Abstract:Carboxylic acids can be isolated from fermentation broths using reactive liquid-liquid extraction, offering an alternative to the environmentally harmful state-of-the-art process of precipitating calcium lactate. To enhance the sustainability of liquid-liquid extraction processes, greener solvents, such as natural deep eutectic solvents, are investigated. However, fermentation broths often exhibit pH values unsuitable for carboxylic acid extraction, which can be adjusted using mineral acids, though mineral acids may be co-extracted. In this study, we systematically examine the co-extraction of hydrochloric, nitric, sulfuric, and phosphoric acid during extraction and back-extraction of lactic acid. The solvent phase consisted of tri-n-octylamine, trioctylphosphine oxide, or tributyl phosphate diluted in a thymol-menthol deep eutectic solvent. The back-extraction was conducted using a diluent swing with p-cymene as the antisolvent and water as the receiving phase. Tri-n-octylamine showed the highest efficiency for lactic acid (up to 29.8%) but also the highest co-extraction of mineral acids (up to 50.9%). In contrast, trioctylphosphine oxide exhibited a lower but more selective lactic acid extraction (5.94%) with low mineral acids co-extraction (0.135%). Overall, the highest co-extraction was observed for phosphoric acid and the lowest for nitric acid. In conclusion, the selected solvent phase composition and mineral acid influence the co-extraction and, thus, final product purity. The successful application of the natural deep eutectic solvent as the modifier enhances the sustainability of liquid–liquid extraction processes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the co - extraction phenomenon of mineral acids in the process of lactic acid reactive extraction using natural deep eutectic solvents (NADES). Specifically, the research aims to:
1. **Improve the sustainability of the lactic acid extraction process**: By using natural deep eutectic solvents (such as thymol - menthol - based NADES) as green modifiers to replace traditional fossil - based solvents, thereby reducing environmental harm.
2. **Evaluate the impact of co - extraction of mineral acids**: Study the co - extraction behaviors of different mineral acids (such as hydrochloric acid, nitric acid, sulfuric acid, and phosphoric acid) in the lactic acid extraction and back - extraction processes to understand their influence on the purity of the final product.
3. **Optimize the selection of extractants**: Compare the performances of different extractants (such as tri - n - octylamine, tri - octylphosphine oxide, and tributyl phosphate) in different solvent systems, and find the optimal combination to achieve efficient lactic acid extraction and minimize the co - extraction of mineral acids.
### Research Background
Lactic acid (LA) is an important bio - based chemical, which is widely used in chemical, food, cosmetic and other fields. Traditional lactic acid separation methods (such as calcium lactate precipitation method) have problems such as high chemical requirements and large amounts of gypsum waste residue production, so more environmentally - friendly alternative methods need to be developed. Liquid - liquid reactive extraction (LLE) as a potential alternative method can effectively separate lactic acid, but the problem of co - extraction of mineral acids in its application urgently needs to be solved.
### Research Methods
1. **Physical extraction experiments**: The physical extraction behaviors of single - mineral - acid model solutions in different solvents (such as 1 - octanol, tmDES and limonene) were studied.
2. **Reactive extraction experiments**: Different extractants (TOA, TOPO, TBP) diluted in 1 - octanol, tmDES or limonene were used to carry out reactive extraction on single - mineral - acid model solutions, and the distribution coefficients of mineral acids were analyzed.
3. **Multi - acid model solution experiments**: The extraction behaviors of model solutions containing multiple mineral acids in different solvent systems were investigated, and the extraction selectivity and efficiency when mineral acids co - exist were evaluated.
### Main Findings
1. **Extractant selectivity**: Tertiary amine extractants (such as TOA) show a relatively high extraction ability for strong mineral acids (such as hydrochloric acid and nitric acid), while phosphorus - based extractants (such as TOPO and TBP) have a lower extraction ability for mineral acids.
2. **Mineral acid co - extraction**: The co - extraction of mineral acids by TOA diluted in 1 - octanol is the most significant, while the co - extraction degrees in tmDES and limonene are lower. In particular, the co - extraction of phosphoric acid is the highest, and that of nitric acid is the lowest.
3. **Lactic acid extraction efficiency**: In the presence of mineral acids, TOA diluted in 1 - octanol has the highest lactic acid extraction efficiency, but the co - extraction of mineral acids is also the most obvious. In contrast, TOPO and TBP perform more stably in tmDES, and the co - extraction of mineral acids is less.
### Conclusion
This research shows that choosing appropriate extractants and solvent systems is crucial for improving lactic acid extraction efficiency and reducing the co - extraction of mineral acids. Using natural deep eutectic solvents as green modifiers not only improves the sustainability of the process, but also provides new ideas for developing more environmentally - friendly lactic acid separation technologies.