Repurchases for Price Impact: Evidence from Fragile Stocks

Massimo Massa,David Schumacher,Yan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s002210902400036x

IF: 4.337

2024-05-23

Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis

Abstract://static.cambridge.org/content/id/urn%3Acambridge.org%3Aid%3Aarticle%3AS002210902400036X/resource/name/firstPage-pdf-S002210902400036Xa.jpg

economics,business, finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Sources of the Stock Price Fluctuations in Chinese Equity Market

Zhenhua Su,Jun Ma,Mark E. Wohar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1351847x.2012.671779

2020-01-01

Abstract:This paper proposes a latent factor approach based on a state–space framework in order to identify which factor, if any, dominates price fluctuations in the Chinese stock markets. We also illustrate the connection of such stock price decomposition with several general equilibrium asset pricing models and show that the decomposition results can potentially offer useful insights with regard to the empirical relevance of asset pricing models. We use quarterly data of the Chinese A-Share equity market over the period 1995Q3–2011Q1 and find that the estimates of the state–space model suggest that the expected return is the primary driving force behind price fluctuations in the Chinese stock market. We show that the time-varying expected returns appear to be counter-cyclical and this result seems to be consistent with the habit formation model of Campbell and Cochrane [1999. By force of habit: A consumption-based explanation of aggregate stock market behavior. Journal of Political Economy 107, no. 2: 205–51.]. However, we also note that there is a great deal of uncertainty with respect to this variance decomposition due to the resulting small signal-to-noise ratio in the estimated state–space model.
The Credibility of Stock Repurchase Signals

Chen Chao

2007-01-01

Abstract:The information hypothesis has been tested in the context of stock repurchase tender-offers and open-market stock repurchases. Favorable stock price reactions to repurchase tender-offer announcements and subsequent positive earnings surprises are documented by early empirical studies. However, recent studies find that earnings decline for the year after the repurchase announcement and the U.S. has the least stringent regulations on repurchase in terms of execution and disclosure. Since both stock repurchases and earnings management are important managerial choices, this paper links these two managerial choices by exploring the creditability of stock repurchase signals. A major innovation of this paper is to classify stock repurchase into completed repurchase programs versus incomplete repurchase programs. Do companies with incomplete repurchase programs behave and perform differently? Using discretional accrual as a measure of earning management, we show that discretionary accrual is a negative and significant predictor of future ROA for firms with incomplete repurchases but not for those firms with completed repurchase programs. Moreover, our empirical results show that the firm with a higher degree of earnings management, a greater percentage of outstanding shares that the firm attempts to buyback, and without disclosing the funding sources in the repurchase announcement tends to have a higher probability leaving the stock repurchase program incomplete.
Do Share Repurchases Distort Stock Prices? Evidence from the United States and Malaysia

Chong-Meng Chee,Nazrul Hisyam bin Ab Razak,Bany Ariffin bin Amin Noordin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/23210222211024380

2021-06-23

Studies in Microeconomics

Abstract:Heavy share buyback years after the global finance crisis 2008–2009 drew criticism from scholars and financial press that share repurchases were being used by firms to manipulate their stock prices. This paper examines whether a greater firm’s repurchase intensity distorts stock prices reflecting to information. We analyse 2 sets of unbalanced panel data that contain a sample of 337 US and another sample of 167 Malaysian repurchasing firms between 2012 and 2016. Contrary to the criticism, we find that a greater firms’ share buyback intensity in the USA stimulates faster incorporation of information in price and results in more efficient stock prices. The main findings hold true and are robust when an alternative measure of share repurchase intensity was used. The findings of US sample support the notion that share repurchase serves as a signalling tool and price support to promote more efficient stock prices. We also find no strong evidence supporting the notion that shares repurchased by Malaysian firms distort stock prices. JEL Classification: G10, G14, G35
A comprehensive examination of the wealth effects of recent stock repurchase announcements

Ken C. Yook,Partha Gangopadhyay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11156-010-0215-y

2010-10-20

Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting

Abstract:The main purpose of this paper is to examine the wealth effect of stock repurchase announcements using a sample of 11,862 repurchase programs announced during 1994–2007. The results of several recent industry surveys indicate that managerial motivations for repurchasing shares may have changed in recent years. To better understand the reasons for repurchasing shares we classify our sample in various ways—by year, by the method used for repurchasing shares, and by the stated purpose of the program. We find that the median size of firms repurchasing shares has increased dramatically recently, and concomitantly, the announcement returns have declined. Signaling undervaluation of share prices appears to become less important than previously assumed. While smaller firms signal undervaluation using open market repurchases, tender offers are chosen to enhance shareholder values by other means.

