Abstract:Significance It was commented that some modern density functional theory functionals may be giving the correct energies for the wrong reason and functionals that produce “right” energies from “wrong” densities fail twice. However, the route to the “heaven” of the “Jacob’s ladder” is incomplete in Medvedev et al. [Medvedev MG, et al. (2017) Science 355:49–52], as the authors did not provide any information on the top fifth-rung functionals. We fill the gap to show here that the XYG3 type of doubly hybrid density functionals (xDHs) can correctly describe both density and energy for the same atomic set used by Medvedev et al., such that electronic structure calculations for molecular sciences of the main group elements can be carried out reliably by using xDHs. Recently, it was argued [Medvedev MG, et al. (2017) Science 355:49–52] that the development of density functional approximations (DFAs) is “straying from the path toward the exact functional.” The exact functional should yield both exact energy and density for a system of interest; nevertheless, they found that many heavily fitted functionals for molecular energies actually lead to poor electron densities of atoms. They also observed a trend that, for the nonempirical and few-parameter functionals, densities can be improved as one climbs up the first four rungs of the Jacob’s ladder of DFAs. The XYG3 type of doubly hybrid functionals (xDHs) represents a less-empirical and fewer-parameter functional on the top fifth rung, in which both the Hartree–Fock-like exchange and the second-order perturbative (MP2-like) correlation are hybridized with the low rung functionals. Here, we show that xDHs can well describe both density and energy for the same atomic set of Medvedev et al., showing that the latter trend can well be extended to the top fifth rung.

Assessment of simple exchange-correlation energy functionals of the one-particle density matrix

The performance of exchange—correlation functionals in describing electron density parameters of saddle point structures along chemical reactions

Introducing a new exchange functional by altering the electron density's ionization dependency in density functional theory

Assessing Exchange-Correlation Functionals for Accurate Densities of Solids

Understanding electron correlation energy through density functional theory

Exchange‐correlation effects in interatomic energies for pure density functionals and their application to the molecular energy prediction

Exchange energies with forces in density-functional theory

Thirty years of density functional theory in computational chemistry: an overview and extensive assessment of 200 density functionals

Benchmarking Density Functionals on Structural Parameters of Small-/Medium-Sized Organic Molecules.

A CSOV study of the difference between HF and DFT intermolecular interaction energy values: The importance of the charge transfer contribution

Short-range screened density matrix functional for proper descriptions of thermochemistry, thermochemical kinetics, nonbonded interactions, and singlet diradicals

Non-empirical Double-Hybrid Density Functionals as Reliable Tools for Electronic Structure Calculations

Performance of a nonempirical exchange functional from the density matrix expansion: comparative study with different correlation

Combining density based dynamical correlation with a reduced density matrix strong correlation description

A General and Transferable Local Hybrid Functional for Electronic Structure Theory and Many-Fermion Approaches

Numerical Examination of Several Exchange Energy Functionals

Performance of one-body reduced density matrix functionals for the homogeneous electron gas

Approximate Functionals for Multistate Density Functional Theory

Reduced density matrix functional theory from an ab initio seniority-zero wave function: Exact and approximate formulations along adiabatic connection paths

Doubly Hybrid Density Functionals That Correctly Describe Both Density and Energy for Atoms.

Modelling the Kohn-Sham potential for molecular dissociation with orbital-independent functionals: a proof of principle