Abstract:The comprehensive evaluation of model- and satellite-based surface soil temperature (ST) products is a prerequisite for applications of these datasets in hydrology, ecology, and climate change, as well as in passive microwave soil moisture retrieval algorithms. Distinguished from existing regional validations, this study used ground soil temperature observations of approximately 800 stations from 5 sparse and 15 dense networks worldwide to fully assess six model- and satellite-based surface ST products from April 2015 to December 2017. The products consist of five model-based ST from the Modern-Era Retrospective Analysis for Research and Applications, version 2 (MERRA-2), the Goddard Earth Observing System Model version 5 Forward Processing (GEOS-5 FP), the Global Land Data Assimilation System (GLDAS) Noah, the ERA-Interim and the newly released ERA5 produced by the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF), and one satellite-based ST retrieved from the Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer 2 (AMSR2) by using the Land Parameter Retrieval Model (LPRM). The accuracy of these products was comprehensively assessed per availability of ground networks, soil temperature interval, soil moisture interval, land cover, climate zone, and elevation. The results show that the GEOS-5 exhibits the smallest averaged unbiased root mean square difference (ubRMSD) of 1.84 K among all the surface ST products. All model-based products show a high skill in capturing the temporal trend of ground observations with an averaged correlation coefficient larger than 0.97. The ERA5 surface ST obtains visible improvements compared to its predecessor ERA-Interim by showing smaller ubRMSD and absolute bias values. All model-based surface ST products generally show lower values than ground ST, while their bias tends to be warmer as soil temperature and soil moisture increase except for the highest temperature and moisture conditions. Moreover, unstable performance of most model-based products in shrubland and grassland, tropical, arid and cold climate, and high elevation regions is also demonstrated by larger ubRMSD values. The averaged ubRMSD of the satellite-based LPRM ST is 3.04 K, and more attentions should be paid to the impacts of elevations and underlying surfaces on improving this product. These new findings will be valuable for future refinement of ST datasets, algorithms used to estimate soil moisture from satellite data, and applications in various disciplines.

A review and comparison of surface incident shortwave radiation from multiple data sources: satellite retrievals, reanalysis data and GCM simulations

Impact of Geolocations of Validation Data on the Evaluation of Surface Incident Shortwave Radiation from Earth System Models

Global evaluation of simulated surface shortwave radiation in CMIP6 models

Significant discrepancies of land surface daily net radiation among ten remotely sensed and reanalysis products

A Review of the Estimation of Downward Surface Shortwave Radiation Based on Satellite Data: Methods, Progress and Problems

Evaluation of Multi-Reanalysis Solar Radiation Products Using Global Surface Observations

Discrepancies in the Simulated Global Terrestrial Latent Heat Flux from GLASS and MERRA-2 Surface Net Radiation Products

The accuracy improvement of clear-sky surface shortwave radiation derived from CERES SSF dataset with a simulation analysis

An Improved Algorithm for Estimating Surface Shortwave Radiation: Preliminary Evaluation With MODIS Products

Does the Modern‐era Retrospective Analysis for Research and Applications‐2 Aerosol Reanalysis Introduce an Improvement in the Simulation of Surface Solar Radiation over China?

Evaluation of the Surface Downward Longwave Radiation Estimation Models over Land Surface

Evaluation of Two Satellite Surface Solar Radiation Products in the Urban Region in Beijing, China

Retrieval of Daytime Surface Upward Longwave Radiation Under All-Sky Conditions With Remote Sensing and Meteorological Reanalysis Data

Improvement of ERA5 over ERA-Interim in Simulating Surface Incident Solar Radiation throughout China

Assessment of surface downward longwave radiation in CMIP6 with comparison to observations and CMIP5

Evaluations of Land–Ocean Skin Temperatures of the ISCCP Satellite Retrievals and the NCEP and ERA Reanalyses

Global and Regional Evaluation of the CERES Edition-4A Surface Solar Radiation and Its Uncertainty Quantification

Evaluation of six satellite- and model-based surface soil temperature datasets using global ground-based observations

Assessment of Three Satellite-Estimated Land Surface Downwelling Shortwave Irradiance Data Sets

Extensive validation of CM SAF surface radiation products over Europe

Differences Evaluation among Three Global Remote Sensing SDL Products