English Else
The Impact of Investor Heterogeneity in Beliefs on Share Repurchase

Hao Wang,Xiaochun Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.12691/ijefm-2-3-3

2014-01-01

Abstract:In this paper, we propose a new share repurchasing model to show the impact of the heterogeneity of investor beliefs on share repurchase. We first provide a comprehensive survey on the literature of share repurchases which has not been considered by previous studies, to the best of our knowledge. We review both the theoretical model structures and the major empirical results including various measures of divergence of opinion developed in the literature. Our new repurchasing model uses actual share repurchases to show that investors’ divergence of opinion on the firm value matters in a manager’s share repurchase decision. The long-term stock price performance is consistent with our model predictions.
Earnings Management in Response to Stock Price Pressure: Evidence from Fire Sales (and Purchases) by Mutual Funds

Renhui Fu

2016-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper examines whether managers manipulate earnings in response to fire sales (and purchases) of stocks by mutual funds. I find that managers engage in upward earnings management when facing downward price pressure driven by fire sales of mutual funds. I find no evidence that managers engage in downward earnings management when their stocks are fire purchased by mutual funds. My results become stronger for firms with more illiquid stocks, firms under tighter financial constraints and firms issuing new debt. I also find that earnings management increases stock prices in the short term and helps stock prices return to “normal” levels in the long run. Collectively, my evidence suggests that downward price pressure caused by fire sales of mutual funds leads to upward earnings management, which in turn speeds up price recovery.
Price Elasticity for Stocks: Evidence from China's Split-Share Structure Reform

Jinliang Li,Li Liao,Hongbo Shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2362257

2013-01-01

Abstract:In 2005 and 2006, the split-share structure reform converted the nontradable shares of most domestic public firms in China to tradable shares. This conversion imparted a drastic supply shock to the public market. Studying this unique event, we provide direct evidence to support an inelastic demand curve for stocks. Abnormal returns of the sample firms resulting from the reform are found to be negatively associated with the size of the supply shock. This finding is free from the confounding information effects present in many prior studies of stock price elasticity. It is also robust after controlling for opposite price impacts of ROA, firm size, and ownership concentration.
Asset Price, Risk Transfer and Economic Activities: Firm-level Evidence from China

Ying Sophie Huang,Yizhong Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.najef.2012.10.008

IF: 3.136

2013-01-01

The North American Journal of Economics and Finance

Abstract:The paper investigates the extent of the impact from changes in asset price and risk on corporate investment behaviors as well as the real economy. The results support the unidirectional causality effects from asset price fluctuations on the macro-level. By applying quarterly data of Chinese listed companies, we further find the existence of balance sheet effect on the firm-level, which suggests that the changes in asset prices and risk affect the net asset value, and consequently influence corporate investment decisions. More importantly, the balance sheet effect appears to be much more significant after the implementation of new fair value accounting standards in 2007. The impact on the real economy from asset price risk is found to be more prominent as well.
Price ceilings, market structure, and payout policies

Xiongshi Li,Mao Ye,Miles Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2024.103818

IF: 8.9

2024-05-01

Journal of Financial Economics

Abstract:To prevent issuers from inflating their share prices, SEC Rule 10b-18 sets price ceilings on share repurchases through open markets. We find that market-structure reforms in the 1990s and 2000s dramatically increased share repurchases because they relaxed constraints on issuers competing with other buyers under price ceilings. The Tick Size Pilot Program, a controlled experiment that partially reversed previous reforms, significantly reduced share repurchases. We estimate that price ceilings and reduced market-structure frictions explain 18% of the secular increase in share repurchases. Meanwhile, these two frictions still exist, which explains why share repurchases have not crowded out dividends entirely.

economics,business, finance
Quantitative earnings enhancement from share buybacks

Lawrence Middleton,James Dodd,Graham Baird

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1911.04199

2019-11-11

General Finance

Abstract:This paper aims to explore the mechanical effect of a company's share repurchase on earnings per share (EPS). In particular, while a share repurchase scheme will reduce the overall number of shares, suggesting that the EPS may increase, clearly the expenditure will reduce the net earnings of a company, introducing a trade-off between these competing effects. We first of all review accretive share repurchases, then characterise the increase in EPS as a function of price paid by the company. Subsequently, we analyse and quantify the estimated difference in earnings growth between a company's natural growth in the absence of buyback scheme to that with its earnings altered as a result of the buybacks. We conclude with an examination of the effect of share repurchases in two cases studies in the US stock-market.
Open Market Share Repurchases and Earnings Management

