Climate, Technology and Value: Insights from the First Decade with Mass-Consumption of Electric Vehicles

Gøril L. Andreassen,Jo Thori Lind
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10640-024-00872-z
2024-05-30
Environmental and Resource Economics
Abstract:Adoption of low-carbon technology is key to mitigating climate change. A possible unwanted consequence of fast technological progress is that products get outdated before their technical lifetime is over. We investigate whether the market value of electric vehicles, characterized by rapid technological progress, declines faster over their lifetime than gasoline vehicles, which represent a mature technology. We use novel data from Norway, the market with the highest market shares for electric vehicles in the world. The data are from the largest web platform for secondhand vehicles over the period 2011–2021. Prices of electric vehicles decline faster than gasoline vehicles. This seems to be driven by the electric vehicles with below median driving range. We hypothesize that the large price drop is mainly due to the fast technological improvement of electric vehicles.
economics,environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper explores the issue of market value changes for low-emission technologies (such as electric vehicles) in the context of rapid technological advancement. Specifically, the authors investigate whether there is a difference in the rate of market price decline over the lifecycle of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline cars and analyze the reasons for this difference. #### Research Background - **Importance of Low-Emission Technologies**: The widespread deployment and continuous improvement of low-emission technologies are crucial for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. - **Impact of Technological Progress**: Rapid technological progress may cause products to become obsolete before the end of their technical lifespan, thereby affecting their market value. #### Research Objectives - **Compare Price Paths**: By comparing the price paths of electric vehicles and gasoline cars in the second-hand market in Norway, the study examines the impact of technological progress on vehicle market value. - **Analyze Reasons**: Investigate why the price decline of electric vehicles might be faster than that of gasoline cars, particularly focusing on electric vehicles with lower mileage. #### Main Findings - **Rate of Price Decline**: The market price of electric vehicles declines faster than that of gasoline cars. - **Reason Analysis**: This price decline is mainly driven by electric vehicles with mileage below the median, possibly due to the rapid technological progress making older models quickly obsolete. #### Theoretical Framework - **Market Model for Durable Goods**: Based on the model by Stolyarov (2002), the study examines how technological progress affects the supply-demand balance and prices in the second-hand car market. - **Impact of Technological Progress**: Technological progress increases the performance and cost advantages of new electric vehicles, thereby reducing the market demand for older electric vehicles, increasing supply, and ultimately leading to price declines. #### Data Source - **Norwegian Market Data**: The study uses data from Norway's largest second-hand car trading platform, finn.no, covering the period from 2011 to 2021 and approximately 90% of the second-hand car market. #### Conclusion - **Impact of Technological Progress on Market Value**: Rapid technological progress leads to a faster decline in the market price of electric vehicles compared to gasoline cars, especially for electric vehicles with lower mileage. - **Policy Implications**: This finding is significant for assessing the costs of climate policies, as the rapid advancement of low-emission technologies may affect their residual value and, consequently, the overall cost of ownership. In summary, through empirical research and theoretical analysis, this paper reveals the impact of rapid technological progress on the market value of electric vehicles, providing valuable insights for future policy-making.