Exploring the Heterogeneous Impact of Trade Agreements on Trade: Depth Matters

Carmen Díaz-Mora,Silviano Esteve-Pérez,Salvador Gil-Pareja
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/econ-2022-0064
2024-01-01
ECONOMICS
Abstract:Abstract One of the most relevant features in the context of international trade in recent decades is the increase in the depth of trade agreements. The aim of this article is to explore the heterogeneous effect of preferential trade agreements (PTAs) on bilateral trade flows including their depth in addition to other agreement characteristics such as the geographical scope of the member countries, their degree of development, or their nature. To measure depth, we follow the most recent works that propose indirect instead of direct measures. Once we control for depth, our results reveal that (i) the positive effect of regional PTAs is notably larger for deep agreements whereas the shallow interregional agreements do not seem to increase bilateral trade flows; (ii) North–North PTAs only boost trade when they exhibit a high depth level; and (iii) the depth is not a relevant factor for plurilateral agreements and those that consist of the adhesion of a country to an existent PTA.
economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to explore the heterogeneous effects of trade agreements of different depths on bilateral trade flows. Specifically, the author seeks to address this issue by examining the following aspects: 1. **Regional Trade Agreements (Regional PTAs)**: Deep regional trade agreements have a significantly greater impact on bilateral trade flows than shallow regional trade agreements; shallow cross-regional trade agreements do not seem to increase bilateral trade flows. 2. **Trade Agreements between Developed Countries (North–North PTAs)**: These agreements only promote trade growth when they are of high depth. 3. **Plurilateral Agreements and Accession to Existing Trade Agreements**: Depth is not a determining factor. Through the above analysis, the paper attempts to reveal the different impacts of trade agreement depth on bilateral trade flows for different types of trade agreements (such as geographical scope, the development level of member countries, and their nature). Additionally, by introducing new indirect measurement methods to gauge the depth of agreements, the paper aims to obtain more accurate results.