Arturo Rodríguez,Heng Yue

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5354/0719-0816.2008.56410

2005-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:In this study we examine earnings management around open market share repurchases. We examine two hypotheses: managerial opportunism and market response, both of which predict that managers will manage earnings down prior to an open market repurchase. Using 2,939 repurchase announcements during 1980- 1998 we find evidence that managers do manage earnings down before share repurchases. We also find that the market does not identify the earnings manipulation when the repurchase is announced, and that discretionary accruals can explain a significant part of long-term positive returns following repurchases. Altogether the evidence is consistent with the managerial opportunism hypothesis. Further investigation indicates that managers with higher ownership in the firm are more likely to manage earnings down.
Real Effects of Share Repurchases Legalization on Corporate Behaviors

Zigan Wang,Qie Ellie Yin,Luping Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2020.10.008

IF: 8.9

2020-01-01

Journal of Financial Economics

Abstract:We use staggered share repurchases legalization from 1985 to 2010 across the world to examine its impact on corporate behaviors. We find that share-repurchasing firms do not cut dividends as a substitution. The cash for repurchasing shares comes more from internal cash than external debt issuance, leading to reductions in capital expenditures and R&D expenses. While this strategy boosts stock prices, it results in lower long-run Tobin's Q, profitability, growth, and innovation, accompanied by lower insider ownership. Tax benefits and paying out temporary earnings are two primary reasons that firms repurchase.
Reference Price Distributions and Stock Returns: an Analysis Based on the Disposition Effect

Yuegang Zhou,Xiaoyan Lei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1594110

2010-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper provides evidence that reference price distributions can predict stocks’ expected returns. We develop a model based on the disposition effect by considering shareholders’ trading activities with different relative capital gains. The model suggests that both disposition-prone investors’ incentives to sell shares and their paper capital gains impact stock performance over a subsequent period. By applying four proxy variables this paper finds that a stock with higher mean and skewness of relative capital gains holds a higher return in the cross-section of the Chinese stocks. The empirical evidence supports our model’s implications. In addition, the average capital gain is the key explanatory variable for variations in returns for winner stocks, and the skewness of capital gains works as the key variable for loser stocks in the Chinese stock markets. These findings hold true when the factors identified in the related literature are taken into consideration.
Bond Price Fragility and the Structure of the Mutual Fund Industry

Mariassunta Giannetti,Chotibhak Jotikasthira

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/hhad095

IF: 8.4137

2024-03-25

Review of Financial Studies

Abstract:We conjecture that mutual funds with large shares of outstanding bond issues are more inclined to internalize the negative price spillovers of fire sales and thus sell their holdings in those issues, to a lower extent, when they experience redemptions. We provide evidence consistent with this conjecture and further show that ownership concentration limits bonds' exposures to flow-induced fire sales. We exploit variation in negative spillovers arising from the Fed's SMCCF to confirm the economic mechanism and explore our findings' implications for fund performance and fire-sale spillovers to other funds.

economics,business, finance
Corporate responses to stock price fragility

Richard Friberg,Itay Goldstein,Kristine W. Hankins

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2024.103795

IF: 8.9

2024-02-07

Journal of Financial Economics

Abstract:This study shows that firms regard stock price fragility - exposure to non-fundamental demand shocks stemming from the composition of equity ownership - as a salient corporate risk. We model ex ante corporate responses to higher potential for future stock market misvaluation and then empirically document that within firm variation in equity fragility has effects in line with the model: higher fragility raises cash holdings and lowers investment. Multiple natural experiments support a causal interpretation of the results. The results are shown to be more prominent in the face of high uncertainty and financial constraints. The evidence presents a new dimension of how managerial expectations affect corporate policies.

economics,business, finance
Do Share Repurchases Facilitate Movement Toward Target Capital Structure? International Evidence

Zigan Wang,Qie Ellie Yin,Luping Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jempfin.2024.101498

IF: 3.025

2024-03-30

Journal of Empirical Finance

Abstract:We use a new international setting to test and strengthen identification of the "target leverage" hypothesis in the payout policy literature. We conduct a quasi-natural experiment induced by staggered share repurchase legalization in 17 economies and analyze its influences on leverage dynamics. After controlling for other repurchasing motives, firms under-leveraged before legalization are more likely to buy back shares immediately after legalization. Post-legalization repurchases also facilitate firms' movement toward target leverage, especially when firms are under-leveraged. This facilitating effect is stronger under lower repurchasing restriction, higher dividend tax penalty, and lower financial constraint.

