Abstract:Introduction: Logistic regression models are frequently used to estimate measures of association between an exposure, health determinant or intervention, and a binary outcome. However, when the outcome is frequent (> 10%), model estimates for relative risks and prevalence ratios might be biased. Despite the availability of several alternatives, many still rely on these models, and a consensus is yet to be reached. We aimed to compare the estimation and goodness-of-fit of logistic, log-binomial and robust Poisson regression models, in cross-sectional studies involving frequent binary outcomes. Methods: Two cross-sectional studies were conducted. Study 1 was a nationally representative study on the impact of air pollution on mental health. Study 2 was a local study on immigrants' access to urgent healthcare services. Odds ratios (OR) were obtained through logistic regression, and prevalence ratios (PR) through log-binomial and robust Poisson regression models. Confidence intervals (CI), their ranges, and standard-errors (SE) were also computed, along with models' relative goodness-of-fit through Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), when applicable. Results: In Study 1, the OR (95% CI) was 1.015 (0.970 - 1.063), while the PR (95% CI) obtained through the robust Poisson mode was 1.012 (0.979 - 1.045). The log-binomial regression model did not converge in this study. In Study 2, the OR (95% CI) was 1.584 (1.026 - 2.446), the PR (95% CI) for the log-binomial model was 1.217 (0.978 - 1.515), and 1.130 (1.013 - 1.261) for the robust Poisson model. The 95% CI, their ranges, and the SE of the OR were higher than those of the PR, in both studies. However, in Study 2, the AIC value was lower for the logistic regression model. Conclusion: The odds ratio overestimated PR with wider 95% CI and higher SE. The overestimation was greater as the outcome of the study became more prevalent, in line with previous studies. In Study 2, the logistic regression was the model with the best fit, illustrating the need to consider multiple criteria when selecting the most appropriate statistical model for each study. Employing logistic regression models by default might lead to misinterpretations. Robust Poisson models are viable alternatives in cross-sectional studies with frequent binary outcomes, avoiding the non-convergence of log-binomial models.

Proportional odds logistic regression—effective means of dealing with limited uncertainty in dichotomizing clinical outcomes

Logistic Regression: Limitations in the Estimation of Measures of Association with Binary Health Outcomes

Risk prediction models for discrete ordinal outcomes: calibration and the impact of the proportional odds assumption

Applications of Proportional Odds Model to Multivariate Interval-Censored Data

Individual-level probabilities and cluster-level proportions: Toward interpretable level 2 estimates in unconflated multilevel models for binary outcomes.

Binary classification with fuzzy logistic regression under class imbalance and complete separation in clinical studies

Analysis of an Incomplete Binary Outcome Dichotomized From an Underlying Continuous Variable in Clinical Trials

A bias-reduced generalized estimating equation approach for proportional odds models with small-sample longitudinal ordinal data

Primer on binary logistic regression

Estimating Bayesian Optimal Treatment Regimes for Dichotomous Outcomes using Observational Data

Meta-analysis of dichotomous and ordinal tests without a gold standard

Logistic Regression with Misclassification in Binary Outcome Variables: a Method and Software

A constrained regression model for an ordinal response with ordinal predictors

Robust Estimation of Causal Effects of Binary Treatments in Unconfounded Studies with Dichotomous Outcomes

Sample Size and Power Determination for a Binary Outcome and an Ordinal Exposure when Logistic Regression Analysis Is Planned

Ordered multinomial regression for genetic association analysis of ordinal phenotypes at Biobank scale

A Proportional Hazards Model for the Subdistribution of a Competing Risk

Non Proportional Odds Models are Widely Dispensable -- Sparser Modeling based on Parametric and Additive Location-Shift Approaches

Modeling Zero-inflated Count Data Using Generalized Poisson and Ordinal Logistic Regression Models in Medical Research

Doubly-Robust Dynamic Treatment Regimen Estimation for Binary Outcomes

Time series regression models for zero-inflated proportions