Abstract:Due to the large number of different docking programs and scoring functions available, researchers are faced with the problem of selecting the most suitable one when starting a structure-based drug discovery project. To guide the decision process, several studies comparing different docking and scoring approaches have been published. In the context of comparing scoring function performance, it is common practice to use a predefined, computer-generated set of ligand poses (decoys) and to reevaluate their score using the set of scoring functions to be compared. But are predefined decoy sets able to unambiguously evaluate and rank different scoring functions with respect to pose prediction performance? This question arose when the pose prediction performance of our piecewise linear potential derived scoring functions (Korb et al. in J Chem Inf Model 49:84–96, 2009) was assessed on a standard decoy set (Cheng et al. in J Chem Inf Model 49:1079–1093, 2009). While they showed excellent pose identification performance when they were used for rescoring of the predefined decoy conformations, a pronounced degradation in performance could be observed when they were directly applied in docking calculations using the same test set. This implies that on a discrete set of ligand poses only the rescoring performance can be evaluated. For comparing the pose prediction performance in a more rigorous manner, the search space of each scoring function has to be sampled extensively as done in the docking calculations performed here. We were able to identify relative strengths and weaknesses of three scoring functions (ChemPLP, GoldScore, and Astex Statistical Potential) by analyzing the performance for subsets of the complexes grouped by different properties of the active site. However, reasons for the overall poor performance of all three functions on this test set compared to other test sets of similar size could not be identified.

DeepBSP—a Machine Learning Method for Accurate Prediction of Protein–Ligand Docking Structures

GSScore: a novel Graphormer-based shell-like scoring method for protein–ligand docking

A fully differentiable ligand pose optimization framework guided by deep learning and a traditional scoring function

DeepDock: Enhancing Ligand-protein Interaction Prediction by a Combination of Ligand and Structure Information

PoseBusters: AI-based docking methods fail to generate physically valid poses or generalise to novel sequences

Synergistic Application of Molecular Docking and Machine Learning for Improved Binding Pose

The Impact of Cross-Docked Poses on Performance of Machine Learning Classifier for Protein–ligand Binding Pose Prediction

A fully differentiable ligand pose optimization framework guided by deep learning and traditional scoring functions

Are predefined decoy sets of ligand poses able to quantify scoring function accuracy?

zPoseScore model for accurate and robust protein–ligand docking pose scoring in CASP15

Deep Learning for Protein-Ligand Docking: Are We There Yet?

DeltaDock: A Unified Framework for Accurate, Efficient, and Physically Reliable Molecular Docking

A Generalized Protein-Ligand Scoring Framework with Balanced Scoring, Docking, Ranking and Screening Powers.

Combining Docking Pose Rank and Structure with Deep Learning Improves Protein–Ligand Binding Mode Prediction over a Baseline Docking Approach

A machine learning approach to predicting protein–ligand binding affinity with applications to molecular docking

CarsiDock: a deep learning paradigm for accurate protein-ligand docking and screening based on large-scale pre-training

Pre-Training on Large-Scale Generated Docking Conformations with HelixDock to Unlock the Potential of Protein-ligand Structure Prediction Models

Boosting Deep Learning-based Docking with Cross-attention and Centrality Embedding

From machine learning to deep learning: Advances in scoring functions for protein–ligand docking

DOCKSTRING: Easy Molecular Docking Yields Better Benchmarks for Ligand Design

Uni-Mol Docking V2: Towards Realistic and Accurate Binding Pose Prediction