Abstract:Introduction: 4D flow cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) is a versatile technique to non-invasively assess cardiovascular hemodynamics. With developing technology, choice in sequences and acquisition parameters is expanding and it is important to assess if data acquired with these different variants can be directly compared, especially when combining datasets within research studies. For example, sequences may allow a choice in gating techniques or be limited to one method, yet there is not a direct comparison investigating how gating selection impacts quantifications of the great vessels, semilunar and atrioventricular valves and ventricles. Thus, this study investigated if quantifications across the heart from contemporary 4D flow sequences are comparable between two commonly used 4D flow sequences reliant on different ECG gating techniques. Methods: Forty participants (33 healthy controls, seven patients with coronary artery disease and abnormal diastolic function) were prospectively recruited into a single-centre observational study to undergo a 3T-CMR exam. Two acquisitions, a k-t GRAPPA 4D flow with prospective gating (4Dprosp) and a modern compressed sensing 4D flow with retrospective gating (4Dretro), were acquired in each participant. Images were analyzed for volumes, flow rates and velocities in the vessels and four valves, and for biventricular kinetic energy and flow components. Data was compared for group differences with paired t-tests and for agreement with Bland-Altman and intraclass correlation (ICC). Results: Measurements primarily occurring during systole of the great vessels, semilunar valves and both left and right ventricles did not differ between acquisition types (p > 0.05 from t-test) and yielded good to excellent agreement (ICC: 0.75-0.99). Similar findings were observed for the majority of parameters dependent on early diastole. However, measurements occurring in late diastole or those reliant on the entire-cardiac cycle such as flow component volumes along with diastolic kinetic energy values were not similar between 4Dprosp and 4Dretro acquisitions resulting in poor agreement (ICC < 0.50). Discussion: Direct comparison of measurements between two different 4D flow acquisitions reliant on different gating methods demonstrated systolic and early diastolic markers across the heart should be compatible when comparing these two 4D flow sequences. On the other hand, late diastolic and intraventricular parameters should be compared with caution.

Fully Automated Valve Segmentation for Blood Flow Assessment From 4D Flow MRI Including Automated Cardiac Valve Tracking and Transvalvular Velocity Mapping

Characterization and improved quantification of left ventricular inflow using streamline visualization with 4DFlow MRI in healthy controls and patients after atrioventricular septal defect correction

Automated Quantification of Simple and Complex Aortic Flow Using 2D Phase Contrast MRI

Coronary Flow Assessment Using Accelerated 4D Flow MRI With Respiratory Motion Correction

A Systematic Review of 4D-Flow MRI Derived Mitral Regurgitation Quantification Methods

Quantifying aortic valve regurgitation in patients with congenital aortic valve disease by 2D and 4D flow magnetic resonance analysis

Automatic 4D Flow MRI Segmentation Using the Standardized Difference of Means Velocity

Tricuspid valve flow measurement using a deep learning framework for automated valve‐tracking 2D phase contrast

Novel contouring method for optimizing MRI flow quantification in patients with aortic valve disease

Automated left atrial time-resolved segmentation in MRI long-axis cine images using active contours

The Role of 2, 4, and 5‐dimensional Cardiac Flow MRI for Evaluation of Valvulopathies: A Literature Review

Fully-automatic left ventricular segmentation from long-axis cardiac cine MR scans

Assessment of paravalvular regurgitation after transcatheter aortic valve replacement using 2D multi-venc and 4D flow CMR

Evaluation of left ventricular and left atrial volumetric function from native MR multislice 4D flow magnitude data

The influence of post-processing software on quantitative results in 4D flow cardiovascular magnetic resonance examinations

Assessing Aortic Motion with Automated 3D Cine Balanced SSFP MRI Segmentation

Direct comparison of whole heart quantifications between different retrospective and prospective gated 4D flow CMR acquisitions

4D flow magnetic resonance imaging evaluation after transcatheter closure of sinus venosus defects

Super-resolution 4D flow MRI to quantify aortic regurgitation using computational fluid dynamics and deep learning

Left atrium 4D-flow segmentation with high-resolution contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance angiography

Deep learning based automated left ventricle segmentation and flow quantification in 4D flow cardiac MRI