Abstract:Diagnosis is often based on the exceedance or not of continuous health indicators of a predefined cut-off value, so as to classify patients into positives and negatives for the disease under investigation. In this paper, we investigate the effects of dichotomization of spatially-referenced continuous outcome variables on geostatistical inference. Although this issue has been extensively studied in other fields, dichotomization is still a common practice in epidemiological studies. Furthermore, the effects of this practice in the context of prevalence mapping have not been fully understood. Here, we demonstrate how spatial correlation affects the loss of information due to dichotomization, how linear geostatistical models can be used to map disease prevalence and thus avoid dichotomization, and finally, how dichotomization affects our predictive inference on prevalence. To pursue these objectives, we develop a metric, based on the composite likelihood, which can be used to quantify the potential loss of information after dichotomization without requiring the fitting of Binomial geostatistical models. Through a simulation study and two applications on disease mapping in Africa, we show that, as thresholds used for dichotomization move further away from the mean of the underlying process, the performance of binomial geostatistical models deteriorates substantially. We also find that dichotomization can lead to the loss of fine scale features of disease prevalence and increased uncertainty in the parameter estimates, especially in the presence of a large noise to signal ratio. These findings strongly support the conclusions from previous studies that dichotomization should be always avoided whenever feasible.

Optimal dichotomization of bimodal Gaussian mixtures

Gaussian mixture density modeling and decomposition with weighted likelihood

A revision for gaussian mixture density decomposition algorithm

A Bayesian finite mixture model approach to evaluate dichotomization method for correlated ELISA tests

A mixture distribution for modelling bivariate ordinal data

The Breakdown of Gaussian Universality in Classification of High-dimensional Mixtures

Misclassification among methods used for multiple group discrimination--the effects of distributional properties

Understanding the effects of dichotomization of continuous outcomes on geostatistical inference

A short note on the maximal point-biserial correlation under non-normality

Comparison of Dichotomized and Distributional Approaches in Rare Event Clinical Trial Design: a Fixed Bayesian Design

Mixture models for simultaneous classification and reduction of three-way data

Analysis of an Incomplete Binary Outcome Dichotomized From an Underlying Continuous Variable in Clinical Trials

A dichotomous behavior of Guttman-Kaiser criterion from equi-correlated normal population

D-optimal Designs for Multinomial Logistic Models

A binarization approach to model interactions between categorical predictors in Generalized Linear Models

A Shrinkage Likelihood Ratio Test for High-Dimensional Subgroup Analysis with a Logistic-Normal Mixture Model

Local Minima Structures in Gaussian Mixture Models

Proportional odds logistic regression—effective means of dealing with limited uncertainty in dichotomizing clinical outcomes

Optimal projections for Gaussian discriminants

Interpolating Discriminant Functions in High-Dimensional Gaussian Latent Mixtures