Abstract:Altruistic punishment is key to establishing cooperation and maintaining social order, yet its developmental trends across cultures remain unclear. Using computational reinforcement learning models, we provided the first evidence of how social feedback dynamically influences group-biased altruistic punishment across cultures and the lifespan. Study 1 ( n = 371) found that Chinese participants exhibited higher learning rates than Americans when socially incentivized to punish unfair allocations. Additionally, Chinese adults showed slower learning and less exploration when punishing ingroups than outgroups, a pattern absent in American counterparts, potentially reflecting a tendency towards ingroup favoritism that may contribute to reinforcing collectivist values. Study 2 ( n = 430, aged 12–52) further showed that such ingroup favoritism develops with age. Chinese participants' learning rates for ingroup punishment decreased from adolescence into adulthood, while outgroup rates stayed constant, implying a process of cultural learning. Our findings highlight cultural and age-related variations in altruistic punishment learning, with implications for social reinforcement learning and culturally sensitive educational practices promoting fairness and altruism. How do people from different cultures and ages learn to punish unfair behavior? Such punishment is crucial for societal cohesion, yet remains poorly understood. We tested participants from China and the USA, and from early adolescence to adulthood. Chinese individuals, compared to Americans, quickly associate punishing unfair actions with social feedback. However, they tend to hesitate when learning to punish ingroup members, unlike American individuals. Interestingly, this preference for ingroup members becomes more prominent as Chinese participants grow from adolescence into adulthood, reflecting a gradual adoption of collectivist values. These findings emphasize how cultural norms and developmental stages strongly influence the learning processes that shape social decision-making, offering insights for creating interventions that promote justice and cooperation in diverse societies.

Learning in anticipation of reward and punishment: Perspectives across the human lifespan

Adolescents exhibit reduced Pavlovian biases on instrumental learning

Examining the Association between Punishment and Reward Sensitivity and Response Inhibition to Previously-Incentivized Cues across Development

Reward speeds up and increases consistency of visual selective attention: a lifespan comparison

Adolescents flexibly adapt action selection based on controllability inferences

Reward and punishment contingency shifting reveals distinct roles for VTA dopamine and GABA neurons in behavioral flexibility

Adolescent-specific Patterns of Behavior and Neural Activity During Social Reinforcement Learning

Electrical brain activations in preadolescents during a probabilistic reward-learning task reflect cognitive processes and behavioral strategy.

Emotional cues reduce Pavlovian interference in feedback-based go and nogo learning

Age-related changes in deterministic learning from positive versus negative performance feedback

Pavlovian impatience: The anticipation of immediate rewards increases approach behaviour

Reinforcement learning of altruistic punishment differs between cultures and across the lifespan

The Neural Correlates of Individual Differences in Reinforcement Learning during Pain Avoidance and Reward Seeking

Influence of surprise on reinforcement learning in younger and older adults

High stakes slow responding, but do not help overcome Pavlovian biases in humans

Early Salience Signals Predict Interindividual Asymmetry in Decision Accuracy Across Rewarding and Punishing Contexts

Dissociated Modulations of Intranasal Vasopressin on Prosocial Learning Between Reward-Seeking and Punishment-Avoidance.

The Brain Ages Optimally to Model Its Environment: Evidence from Sensory Learning over the Adult Lifespan

Rewards, aversions and affect in adolescence: emerging convergences across laboratory animal and human data

Affective learning: Awareness and aversion

Punishing temporal judgement boosts sense of agency and modulates its underlying neural correlates