Abstract:On-demand service platforms are interested in having gig workers use self-set, nonbinding performance goals to improve efforts and performance. To examine the effects of such self-set goal mechanisms, we build a behavioral model, derive theoretical results and testable hypotheses, and conduct a field experiment using a large gig platform for food delivery. Our model analysis finds that individual workers’ optimal self-set goals may exhibit a spectrum of difficulty levels, ranging from trivial to impossible, depending on workers’ reference-dependent utility coefficients and self-control cost. Moreover, workers’ efforts are higher with properly set goals rather than no-goals. Consistently, our experimental data show significant treatment effects of self-goal setting, and a causal tree algorithm identifies subgroups who are mostly motivated by self-set goals. Furthermore, our study compares two common types of performance metrics for goal setting: the number of completed orders and total revenue. Our model suggests different cases of effort and performance improvement for the two goal types. The experimental data suggests that both goal types improve efforts equally but lead to different attainment rates. Specifically, the goal attainment rate is lower for the revenue-goal treatment than for the order-quantity-goal treatment. Further analysis reveals that this disparity is due to workers setting excessively high revenue goals. Our study demonstrates the efficacy and limitations of self-goal-setting mechanisms and yields two important managerial implications. First, the implementation of self-goal-setting mechanisms could improve gig workers’ efforts and performance. Second, encouraging order-quantity goals instead of revenue goals could help gig workers achieve higher attainment rates.

Investigating the effect of self-leadership on thriving at work among gig workers: a moderated dual path model

Navigating autonomy: unraveling the dual influence of job autonomy on workplace well-being in the gig economy

Driven to succeed, or to leave? The variable impact of self-leadership in rideshare gig work

Authentic Leadership and Taking Charge Behavior: A Moderated Mediation Model of Psychological Capital and Occupational Calling

Impact of self-leadership on employee voice behavior: a moderated mediating model

How Algorithmic Management Influences Gig Workers’ Job Crafting

ETHICAL LEADERSHIP AND EMPLOYEE VOICE: EMPLOYEE SELF-EFFICACY AND SELF-IMPACT AS MEDIATORS.

Challenge or Hindrance? The Dual Impact of Algorithmic Control on Gig Workers' Prosocial Service Behaviors

Set a Goal for Yourself? A Model and Field Experiment with Gig Workers

Are algorithmically controlled gig workers deeply burned out? An empirical study on employee work engagement

The Effects of Self-sacrificial Leadership on Thriving at Work: The Mediating Role of Perceived Interpersonal Justice and the Moderating Role of Perceived Corporate Social Responsibility

When and Why Leaders’ Helping Behavior Promotes Employees’ Thriving: Exploring the Role of Voice Behavior and Perceived Leader’s Role Overload

The dual effect of gamification on customer-oriented organizational citizenship behavior in gig economy: a study of the mechanisms and moderators

Exploring the Effectiveness of Self-and Other-Focused Happiness: The Moderating Role of Job Resources

Perceived Empowering Leadership, Harmonious Passion, and Employee Voice: The Moderating Role of Job Autonomy

Gig Work Self-Efficacy and Its Effects on Flexibility, Career Adoptability, and Adoption in the Metaverse: A Moderated Mediation Model

The impact of leaders' self-serving and ethical behaviors on employee thriving: The mediating role of interpersonal justice perception

Gig worker’s perceived algorithmic management, stress appraisal, and destructive deviant behavior

Effect of empowering leadership on employees' workplace loneliness: a moderated mediation model

Aspiring to Be an Entrepreneur While on Paid Employment: A Moderated Mediation Model of Entrepreneur Identity Aspiration

Effect of Gig Workers’ Psychological Contract Fulfillment on Their Task Performance in a Sharing Economy—A Perspective from the Mediation of Organizational Identification and the Moderation of Length of Service