Abstract:We present the parallel particle-in-cell (PIC) code Apar-T and, more importantly, address the fundamental question of the relations between the PIC model, the Vlasov-Maxwell theory, and real plasmas. First, we present four validation tests: spectra from simulations of thermal plasmas, linear growth rates of the relativistic tearing instability and of the filamentation instability, and nonlinear filamentation merging phase. For the filamentation instability we show that the effective growth rates measured on the total energy can differ by more than 50% from the linear cold predictions and from the fastest modes of the simulation. We link these discrepancies to the superparticle number per cell and to the level of field fluctuations. Second, we detail a new method for initial loading of Maxwell-Jüttner particle distributions with relativistic bulk velocity and relativistic temperature, and explain why the traditional method with individual particle boosting fails. The formulation of the relativistic Harris equilibrium is generalized to arbitrary temperature and mass ratios. Both are required for the tearing instability setup. Third, we turn to the key point of this paper and scrutinize the question of what description of (weakly coupled) physical plasmas is obtained by PIC models. These models rely on two building blocks: coarse-graining, i.e., grouping of the order of p ~ 1010 real particles into a single computer superparticle, and field storage on a grid with its subsequent finite superparticle size. We introduce the notion of coarse-graining dependent quantities, i.e., quantities depending on p. They derive from the PIC plasma parameter ΛPIC, which we show to behave as ΛPIC ∝ 1/p. We explore two important implications. One is that PIC collision- and fluctuation-induced thermalization times are expected to scale with the number of superparticles per grid cell, and thus to be a factor p ~ 1010 smaller than in real plasmas, a fact that we confirm with simulations. The other is that the level of electric field fluctuations scales as 1/ΛPIC ∝ p. We provide a corresponding exact expression, taking into account the finite superparticle size. We confirm both expectations with simulations. Fourth, we compare the Vlasov-Maxwell theory, often used for code benchmarking, to the PIC model. The former describes a phase-space fluid with Λ = + ∞ and no correlations, while the PIC plasma features a small Λ and a high level of correlations when compared to a real plasma. These differences have to be kept in mind when interpreting and validating PIC results against the Vlasov-Maxwell theory and when modeling real physical plasmas.

On Variational Fourier Particle Methods

GEMPIC: Geometric ElectroMagnetic Particle-In-Cell Methods

Variational Framework for Structure-Preserving Electromagnetic Particle-in-Cell Methods

A Unified Hamiltonian Solution to Maxwell–Schrödinger Equations for Modeling Electromagnetic Field–particle Interaction

Universal Vector–Scalar Potential Framework for Inhomogeneous Electromagnetic System and Its Application in Semiclassical Quantum Electromagnetics

Geometric Particle-In-Cell discretizations of a plasma hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less fluid electrons

An Envelope Tracking Approach for Particle in Cell Simulations

A particle-in-Fourier method with semi-discrete energy conservation for non-periodic boundary conditions

Geometric particle-in-cell methods for Vlasov--Poisson equations with Maxwell--Boltzmann electrons

A Charge Conserving Exponential Predictor Corrector FEMPIC Formulation for Relativistic Particle Simulations

Semi-Implicit Particle-in-Cell Methods Embedding Sparse Grid Reconstructions

A Particle-in-cell Method for Plasmas with a Generalized Momentum Formulation, Part II: Enforcing the Lorenz Gauge Condition

Geometric integration of the Vlasov-Maxwell system with a variational particle-in-cell scheme

Variational formulation of macro-particle plasma simulation algorithms

Geometric Particle-in-Cell Simulations of the Vlasov--Maxwell System in Curvilinear Coordinates

Apar-T: code, validation, and physical interpretation of particle-in-cell results

VSHPIC: A Particle-In-Cell Algorithm Based On Vector Spherical Harmonics Expansion

Asymptotic-preserving gyrokinetic implicit particle-orbit integrator for arbitrary electromagnetic fields

Implementation of a Hybrid Particle Code with a PIC Description in R–z and a Gridless Description in Φ into OSIRIS

Explicit energy-conserving modification of relativistic PIC method

Mitigation of Numerical Cerenkov Radiation and Instability Using a Hybrid Finite Difference-Fft Maxwell Solver and a Local Charge Conserving Current Deposit