economics,business, finance
Corporate Actions and the Manipulation of Retail Investors in China: An Analysis of Stock Splits

Sheridan Titman,Chishen Wei. Wei,Bin Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3386/w29212

2021-09-01

Abstract:We identify a group of "suspicious" firms that use stock splits, perhaps along with other activities, to artificially inflate their share prices. Following the initiation of suspicious splits, share prices temporarily increase, and subsequently decline below their presplit levels. Using account level data from the Shanghai Stock Exchange, we find that small retail investors acquire shares in firms initiating suspicious splits, while more sophisticated investors accumulate positions before suspicious split announcements and sell in the postsplit period. We also find that insiders sell large blocks of shares and obtain loans using company stock as collateral around the initiation of suspicious splits.
Why do Firms Repurchase Shares? Evidence from Actual Share Repurchases

xiaochun liu,hao wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.12735/jfe.v3i2p22

2015-01-01

Journal of Finance and Economics

Abstract:In practice, the share repurchase announcement is not a commitment to managers. To this end, the large difference between the actual and announced share repurchases is often observed in markets. In this paper, we explore the implications from actual share repurchase activities, different from the existing methods which focus on the announcements of share repurchases and hence largely ignore the managers’ actual repurchasing activities. By considering actual share repurchases and controlling variables, the new empirical evidence found in this paper clearly supports the agency and investor divergence of opinion hypotheses, but not for the information asymmetry hypothesis.
Stock Price Manipulation: Corporate Actions and the Exploitation of Retail Investors in China

Sheridan Titman,Chishen Wei,Bin Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3569429

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Using account level data from the Shanghai Stock Exchange, we find widespread evidence consistent with insiders manipulating share prices to exploit naïve retail investors. We identify a group of “suspicious” firms that use stock splits—perhaps, along with other misleading activities—to artificially inflate their share prices. Retail investors are strongly attracted to these suspicious splits, providing insiders an opportunity to sell large blocks of shares or use their shares as collateral for loans. A group of large accounts exploits the positive feedback trading behavior of naïve retail investors by accumulating positions before suspicious split announcements and selling in the post-split period.
Anatomy of Aborted Stock Repurchases

Hamid Rahman,Qian Sun,Kenneth Yung

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2134206

2012-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:The motivation and characteristics of firms that announce stock repurchase programs but do not carry them out are poorly understood. We conjecture that the long-term earnings quality of such firms is low, which makes them poor candidates for subsequent stock purchase. Their announcement is just a bluff, possibly to get a short-term bounce in their stock price. We find evidence of poor long-term earnings quality in these firms in the pre-purchase period with further deterioration in the post-purchase period. A probit model confirms that poor long-term quality of accruals, a proxy for earnings quality, increases the chance of not carrying through on the repurchase announcement. We find a significant relationship between long-term earnings quality and subsequent performance for firms that carry through on their purchase plans but no such evidence for firms that do not.

Repurchases for Price Impact: Evidence from Fragile Stocks

Sources of the Stock Price Fluctuations in Chinese Equity Market

The Credibility of Stock Repurchase Signals

Do Share Repurchases Distort Stock Prices? Evidence from the United States and Malaysia

A comprehensive examination of the wealth effects of recent stock repurchase announcements

The Impact of Investor Heterogeneity in Beliefs on Share Repurchase

Earnings Management in Response to Stock Price Pressure: Evidence from Fire Sales (and Purchases) by Mutual Funds

Price Elasticity for Stocks: Evidence from China's Split-Share Structure Reform

Asset Price, Risk Transfer and Economic Activities: Firm-level Evidence from China

Price ceilings, market structure, and payout policies

Quantitative earnings enhancement from share buybacks

Open Market Share Repurchases and Earnings Management

Real Effects of Share Repurchases Legalization on Corporate Behaviors

Reference Price Distributions and Stock Returns: an Analysis Based on the Disposition Effect

Bond Price Fragility and the Structure of the Mutual Fund Industry

Corporate responses to stock price fragility

Do Share Repurchases Facilitate Movement Toward Target Capital Structure? International Evidence

Corporate Actions and the Manipulation of Retail Investors in China: An Analysis of Stock Splits

Why do Firms Repurchase Shares? Evidence from Actual Share Repurchases

Stock Price Manipulation: Corporate Actions and the Exploitation of Retail Investors in China

Anatomy of Aborted Stock Repurchases