Abstract:Healthy adults flexibly adapt their learning strategies to ongoing changes in uncertainty, a key feature of adaptive behaviour. However, the developmental trajectory of this ability is yet unknown, as developmental studies have not incorporated trial-to-trial variation in uncertainty in their analyses or models. To address this issue, we compared adolescents' and adults' trial-to-trial dynamics of uncertainty, learning rate, and exploration in two tasks that assess learning in noisy but otherwise stable environments. In an estimation task—which provides direct indices of trial-specific learning rate—both age groups reduced their learning rate over time, as self-reported uncertainty decreased. Accordingly, the estimation data in both groups was better explained by a Bayesian model with dynamic learning rate (Kalman filter) than by conventional reinforcement-learning models. Furthermore, adolescents' learning rates asymptoted at a higher level, reflecting an over-weighting of the most recent outcome, and the estimated Kalman-filter parameters suggested that this was due to an overestimation of environmental volatility. In a choice task, both age groups became more likely to choose the higher-valued option over time, but this increase in choice accuracy was smaller in the adolescents. In contrast to the estimation task, we found no evidence for a Bayesian expectation-updating process in the choice task, suggesting that estimation and choice tasks engage different learning processes. However, our modeling results of the choice task suggested that both age groups reduced their degree of exploration over time, and that the adolescents explored overall more than the adults. Finally, age-related differences in exploration parameters from fits to the choice data were mediated by participants' volatility parameter from fits to the estimation data. Together, these results suggest that adolescents overestimate the rate of environmental change, resulting in elevated learning rates and increased exploration, which may help understand developmental changes in learning and decision-making.To successfully learn the value of stimuli and actions, people should take into account their current (un)certainty about these values: Learning rates and exploration should be high when one's value estimates are highly uncertain (in the beginning of learning), and decrease over time as evidence accumulates and uncertainty decreases. Recent studies have shown that healthy adults flexibly adapt their learning strategies based on ongoing changes in uncertainty, consistent with normative learning. However, the development of this ability prior to adulthood is yet unknown, as developmental learning studies have not considered trial-to-trial changes in uncertainty. Here, we show that adolescents, as compared to adults, showed a smaller decrease in both learning rate and exploration over time. Computational modeling revealed that both of these effects were due to adolescents overestimating the amount of environmental volatility, which made them more sensitive to recent relative to older evidence. The overestimation of volatility during adolescence may represent the rapidly changing environmental demands during this developmental period, and can help understand the surge in real-life risk taking and exploratory behaviours characteristic of adolescents.

Observational reinforcement learning in children and young adults

Differential Neural Correlates Underlie Judgment of Learning and Subsequent Memory Performance

Adolescent-specific Patterns of Behavior and Neural Activity During Social Reinforcement Learning

Electrical brain activations in preadolescents during a probabilistic reward-learning task reflect cognitive processes and behavioral strategy.

Hippocampus and striatum show distinct contributions to longitudinal changes in value-based learning in middle childhood

Hippocampus and Striatum Showed Distinct Contributions to Longitudinal Changes in Value-Based Learning in Middle Childhood

Distentangling the systems contributing to changes in learning during adolescence

Age-dependent predictors of effective reinforcement motor learning across childhood

Behavioral and Neural Properties of Social Reinforcement Learning.

Prediction Error During Retrospective Revaluation of Causal Associations in Humans: Fmri Evidence in Favor of an Associative Model of Learning

Neuroimaging of learning and development: improving ecological validity

Uncertainty-driven regulation of learning and exploration in adolescents: A computational account

Learning in anticipation of reward and punishment: Perspectives across the human lifespan

Initial Learning in the Brain: From Rules to Action

Childhood neglect is associated with alterations in neural prediction error signaling and the response to novelty

Young Children Integrate Current Observations, Priors and Agent Information to Build Predictive Models of Others’ Actions

Computational neurodevelopment: infant decision-making in changing environments

Meta-analysis of human prediction error for incentives, perception, cognition, and action

Neural reactivity to monetary rewards and losses in childhood: longitudinal and concurrent associations with observed and self-reported positive emotionality

Causal involvement of dorsomedial prefrontal cortex in learning the predictability of observable actions

Metacognitive monitoring of oneself and others: developmental changes during childhood and adolescence