Risk analysis of reservoir floodwater utilization coupling meteorological and hydrological uncertainties

Qingwen Lu,Ping-an Zhong,Bin Xu,Feilin Zhu,Han Wang,Yufei Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00477-020-01834-9
IF: 3.821
2020-07-08
Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment
Abstract:Dynamic control of flood-limited water level (FLWL) is an effective method to realize floodwater utilization, which can alleviate the contradiction between flood control and conservation during flood seasons. In this study, a method of identifying upper bound of FLWL is presented simultaneously considering pre-release for water supply in rainless period and pre-release for flood control in the early period of flood. A risk analysis framework considering continuous rainless-day forecast error and flood forecast error is established. An improved truncated Gaussian distribution to describe rainless-day forecast error is proposed, combined with normal distribution describing flood forecast error to derive the distribution of excess storage determined by the method of pre-release based on forecasts. Then risk assessment and decision making are conducted. The Xianghongdian Reservoir is selected for a case study. The results indicate that the allowable excess storage can be determined under a given acceptable risk by using this analytical method. Moreover, the excess storage decreases with the safety margin reserved for the downstream increasing under the same acceptable risk.
environmental sciences,engineering, environmental,water resources, civil,statistics & probability
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the issue of how to reasonably determine the upper limit of the Flood Limited Water Level (FLWL) of reservoirs during the flood season, considering the uncertainties in meteorological and hydrological forecasts, to achieve effective utilization of flood water resources and improve the economic benefits of reservoirs while ensuring flood control safety. Specifically, the paper proposes a new method to identify the upper limit of FLWL, taking into account pre-release water during non-rainy periods and early flood stages. Additionally, the paper establishes a risk analysis framework to assess the risks of excess storage based on forecast information and provides decision support. ### Background of the Paper The main design and operation purposes of reservoirs are flood control and water storage. However, during the flood season, there is a conflict between flood control safety and economic benefits: flood control requires more empty storage capacity to accommodate incoming floods, while water storage requires more water for irrigation, recreation, and power generation. Traditional Static Control FLWL (SC-FLWL) ensures flood control safety to some extent but may lead to no water storage after floods, affecting storage benefits. Therefore, some scholars have proposed the concept of "multi-stage FLWL," which divides the flood season into multiple sub-stages and adopts different FLWLs to improve economic benefits without lowering the flood control standards of the reservoir. ### Research Objectives This paper aims to achieve Dynamic Control FLWL (DC-FLWL) by introducing real-time meteorological and hydrological forecast information, thereby improving the utilization rate of flood water resources while ensuring flood control safety. The specific objectives include: 1. **Determining the upper limit of FLWL**: Proposing a new method to determine the upper limit of FLWL, considering pre-release water during non-rainy periods and early flood stages. 2. **Risk analysis**: Establishing a risk analysis framework to evaluate the risks of excess storage based on forecast information, considering forecast errors of consecutive non-rainy days and flood forecasts. 3. **Decision support**: Providing risk-based decision support through risk assessment to ensure maximum economic benefits under reasonable risk control. ### Methods 1. **Determining the upper limit of FLWL**: Using the pre-release water method, combined with forecast information during non-rainy periods and early flood stages, to determine the upper limit of FLWL. 2. **Risk analysis**: Considering forecast errors of consecutive non-rainy days and flood forecasts, establishing a distribution model of excess storage, and conducting risk assessment. 3. **Decision support**: Based on the risk assessment results, determining the maximum excess storage under a given acceptable risk level to provide guidance for actual operations. ### Conclusion Through the above methods, the paper demonstrates how to reasonably determine the upper limit of FLWL, considering the uncertainties in meteorological and hydrological forecasts, to achieve effective utilization of flood water resources. The research results show that by dynamically controlling FLWL, it is possible to improve the economic benefits of reservoirs while ensuring flood control safety.