taxonomy. We performed a probabilistic analysis, computing the conditional probability of recording a species given a particular set of species are also recorded, to test the validity of defining target groups by taxonomic order and to explore other potential groupings. Based on this quantification of recording associations we outline a new method to inform pseudo-absence selection comparing predictive performance, measured the area under curve (AUC) statistic, against the standard method of selection across a series of SDMs. Our findings show some support for target grouping classification based on taxonomy but indicate that an alternative classification using survey method may be more appropriate for informing effort and consequently absence. Across 49 terrestrial mammal species, pseudo-absence selection using our proposed method outperformed that of the standard method showing an improvement in the predictive performance of presence-absence models for 17 out of 22 with sufficient data to elicit a significant difference. Based on our method we also observed a substantial improvement in the performance of presence-absence models compared to that of presence-only models (MaxEnt) with a higher AUC for all 22 species showing a significant difference between approaches. We conclude that our method produces sensible robust pseudo-absences which either compliment patterns in known presences or, where conflicts occur, are explainable in terms of ecological variables potentially improving our understanding of species behaviour. Furthermore, we suggest that presence-absence models using these pseudo-absences provide a viable alternative to MaxEnt when modelling using presence-only data.

Determining representative pseudo-absences for invasive plant distribution modeling based on geographic similarity

Structuring the unstructured: estimating species-specific absence from multi-species presence data to inform pseudo-absence selection in species distribution models

Can We Model the Probability of Presence of Species Without Absence Data?

A new method of pseudo absence data generation in landslide susceptibility mapping with a case study of Shenzhen

Projecting future expansion of invasive species: comparing and improving methodologies for species distribution modeling

Determinants of the Geographical Extent of Invasive Plants in China: Effects of Biogeographical Origin, Life Cycle and Time Since Introduction

How to assess the prediction accuracy of species presence-absence models without absence data?

Dealing with sampling bias and inferring absence data to improve distribution models of a widely distributed vulnerable marsupial

Partial differential equation models for invasive species spread in the presence of spatial heterogeneity

Distribution Patterns and Determinants of Invasive Alien Plants in China.

Species distribution models for invasive Eurasian watermilfoil highlight the importance of data quality and limitations of discrimination accuracy metrics

Evaluating presence-absence models in ecology: the need to account for prevalence

Predicting the distribution of out-of-reach biotopes with decision trees in a Swedish marine protected area

Study on selecting sensitive environmental variables in modelling species spatial distribution.

Poisson point process models solve the "pseudo-absence problem" for presence-only data in ecology

Spatial Distribution Patterns of Invasive Alien Species in China

Estimating Abundance from Presence/absence Maps

Application of a Negative Multinomial Model Gives Insight into Rarity-Area Relationships

A Similarity-Based Approach to Sampling Absence Data for Landslide Susceptibility Mapping Using Data-Driven Methods

Constructing indicator species distribution models to study the potential invasion risk of invasive plants: A case of the invasion of Parthenium hysterophorus in China